3 ms·
You don't buy beats for the sound, you buy beats to signal your tribal membership. People go to extraordinary lengths to join groups and send this membership si
by bane 12y ago
You don't buy beats for the sound, you buy beats to signal your tribal membership. People go to extraordinary lengths to join groups and send this membership signal. It's almost instinctual and done without a lot of thinking and good marketers know how to leverage this.
It's dumb, but it is what it is, and people wrap an awful lot of their identity up in their chosen tribe rather than just being themselves.
- sjwright 12y agoI agree it's dumb, but the important thing to realise is that pretty much everyone is falling for it pretty much all the time. It's hard to argue that this same motivation isn't driving sales of iPhones over Android and vice versa. Or Canon versus Nikon. Nike versus Adidas. Harvard versus Stanford. Obama versus (!Obama). Ford versus Toyota. We can rationalise many of these decisions, but so can the people who bought the other thing.
- bane 12y agoWell, like I said. It's basically instinctual. Humans are social animals that form into groups and groups need in-group out-group signaling to define themselves. Joining a group identity like this is basically our animal bits controlling what we do. It's subtle, and people are often surprised when they realize that this is what they're doing. But if you buy into a group identity and you can't rationally explain why, or have to post-rationalize, it's probably this effect. But it's also one of those things that, whenever you see it, is a reminder that humans have a long way to go and aren't as different from the rest of the animals as they'd like to believe. Why Apple purchased beats, is that it helps tie together several different social tribes, with Apple now able to try to cross-sell between them, something very hard to do.
- icebraining 12y agoIf I'm the kind of person who buys expensive stuff to signal my membership, then buying Beats headphones is being myself, no?
- bane 12y agoNo, by definition, group identity replaces and/or subsumes personal identity.
- icebraining 12y agoHow is that personal identity formed, if not by social interaction? I think the dichotomy you refer to is illusory.
- bane 12y agosocial interaction != group membership I think you're confusing the two.
- icebraining 12y agoI don't think the two are dissociable.
- bane 12y agoOf course they are. Even if you belong to a tribe, interacting with anybody outside of your tribe is by definition social interaction. If you've never had a non-inter-group interaction, then I feel terribly sorry for you. For most people, that's the normal mode of interaction.
- icebraining 12y agoI'm guessing you're overly restricting your definition of social group. "Americans" is a group. So are "men" and "women".
- bane 12y agoLet me review what you've said, in case I misinterpreted any of it. I stated the group identity replaces and/or subsumes personal identity. You replied, "How is that personal identity formed, if not by social interaction? I think the dichotomy you refer to is illusory." I believe this indicates that you think all collections of people are "groups" regardless of the way that they formed, the size and any notion of in-group out-group membership status. So I replied "social interaction != group membership" To which you replied "I don't think the two are dissociable" which reinforced my understanding of your previous statement -- that you believe all collections of people, regardless of the size or reason for their formation, are interchangeable. A society = team = club = class = mob = airplane full of people = global population = tribe = clan = family = nation = citizenry = company = group = like-working tradesmen = guild = union = etc. My claim is that this is patently absurd and a remarkably oversimplified model of how the world works, one that's so wrong as to be virtually non-functional. It doesn't provide any workable estimates or cause-effect relationship that apply even trivially across almost any pair of those words. We've decided that these things are so different that we even give them different words, definitions, legal status, philosophies, fields of study, and so on. In fact it's unusual when any of these two words even start to smell like the same thing. For example, a team doesn't play a game against a tribe, people don't organize labor into a citizenry, a train-car full of people aren't a global population, a nation-state isn't a guild. These concepts are vastly different and any model that conflates them is so useless as to not be considered.
- picks_at_nits 12y ago> People go to extraordinary lengths to join groups and send this membership signal... > It's dumb, but it is what it is, and people wrap an awful lot of their identity up in their chosen tribe rather than just being themselves. Cough. Written on Hacker News, but not Reddit or Digg or Facebook. Cough. C’mon, we’re sitting right in the middle of a tribe. Even writing that Sennheisers sound better is sending a tribal signal. That’s why people write it instead of just buying a pair and listening to them in private.
- bane 12y agoI'm not saying I'm not dumb at times. FWIW, I have a $20 pair of Sony unknown model # headphones I picked up at Ross. I bought them because they were over ear and cheap not because they're white, have Sony logos on them, or because I wanted to make a statement about what group I'm in or not in. But yeah, HN is also very group membership oriented and people spend extraordinary amount of time to build things with things that signal that they're part of this group. The trope is "yet another photo sharing app" right?
- picks_at_nits 12y agoI don’t think it’s dumb at all. Humans cannot survive without the protection of a tribe. Just try doing a startup in Somalia.
- bane 12y ago> Humans cannot survive without the protection of a tribe. That's utter fear driven rubbish. Humans survive and thrive all the time without joining a group.
- picks_at_nits 12y agoWhere? Alaska in an old bus? Even there, humans benefit to a small degree from law enforcement that strongly discourages the next hunter from shooting them and taking their possessions. There are some survivalists who may or may not be able to operate for a while on this basis, but even if they aren’t “joining” a tribe, they are protected by tribes. get rid of all the tribes, and new ones would spring up and we’d be back to this.
- smrtinsert 12y agoright - the marketed.