12 ms·
We Should Have a Better Condom by Now
- bookwormAT 12y agotl;dr?
- mjhoy 12y agoThe second parenthetical of this sentence sums it up, I'd say. > He learned how latex condoms are made (by dipping phallic molds into vats of liquid latex, which is peeled off after it dries), and how they are regulated (the Food and Drug Administration considers condoms medical devices and dictates how they are manufactured and labeled). edit: Main points seem to be that the FDA - encourages latex, through labeling and testing requirements - limits the range of sizes of condoms - tests only vaginal intercourse, there can be no anal-sex specific condoms
- eru 12y agoCouldn't Americans import a wider variety from less stuck-up countries?
- dpark 12y agoProbably not. The FDA controls all drugs and medical devices sold in the US, not just manufactured here.
- nly 12y agoTheyfit have the same problem and provider a partner forwarding service[0]. Presumably there are other services like this. [0] http://www.theyfit.co.uk/pages/ordering-from-outside-of-europe http://www.theyfit.co.uk/pages/ordering-from-outside-of-euro...
- pariya 12y agoWhat ARE the best condoms in the world? Does anyone know of a country with more superior condoms?
- eru 12y agoI am not sure about best, but special needs can require special items, without any notion of superiority or inferiority in the general case.
- alanctgardner3 12y agoOkamoto (based in Japan) makes some good ones that can legally be sold in the US. http://www.okamotousa.com/ http://www.okamotousa.com/
- danso 12y agoThere's actually a lot of interesting facts about the origin/manufacturing of condoms and of the regulatory process/history. I submitted the article because I thought the lead anecdote of the man taking it upon himself to improve it was interesting and inspiring, as it's so often the case that we just tolerate everyday things that could be better...but condoms are an everyday thing tied so closely to love/intimacy as well as having a critical impact on health.
- tjradcliffe 12y agoThe most interesting thing is also depressing: there was a fairly well-known researcher at the University of Manitoba who was working on designing a better condom in the early 1990's, and there is still work going on there today: http://news.nationalpost.com/news/condoms-treated-with-silver-nanoparticles-could-completely-inactivate-hiv-other-stds-researchers http://news.nationalpost.com/news/condoms-treated-with-silve... The work I recall from the '90's (I was a post-doc there, working in a different field) involved changes to both shape and design, with some kind of extra band around the base to prevent leakage and accidental slip-off. As near as I can tell, none of this research has had any impact on condoms as they are manufactured and sold. The best you see is a non-latex condom being sold now and then, but they never seem to stay on the market very long (they are generally more expensive). So the most pressing topic for research would seem to be going after the question, "We know all kinds of things about building a better condom, and have for decades, so why haven't the condoms we buy changed appreciably?" Some of this will be due to the difficulties of getting things past the FDA, particularly for smaller operations as the article suggests, but since we do see non-latex condoms from major manufacturers (http://www.walgreens.com/q/non-latex-condoms http://www.walgreens.com/q/non-latex-condoms) it is clearly not the case that the FDA makes stuff impossible. It may be there are economic issues at work as well, but I don't think the situation is so obvious that we can just apply $IDEOLOGY_OF_YOUR_CHOICE and say we're done. This is particularly true because condom availability isn't great outside the US, either (although what the US approves does have an influence on what gets sold elsewhere, I'm sure.)
- portmantoad 12y agothat walgreens page is 100% polyisoprene (the latex derived kind from the article) or mis-categorized latex.
- mkr-hn 12y agoI'd probably worry less about this if PrEP were cheap enough to get without insurance (or wealth). The odds of finding a monogomous (or at least polyfidelitous) partner around here is slim, and I'm not too keen on taking my chances with Grindr. A better condom would alleviate a lot of worries.
- foobarqux 12y agoDoesn't PrEP have serious side-effects?
- mkr-hn 12y agoCurrently. I'm sure things will improve as existing drugs are improved and new ones are invented.
- peter303 12y agoAbout $15,000 a year for someone to pay. Insurance companies resist expensive drugs not used to treat an existing disease. Seems to be readily available under medicaid. But you have to keep you income under $15K or ($10K in non-Obamacare states) to qualify.
- gboss 12y agoThat's actually not true. Insurance companies, such as Kaiser Permanente, see a few years of PrEP during a patients active sexual years favorable to treating HIV for life. I have a few friends that are on Prep and have private insurance and have not had any difficulty acquiring the prescription.
- megaframe 12y agoSome yes. Kidney failure in a small set of patients. Typically urine/blood samples are taken for the first few months to check for this. There's some evidence of bone degradation in long term use (think 10+ years) but its mitigated with regular strength exercises. Beyond that not much else the formula has been altered a few times to make it pretty safe to take regularly. Some people experience gastrointestinal distress from it but that usually passes after a month. If it doesn't they usually just stop taking it. All of the side effects stop if you stop taking it.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- jbhatab 12y agoI could only imagine the positive impact a noticeable increase in condom usage would bring to the world. I feel like it would be a silent yet very beneficial change if condom usage went up about 10% globally.
- alexashka 12y agoLet's start with making them free. Are the medical/abortion costs really lower than providing everyone with unlimited plastic with a little lotion on it?
- jessaustin 12y agoSome condoms should be free. But since the point of TFA is that innovation is slow, it seems good for better condoms (as judged by consumers) to cost more. That way condom manufacturers have an incentive to make better condoms.
- jpgauthier 12y agoI'm from Québec (Canada) and you can easily find free condoms at your Local Community Services Centre or any anti-aids/healthcare organization. But, I'm not exactly sure that it helped to reduce AIDS transmission or the number of abortions (if we look at the numbers they have increased in past years), but there's a lot more to take into account than condoms usage alone. Still, I completely agree with you that it should be free. I'm curious, are we alone in this world to give free condoms or it's a common practice?
- retardedelk 12y agoYou can get free condoms just about everywhere (including the United States). The problem is that you get them free from your local family-planning clinic, or community centre, etc. People who are at risk for having unprotected sex probably need the condoms to be easily available (i.e free in high-schools, free in bars/nightclubs, etc.). If they have enough forethought in order to make a trip to one of the places where they are free, they probably have enough forethought to buy them themselves without problems.
- wdewind 12y agoYeesh what an overwritten article. I plowed through it because this is relevant to my interests but man this could've been 3 paragraphs. I'll try and sum it up: -People don't use condoms mostly because they are uncomfortable -Current condoms are highly suboptimal for anal sex in particular -Materials other than latex are generally difficult to get to pass FDA tests, and it looks like there is some disagreeing science about why. All condoms seem to be good at blocking pregnancy, some, like polyurethane and lambskin condoms, have disagreeing science about how well they stop the transmission of STDs (including HIV). -New condoms sometimes get blocked because of somewhat antiquated tests (specifically sizing tests) Overall there was not a lot of information here. It follows someone named Resnic, loosely, who claims to be making a new revolutionary condom, but who ultimately decides to change his condom back to latex because it's so much easier to manufacture in the US. It's not clear what his key innovations are that will make his condom more useful/comfortable to more people. Overall the point that a better condom would get more people to use it makes sense, but the article doesn't make the case that one is on the way, or explain what one even would be. Yes, a better material might transmit heat better, but there are obvious downsides, especially with regards to Africa, where STD transmission is the primary concern, not pregnancy. If there is one conclusion I take from this article it's that if you are in a committed relationship where you are not worried about STD transmission and are primarily concerned about pregnancy prevention, and do not like latex condoms, give lamb skin or polyurethane condoms a shot. Otherwise you're probably best sticking to latex.
- mbroshi 12y agoOr, to sum up even more succinctly: - Government regulations have stifled innovation, thereby making existing products less safe, less comfortable, and less used than they would be otherwise. In other words, nothing new.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- jfuhrman 12y agoThat doesn't explain why the innovation didn't happen in, say Somalia, where there are no government regulations to speak of.
- up_and_up 12y agoI recommend this company: https://thisisl.com/ https://thisisl.com/ You buy one, they give one away model. They also use less toxic ingredients in general.
- jseliger 12y agoThanks for this link. These look great, and I've never heard of them.
- ars 12y agoAn article on ebola said that the condom provides 95% protection per use. i.e. a 5% chance of infection anyway each time they are used. That's basically worthless because after 13 uses there is a 50/50 chance of infecting someone. They are more effective with HIV only because HIV is not as infective, not because the condom is more effective. So the problem with the condom is not the design, but that they are not as effective as people think. Couples using them consistently every time still have a good lifetime chance of transmitting HIV if their partner is infected.
- sz4kerto 12y ago"That's basically worthless because after 13 uses there is a 50/50 chance of infecting someone." Well, there's 50/50 chance of not infecting anybody vs infecting at least one person from 13. That's a much better chance than say 50% chance of infecting at least 10 person from 13. When you are thinking about spreading a disease, this matters a lot. Sure, for couples, the chances of infection after N use is high, but that's not the only use case. (E.g. one night stands.)
- ars 12y agoYou are forgetting that people change behavior based on risk. Telling someone there is a tool to reduce risk, that doesn't actually reduce risk (enough), actually makes things much much worse.
- sz4kerto 12y agoYes, they do change, you're right. However, if it comes to sex, people do not care that much about risks. Condom usage decreases the prevalence and spread of STDs. That is a very hard fact. Therefore I guess that in this specific case increased risk taking does not offset the advantages of decreased risk. (Same seems to be true for things like airbags or seat belts in cars. You could not possibly argue that we should remove these from cars because we end up with more fatalities with them as it is simply not the case.)
- deleted 12y ago
- larrys 12y agoHighly recommended: "Female Condoms" http://www.plannedparenthood.org/learn/birth-control/female-condom http://www.plannedparenthood.org/learn/birth-control/female-... Don't want to get into a bunch of inappropriate talk but suffice to say much better for both parties.
- hackuser 12y ago> Don't want to get into a bunch of inappropriate talk but suffice to say much better for both parties. I'd encourage you to talk. The more people know about it, the more they will use effective contraception and the fewer HIV (and other STD) infections there will be. And people who read it from you will tell others. We're all adults here; I don't think it's inappropriate.
- ams6110 12y agoWe're all adults here Almost certainly not true.
- larrys 12y agoFrom my experience there is no comparison to the feeling and sensitivity experienced when using this. Almost feels like nothing is there (or close to it). Women don't seem to mind using it either (and it is actually marketed or was marketed at one point as women taking control). All in all to me no comparison to a traditional condom for men. Edit: And after using it it's hard for me to understand why it's not more widely known. [2] The only drawback is the cost, about $2 each at retail. [1] In theory it can be re-used as well since it's not stretchy but simply a large sheath like protection. [1] Planned parenthood gives them and and sells them. If you are nice to them they will give you a bunch at no cost for a small donation. (Call it $5). [2] My guess is that it lacks the marketing budget to take off. The local pharmacy used to carry them but then stopped for lack of demand which mystifies me given my personal experience. Not a new product by the way has been around for quite some time but as I said primarily distributed by PP and to women, not men.
- Hytosys 12y ago>We're all adults here And even if we aren't, kids have sex too!
- graeme 12y agoOrthogonal to the article: condoms are not one size fit all. A lot of people think they are, and this causes problems. Too small, and condoms break. Too large, and they slip off. Either way feels far less comfortable than with a properly fitting condom. This ultimately leads to less usage. Condom boxes have something called "nominal width" on the side. To fit properly, you or your partner need to take a precise measure of the penis circumference, then match that to the appropriate width: http://www.condom-sizes.org/condom-sizes/suggested-condom-width-in-relation-to-penis-circumference http://www.condom-sizes.org/condom-sizes/suggested-condom-wi... Note that you have to double check the comdoms. For instance, magnums list 58mm, but actually are 54mm at the base, which is the most important place. Fitted properly, latex condoms will feel significantly better and work better.
- rpenm 12y agoNot orthogonal: the article discusses the role of size in breakage and comfort. It also discusses how the FDA forced TheyFit to discontinue their custom-fit condoms due to unreasonable ASTM testing requirements.
- graeme 12y agoOops, my mistake. I read about halfway through the article, and didn't reach that part. Leaving the comment as is as I expect it may help some people get better condoms.
- ta_994855 12y agoIn spite of their niche popularity [...] the FDA challenged the acceptability of TheyFit condoms [...] having noticed [...] that some of the sizes did not meet ASTM dimensional requirements. The smaller sizes, in particular, didn’t hold the requisite volume of air and water in the air-burst test and the water-leak test, because they were, well, smaller. Glickman [...] was given 30 days to remove his condom from the market, and, after consulting with an attorney, complied. Wow. So they were forced to take these off the market because they didn't conform to a completely irrelevant FDA standard....
- 12y ago
- mattpavelle 12y agoA while back (2013?), the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation offered financing for a "next generation" condom. I can't find the link on the Gates Foundation site now (dead links on Google) but this is some press around it and mentions the 11 finalists: http://theweek.com/articles/455793/meet-11-condoms-future-selected-by-bill-gates http://theweek.com/articles/455793/meet-11-condoms-future-se... So I guess better condoms are in the works already?
- zethraeus 12y agothe article follows one of the funded parties
- peterwwillis 12y agoI've always wondered why you can't dip a penis into liquid latex or a similar compound. Perfect fit, won't slip off (presumably?), probably harder to break. Getting it off without lots of screaming might be tricky...
- lotsofmangos 12y agoI wondered if a temporary glue could fix a thin flexible tube in the urethra, containing a carefully folded sealed bag. Full sensitivity, no cum.
- yzh 12y agoJust love the pictures.
- spiralpolitik 12y agoI would also add that the reason that nobody has developed a better condom is that there is no profit in doing so. At a minimum you are looking at a couple of million in research, more if you want to go crazy with material science. Then you have the cost of testing, approval etc. After that you have marketing. It's a great project that will save many lives but the cost/risk analysis alone would put off any for profit organization. The fact that the Gates Foundation is having to get involved is a sign that the market simply isn't going to solve this one. (Government research probably won't deliver it either, at least in the US, due to the politics around contraception)
- UweSchmidt 12y agoThe "no profit" statement made me curious. First link I found http://www.companiesandmarkets.com/MarketInsight/Consumer-Goods/Global-Condom-Industry/NI8052 http://www.companiesandmarkets.com/MarketInsight/Consumer-Go... claims that "The global condom industry has been forecast to hit a market value of US$5.4 billion by 2018". If you have the material science worked out you're mass producing a few grams of latex, selling to non-price sensitive customers, and can even market it as an "entertainment product" as the article states.
- sebular 12y agoWhat a ridiculous and false assertion-- all you've demonstrated is that there are costs of entering the market. That says nothing about the potentially enormous profits to be made if your redesigned condom beats the competition and becomes a new consumer favorite. Condoms are purchased by people in a wide age range, income bracket, geographic location, etc. Even a small percentage of the total market would be an enormous amount of money. You might as well have said that Tesla Motors was a terrible idea, arguing that there's no money to be made in automobiles because of all the upfront costs of designing cars, building factories, and obtaining regulatory permission. In fact, the entire point of starting any business is to overcome upfront costs by seeking long-term profits.
- jaldoretta 12y agoContraceptive innovation is WAY behind other industries. Condoms are completely outdated, the pill really hasn't changed since the 1960s, the IUD since the '70s, the "new" implants are really just a minor evolution of the pill, etc. You'd think such a basic human need would be more of a priority. My startup is helping to tackle this problem by trying to inform people that menstrual cycle data, on its own, can help prevent pregnancy with the same efficacy as hormonal contraception (and this isn't the rhythm method, despite the common misconception). While it doesn't prevent the spread of STIs like condoms, tech that replaces "modern" methods for women could change the industry. We actually just released a marketing campaign for that exact purpose: https://youtube.com/watch?v=3PzfJ4caalY https://youtube.com/watch?v=3PzfJ4caalY I'm really looking forward to the much-needed innovation in this industry.
- jacquesm 12y ago> My startup is helping to tackle this problem by trying to inform people that menstrual cycle data, on its own, can help prevent pregnancy with the same efficacy as hormonal contraception (and this isn't the rhythm method, despite the common misconception). I think you should be very careful with making unqualified statements like that. If it isn't the rhythm method then you should explain exactly what it is because the 'common misconception' requiring you to distance yourself from the rhythm method before someone even brings it up is alive and kicking and it is up to you to provide the evidence that it isn't so by explaining how it does work. Your marketing video certainly does nothing to clarify, and the app description on your website screams 'rhythm method in an app' from every page.
- bsmith 12y agoNoted. If you read our "App" page, you would have seen 'sympto-thermal method of fertility awareness' mentioned at least once. Check out "Learn" for a literal book's worth of information (complete with references) about how this works. We've taken an approach of trying to ease people into this, but maybe that hasn't come across in this instance. How would you suggest we introduce the topic without scaring people off with such scientifically dense-sounding terms as "sympto-thermal method"? Is anything we can say going to be believable to our target customer off the bat?
- wwijs 12y agoMany reasons that hinder condom usage can never be fixed, even with free, plentiful, good feeling condoms: The ability to go from foreplay to sex without stopping The ability to switch between oral and penetrative sex
- bostik 12y agoThis thread practically demands a NSFW link for classic 4-panel comic strip. If you are at work, think at least twice before clicking the following link: [NSFW] http://thinhline.tumblr.com/post/5370750268/thl-7-nothing-i-can-condom-click-on-the http://thinhline.tumblr.com/post/5370750268/thl-7-nothing-i-... The article touches the issue of sensitivity and the need to develop a condom that makes sex more enjoyable. So does the comic at the link above, if in a slightly different way. In case of markets and products, one can rely on cynicism and economics. In case of sex, we should be able to rely on hedonism. (Are there any other SL fans?)
- MichaelGG 12y agoAnti sensitivity condoms seem to be fairly popular, to improve "male performance". Any simple condom or device like in that comic would be a massive success. I don't know the stats but I'd be shocked to find many guys don't rate their partner's pleasure over their own. And yes, SexyLosers is the funniest "adult" comic I've ever read.
- j_lev 12y agoJapan has had polyurethane condoms as standard for at least 15 years (indeed there is the stereotype of foreigners stocking up on latex ones whenever they go home). Polyurethane is definitely superior in many regards, but they are less stretchy than latex and if you're not used to them they can be a little frustrating.
- joeclark77 12y agoWe do. It's called abstinence. Works every time.
- jacob_naked 12y agoHere is a folow-up article that trashes Danny Resnic, the CEO of Origami Condoms. If you want to try out a similar condom that is the best one out there in my opinion, check out nakedcondoms.com
- throwaway76453 12y agoI was kind of shocked that the entire article doesn't mention that Japan has basically solved this problem. They have had 0.03 mm (that's .03 MM, not 3 mm) and more recently 0.02mm polyurethane condoms for quite some time. The only negative to them is that they have to be sold in different size ranges (Normal, Large, probably there's an XL) since they are not very stretchable. Also, being so insanely thin, it takes a fair bit of skill to apply one. They are expensive, but not as expensive as a disease. They feel so close to nothing that someone unwilling to wear one with an unknown partner is shocking to me, yet even in Japan, condom use is extremely low. On a side note, I'm surprised that so many people take their life in their hands to slightly improve the sensory feel of sex, and yet circumcision, which removes a huge percentage of the nerve endings in the area, remains popular in the US.
- devonkim 12y agoAs a user of said Japanese condoms, I still have to admit that I can tell that there's something there. There's nothing that will actually solve the problem that you will want something that feels good. If you ask me, we can get more people to use condoms if we develop a condom that feels even better than not wearing one. If we can combine a sex toy and contraceptive together that works during sex basically, it might be hard to get people to NOT use condoms. Some people swear that fleshlights feel better than actual sex in itself, so who knows if we could develop advanced haptics for condoms or something down the road?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- randywatkins 12y agoThis article seems to ignore cost. I think a pretty fundamental benefit of a simple latex condom is how cheap it is.
- morenoh149 12y agoWhat I'd really like to see is research on a a male version of The Pill. The Pill was introduced in the 1960s. What efforts, research, has been done to bring a similar product for males? Though it wouldn't help on the disease transmission front.
- jacob_naked 12y agoHere it is. Very cool: http://www.newmalecontraception.org/vasalgel/ http://www.newmalecontraception.org/vasalgel/