3 ms·
> Natural language is imprecise and vague. And it is relying on a lot of your experience. Yes. That's because if you need to be precise you remove yourself far
by scotty79 12y ago
> Natural language is imprecise and vague. And it is relying on a lot of your experience.
Yes. That's because if you need to be precise you remove yourself farther and farther from natural language towards professional jargon where words have more specified meanings and towards math and computer languages that you can call precise.
> The top layer is the syntax layer, and it should follow the path of natural language which takes in human context (the human interface).
It would be nice to keep at least some part familiar but more often than not you can't because some 'top layer' constructs you need to express have very cumbersome expression, if any, in natural language.
For example natural languages lacks constructs for deep composability or indirection.
Natural language is perfectly fine in daily work, like deciding what's for dinner, but trying to explain any non-trivial concept with natural language quickly becomes too cumbersome and person trying to convey the message moves onto more expressive and precise tools like math or drawings or pseudocode.
Please look at how theorems and proofs looked before invention of math symbolism. That's natural language stretched to extremes.
Also please read any modern code of law. That's what we get when people go out of their way to express concepts in natural language instead of creating some explicit domain symbolism.
I'll take math or even cobol any day instead of that.