6 ms·
I don't understand why we even need to discuss the usefulness of Bitcoin beyond the fact that it's decentralized. Its decentralized nature, alone, is its most i
by chatmasta 12y ago
I don't understand why we even need to discuss the usefulness of Bitcoin beyond the fact that it's decentralized. Its decentralized nature, alone, is its most important attribute. Bitcoin cannot be stopped. Period.
As long as multiple people can run a program on a set of computers that can connect to each other, Bitcoin can exist. If you want to receive it anonymously, you can perform services anonymously and take payment in Bitcoin. After that, yes your transactions are on the blockchain, but if nobody knows you provided the services to receive the original Bitcoin, then they cannot trace your subsequent transactions back to you without relying on outside variables.
Yes, the regulatory environment and legal status of Bitcoin will affect its adoption as a mainstream currency. If large online merchants begin accepting it, and the price stabilizes to encourage spending, we will naturally see Bitcoin emerge as a useful payment platform. However, neither regulation nor legal status has any impact on the resiliency of the Bitcoin network. Bitcoin is decentralized and mathematical. It cannot be stopped or regulated with any real promise of enforcement.
Bitcoin, by its very nature, is here to stay. Either we can adopt it into the mainstream and build tooling around it to make criminal activity inadvisable, or we can regulate it, discourage innovation, and let the criminals take over the network. Either way, the network remains. Bitcoin is decentralized! It only requires software and network connections.
- random28345 12y ago> Its decentralized nature, alone, is its most important attribute. Bitcoin cannot be stopped. Period. It's just as decentralized as tulip bulbs (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tulip_mania http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tulip_mania), and Bitcoin will be "stopped" when a) it is illegal to transmit or receive a blockchain (unlikely), or b) when people realize the only value Bitcoin has is in the belief that Bitcoin has value. All it takes for Bitcoin to be worthless is the belief that Bitcoin is worthless. Therefore, if you hold any Bitcoin, you are incentivized to be a Bitcoin evangelist. Bitcoin isn't a currency, it's a religion; you need to create "converts" to make your investment of time and belief worthwhile.
- pavel_lishin 12y ago> All it takes for Bitcoin to be worthless is the belief that Bitcoin is worthless. Isn't this true for every currency that isn't literally a physically scarce and useful resource (gold, grain, uranium, gold-pressed latinum?)
- kpommerenke 12y agoNo, it's not necessarily true for a currency backed by a state, since the state can force you to pay taxes in that currency, thus creating demand for the currency and underpinning its value.
- chias 12y agoTell that to Zimbabwe, who still doesn't have a national currency because of exactly this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyperinflation_in_Zimbabwe http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyperinflation_in_Zimbabwe
- dragonwriter 12y agoIts also true for every currency that is a physically scarce and useful resource, though being such a resource (or, alternatively, being designated legal tender and demanded for tax and other payments by a large and significant government) substantially reduces the probability that belief that the currency is worthless will become widespread.
- chias 12y ago> when people realize the only value Bitcoin has is in the belief that Bitcoin has value For the record, people said the same thing about paper currency. And again when paper currency stopped being backed by gold. And this periodically actually happens to real government-backed currencies in the world, especially during times of hyperinflation (e.g. Germany in the 1920s, Zimbabwe in 2008, etc)
- random28345 12y ago> And this periodically actually happens to real government-backed currencies in the world, especially during times of hyperinflation Right, but that happens sometimes, and never with proper governance. (but what is "proper governance" you ask? It's a tautology that says that governments that never allow hyperinflation never suffer from hyperinflation) ALL asset bubbles collapse. The magnitude of the collapse is determined by the non-monetary value of the asset. (e.g. tulip bulbs collapse harder than real-estate). Because the non-monetary value of Bitcoin is negative (you need to burn electricity to use Bitcoin), this implies the eventual collapse of Bitcoin will be absolute.