3 ms·
There are multiple reasons, not only the direct harm from radiation. The latest book from Dr. Welch "Less medicine, more health : 7 assumptions that drive too m
by kgwgk 12y ago
There are multiple reasons, not only the direct harm from radiation. The latest book from Dr. Welch "Less medicine, more health : 7 assumptions that drive too much medical care" explains some of them. The table of contents provides a good summary of his message:
ASSUMPTION #1: ALL RISKS CAN BE LOWERED
Disturbing truth: Risks can’t always be lowered—and trying creates risks of its own
ASSUMPTION #2: IT’S ALWAYS BETTER TO FIX THE PROBLEM
Disturbing truth: Trying to eliminate a problem can be more dangerous than managing one
ASSUMPTION #3: SOONER IS ALWAYS BETTER
Disturbing truth: Early diagnosis can needlessly turn people into patients
ASSUMPTION #4: IT NEVER HURTS TO GET MORE INFORMATION
Disturbing truth: Data overload can scare patients and distract your doctor from what’s important
ASSUMPTION #5: ACTION IS ALWAYS BETTER THAN INACTION
Disturbing truth: Action is not reliably the “right” choice
ASSUMPTION #6: NEWER IS ALWAYS BETTER
Disturbing truth: New interventions are typically not well tested and oft en wind up being judged ineffective (even harmful)
ASSUMPTION #7: IT’S ALL ABOUT AVOIDING DEATH
Disturbing truth: A fixation on preventing death diminishes life
- seagreen 12y agoThis seems like a repetition of the same point seven times. Let me try to rephrase your seven assumptions into a single, strong argument: "Doctors and patients treat intervention as the default response to medical issues, but there are situations where intervention is (on average) neutral or harmful." This is true. It is not a strong argument against medical scans however[1]. For instance, the result of the scans could be analyzed by a third party who isn't the patient or the doctor. Issues could only be passed along to the doctor if it will lead to a statistically better outcome for the patient. [1] It might be a strong argument given a sufficiently weak culture, for instance one that is unable to provide legal immunity to the statistics-running third party. If your argument is, "We suck so bad we can't do 'statistics', so putting our heads in the sand is actually the best outcome we can get", you can just say that directly. EDIT: Changed "can't" to "can". Thanks kgwgk.
- kgwgk 12y ago> If your argument is, "We suck so bad we can't do 'statistics', so putting our heads in the sand is actually the best outcome we can't (?) get", you can just say that directly. As far as I know, the statistics we have show that it is better to avoid doing full-body CT scans to asymptomatic people in the first place. Maybe you have different statistics?
- iamcurious 12y agoASSUMPTION #7: IT’S ALL ABOUT AVOIDING DEATH Disturbing truth: A fixation on preventing death diminishes life I don't like the wording of that last point. Yes, there are more things to life than avoiding death. And yes, fixation on preventing death can, in some cases, be counterproductive. I much prefer: as long as life is worth living, death is worth avoiding.
- krick 12y agoThere's an opinion that his wording is exactly correct, and concentration on avoiding death makes life unworthy by definition. Although that opinion might be incomprehensible for some cultures. I can't think of anything that would explain that opinion clearly enough, but you could read Hagakure anyway.
- deciplex 12y ago>Disturbing truth: A fixation on preventing death diminishes life Define 'fixation'. Total prevention of death obviously does not diminish life. If there ever comes a day when we truly conquer aging, it is going to be one of sadder days for humanity.