4 ms·
This reads to me like a massive overthinking of a very old problem - bad products. We used to have bad products that did a hundred different things badly, rush
by jdietrich 12y ago
This reads to me like a massive overthinking of a very old problem - bad products.
We used to have bad products that did a hundred different things badly, rushed out to meet an overambitious spec sheet and an unrealistic launch date. Now we have bad products that do one thing badly, rushed out because the Kickstarter money or seed funding has all been spent.
I think the author completely misses the mark on what these teams are getting wrong, and the solution to the problem. The products he describes have clearly had no small amount of effort put into the "whole gestalt experience"; The hardware he complains about looks beautiful, and I expect came in beautiful packaging and was sold with beautiful marketing. His gripes are straightforward engineering issues, mainly of poor software quality. There's nothing romantic about refactoring and debugging. It doesn't take any sort of deep philosophical insight to do proper QA.
If I may be somewhat blunt, I think that the answer is perfectly straightforward - stop buying unproven hardware just because it looks cool. Companies ship buggy, half-finished devices because the market makes it profitable to do so. Curb your enthusiasm and wait for version two. Pass over the hot new thing from the hot new startup, and buy something more pedestrian from a manufacturer with a proven track record. Ignore the glowing press reviews on launch day, and wait for the trickle of complaints on Amazon when the thing starts failing after three months.
- clay_to_n 12y agoHe was arguing that these companies got the gestalt / romantic quality right (a positive trend in tech), but that they aren't getting the classic quality right (ie basic working engineering). I think you're mostly agreeing with him.
- Animats 12y ago"Stop buying unproven hardware just because it looks cool." Yes. Remember what happened to Detroit when their quality was inferior to Japanese cars. Don't deal with companies whose approach is "shit early, shit often". And if it doesn't work, return it, demand a refund, and make negative comments on Amazon. ("Internet Thermometer — needs 4 AAA batteries every week". That's incompetent electronic design. I have an outdoor thermometer which transmits to a receiver and display inside. It's been running for seven years now, and it's on its second pair of two AA batteries.)
- camillomiller 12y agoSometimes it works, if you balance the shit levels. Take Samsung's smartphones: a couple of flagship models, usually great, balanced by a ton of mostly shitty mid-tier phones that carriers are happy to bundle with their equally shitty offers. Works well, if you don't make a misstep like last year's S5.
- creshal 12y agoI wouldn't exactly call Samsung's flagship devices "great" either. Flashy hardware, but TouchWiz is so absurdly slow and bugged that the UX is worse than on non-modified Android phones half as expensive.
- belorn 12y agoWhile your advices might be a acceptable for hardware, I don't find it much help with minimum viable software. Proven software is generally out of date, version two can as easily be much worse than version one, and so called proven track records has numerous examples of people milking the good name of a company or product series. The only thing a consumer can do to protect themselves is to hope that consumer reviews are correct and not gamed, and that they are still relevant at the time of purchase. This then leads to new problems, as a recent article on HN talked about (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9207855 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9207855). In particular, a product with many happy reviews but with a small set of negative ones produces doubt, the psychological effect of which pushes consumer to buy less reviewed items.
- raverbashing 12y ago"stop buying unproven hardware just because it looks cool" Does it really need to be said? Yes, it does 90% of the stuff on Kickstarter is crap. And that's already filtering for things that can be produced/shipped. Of course, experimenting is part of the solution. But most producers have no experience, no expert knowledge (on the domain area AND/OR on the technology). I wouldn't be surprised to find people thinking programming an Arduino is the same as using jQuery. IT IS NOT Apple 1 was crap. No doubt about it. But it wasn't marketed for the end user. And it was what got Apple to the Apple II and then to further adoption. And even that wasn't enough. Visicalc did that. Now, a wireless IOT thermometer that uses AA batteries, that's just stupid.
- smellf 12y ago> A wireless IOT thermometer that uses AA batteries, that's just stupid. It's even stupider than that - AAA batteries! While I 100% agree with you, it's easy to see how the team that did that thermometer got to that insane product - they started out with very conservative power estimates, saw some advantage to having a battery-powered thermometer, and started development. The power requirements skyrocketed, and whatever their original estimates for battery life were (6 months, whatever) went down the drain, but by that point it was too late to redesign all the electronics and mechanicals to accommodate bigger batteries or a power plug. Or, they had already raised money with "battery powered" as their main selling point, so it was the one feature they couldn't axe even if it killed the product.