5 ms·
Not a bad introduction. I spent years working on GNU make stuff (including a complete emulation) at Electric Cloud and wrote an "Ask Mr Make" column. Everything
by jgrahamc 12y ago
Not a bad introduction. I spent years working on GNU make stuff (including a complete emulation) at Electric Cloud and wrote an "Ask Mr Make" column. Everything I wrote about GNU make can be found here: http://blog.jgc.org/2013/02/updated-list-of-my-gnu-make-articles.html http://blog.jgc.org/2013/02/updated-list-of-my-gnu-make-arti...
[blatant advertising] And also I have a new book on GNU make coming out this month: http://www.nostarch.com/gnumake http://www.nostarch.com/gnumake if you really want to get into make deeply.
- EliRivers 12y agoI have a (signed and with some nice cloudflare stickers, thank you very much) copy of your previous GNU Make book. How much better is this one? (Disclaimer; Mr GC is totally not paying me to ask this)
- jgrahamc 12y agoThe previous book was self-published, self-edited, etc. This is a properly edited and updated version of that book. Covers up to GNU make 4.0. If you are one of the few who bought the old one then it might not be worth buying the new one. But this book does have exactly 2^8 pages :-)
- angersock 12y ago...do we have to get into make deeply? ;) Like, can't we just get into a little make, and call it square?
- jackmaney 12y agoGNU make is one of the (many) things that I've meant to get a grasp on. I picked up an electronic copy of the book. Very nice! It's a lot more example-driven than the GNU Make Manual.
- teddyh 12y agoIf anyone wants to get into GNU Make deeply, one would think that the obvious thing to do would be to read the official manual for GNU Make. Anyone who writes their own, not freely available, manual to a free software program, is dividing the world into two halves: Those readers who can afford this new book, and will pay the author (not the writers of the software, mind you) for a nice manual, and those readers who can’t afford to pay for this new manual, and will have to do with the inferior¹ official manual. Those readers who can afford the new manual will not be incentivised to improve the official manual, since they have the new, better, one. Therefore, this act (of creating new manuals which are not freely available) is reducing the number of readers who can be expected to help improve the official manual to those readers who cannot afford the new manual. These effects, i.e. reduced funding and reduced help to the original software authors, is not, to me, worth it to have a new, even if better, manual. ① Presumably, by their own standards, since they wrote a replacement manual.
- rando3826 12y agoAgree, except that the underpinning is about about the freedom to improve and share, which generally means there's a freely available version on the internet, but by no means means you can't or shouldn't buy electronic or paper copies for money to support the author. ie. the gnu make manual: http://shop.fsf.org/product/gnu-make-version-381/ http://shop.fsf.org/product/gnu-make-version-381/
- ssalazar 12y agoThe entitlement of your post is out of control, and you're making a lot of assumptions in what is really just a knee-jerk reaction to someone, somewhere making money. > If anyone wants to get into GNU Make deeply, one would think that the obvious thing to do would be to read the official manual for GNU Make. There is a lot of room for both "user guide" type publications in addition to the official manual. In particular the former may be useful to individuals who have had difficulty learning how to use make from other resources. Are you saying that all of the "Learning Basic Linux" books should be pulled since people can just read the Linux manuals? > and will pay the author [of the manual] (not the writers of the software, mind you) for a nice manual You act as if writing a manual is somehow a less valuable act than writing the software, when in fact high-quality documentation is sorely lacking in almost all parts of the free software world. I doubt you have ever written, edited, and had published a book before, because even for something as "simple" as a guide to a software tool, it is an intense, laborious process that involves lots of research and fact-checking in addition to the actual writing and editing. Its incredibly entitled to suggest that all of this effort should not be compensated at the author's discretion. > Those readers who can afford the new manual will not be incentivised to improve the official manual, since they have the new, better, one. They were never incentivized to improve the official manual in the first place. > reduced funding and reduced help to the original software authors There was no expectation of funding to the original software authors in the first place, and to imply that they deserve the money for what would be spent on this book, a separate creative work, is disingenuous.
- teddyh 12y ago> They were never incentivized to improve the official manual in the first place. On the contrary, if they had read the official manual, they would have had the incentive to improve it. Just like with software. > There was no expectation of funding to the original software authors in the first place Yes there is, if the original software authors are (like in the case of GNU Make) also selling the official manual in book form.