8 ms·
France Gives in to the Hashtag
- netrus 12y agoI will start a tumblr account dedicated to news published all arround the year that are april-fools-worthy.
- RyJones 12y agohttps://reddit.com/r/nottheonion https://reddit.com/r/nottheonion ?
- column 12y ago"access without wire" vs "wireless access"
- nmc 12y agoOf course the proper translation for "accès sans fil" is "wireless access", but the author points out that it is translated "literally", and indeed "sans fil" literally means "without wire".
- FreakyT 12y agoLinguistic purity movements continue to strike me as largely pointless. It seems better that language evolve naturally -- as long as it remains effective as a communication medium, what is the issue?
- jhpriestley 12y agoI'm not sure what "natural" evolution you're referring to. We can think of language as a natural behavior of man - a social creature that uses technology. In this case we must admit that this creature also sometimes forms language purity movements.
- jacquesm 12y agoIt stems from fear of identity loss. The weird thing is that in the longer turn it results in a much larger problem: irrelevance.
- rw37 12y agoRight. I can almost see the case when a language is in real danger of extinction, although even then maintaining its purity might be harmful, but French is not in danger of extinction anytime soon.
- panglott 12y agoThere is an ancient perception that one's own language is degraded, that the language of older literature is more vital, more robust, richer. You can find this strain of thought in English literature for hundreds of years, in French, and in classical Latin and Greek, and many other literary traditions, I'm sure. There must be some basic cognitive bias here, like valorizing too highly the literature you loved in your youth, while discounting the creative innovations of your own age.
- kissickas 12y agoOr by cherry-picking the greatest works of century-long periods and comparing them to the endless onslaught of terrible works today. That said, even if there is a selective bias, that doesn't make it any less useful to preserve backwards compatibility so we can understand those great works.
- PepeGomez 12y agoOr maybe old language looks "richer", because you can easily notice grammar used in old literature that is no longer used in modern speech, but it's very hard to spot grammar that didn't exist yet.
- borgia 12y ago>Linguistic purity movements continue to strike me as largely pointless. It seems better that language evolve naturally -- as long as it remains effective as a communication medium, what is the issue? On the one hand I agree with you. The English we use now, even when written or spoken in a grammatically perfect way, is very different to the English used a couple of hundred years ago. On the other hand, seeing "your/you're" or "they're/their/there" used incorrectly or interchangeably rustles my jimmies immeasurably.
- 0xffff2 12y agoDo the French really not have that problem though? It seems to me that most people know the difference between "your" and "you're", they just don't care enough to use the right variant.
- borgia 12y agoRegarding your question about French, I'm not too sure. There/their/they're would be la/leur/ils sont, so perhaps there's scope for the first two to become conflated, not so much the last. As far as I know the biggest issue French is facing is the injection of English words where there isn't a French equivalent. Then again, French people seem to absolutely loathe the version of French spoken in Quebec so there could be a plethora of other issues involved that we don't have in English. Regarding your second point, personally I'm not sure but ignorance certainly plays its part one way or another.
- realusername 12y agoIt depends, sometimes the words they invent fit quite naturally into the language and people tend to use them and sometimes they just invent something unpronounceable and obviously nobody is using those words and use the English word as a replacement instead.
- dorfsmay 12y agoNo. Everybody knows that languages naturally evolve on their own. The advantages of the "Académie" are: - it slows down the evolution allowing better choices. - although the language is still driven by everybody using it, it is stirred in the right direction by linguists and authors, usually making choices consistent with the rest of the languages, its history and roots. The best example of what happens when such a mechanism isn't in place is the "biweekly" and "irregardless" mess in english! I am really fond of the "Real Academia Española" as they go even further than their french counterpart, and regularly change the spelling of words to reflect their modern pronounciation.
- seszett 12y ago> I am really fond of the "Real Academia Española" as they go even further than their french counterpart, and regularly change the spelling of words to reflect their modern pronounciation. The Académie does that too, but people are so used to having irregular or (apparently) illogical spelling that the new spellings catch on very slowly. It works though, and today you rarely see someone write "clef" instead of "clé" or "cuiller" instead of "cuillère". A few verbs got their accents changed from "é" to "è" too, following modern pronunciation. All that was in 1990.
- alricb 12y agoI think it's partly because when spelling was standardized in the 17th-18th century, it was done with a "learned" view that spelling should reflect a word's origin. So you get "doigt" for finger because of the latin digitus, the circumflex to denote an S that has become silent (hôpital vs. hospital), and even overcorrections (that have been recorrected since), like nénuphar -> nénufar (ph is used to denote places where there used to be a greek phi, but nénufar comes from Arabic)
- dorfsmay 12y agoWhen it comes to spelling though, they are too slow. Why do we have 'k', 'c' and 'qu' when one would suffice? What about all the spelling we never pronouce ("ils mangent")? If the Académie doesn't do anything about it, eventually people will create their own simplifications, and that is guaranteed to be a mess.
- agumonkey 12y agoEspecially regarding the cyclic relationship between English and French, it's not as if both of us didn't borrow words in the past.
- Svip 12y agoYou can argue if that if languages are merely tools, then sure, why not? But it leaves out things to wonder about and be intrigued by. I am not a fan of the idea that we cannot make interesting linguistic additions to our languages any more. And certainly not isolated to English. I find internet lingo in non-English languages far more interesting than those in English (at least when we are talking about something else than simply using the English loanword), since the Internet is largely an English-written concept, other languages are finding its incompatibilities with English difficult and the solutions can be quite interesting. I find the anglifications of languages to be uninteresting at best, from a completely linguistic standpoint. Take a modern item like a 'vacuum cleaner', called »støvsuger« in Danish, which literally translates as 'dust sucker'. This reveals a difference in how each language's speakers think about items, words and their meanings. If all words are English, then the languages themselves reveal nothing about our differences and how we think. Moreover, it will cause us all to think in the same way. It's documented that speaking more languages helps one think different about approaching problems, even ones not related to language. It broadens the mind. Everything being English won't broaden the mind.
- mc32 12y agoFrom France's pov, it all started as a way to centralize and wrest power away from the provinces, later as a way put France and French at the center of Europe. Having been the center of science and education for much of the middle ages, renaissance, colonial power, etc. It's hard for France to give in symbolically and allow that there are stronger influences than its own. It's been a quixotic quest, at best, it's not as if in regular speech (French) people didn't inject whatever was the argot dujour into the speech be it domestic or foreign.
- auganov 12y agoWell I can feel how it's neat to have a pure version of the language. Maintaining some knowledge about languages that are/will probably die is also nice. The most striking thing to me is how people tend to get so conservative about natural languages.
- maelito 12y agoC'est classe, mot-dièse
- alricb 12y agoDid you hear about that new language Microsoft has come up with? They call it "do dièse" (and they have a project called "fa dièse" for some reason).
- Zikes 12y ago> accès sans fil à l’Internet Replacing an English word with a phrase containing an English word. Hard to imagine why it failed to catch on.
- guard-of-terra 12y agoAdd to that, "wi-fi" doesn't imply "internet access".
- emilecantin 12y agoI think the Académie Française is doing a very poor job. In Québec we have the Office Québécois de la Langue Française, which is much better at finding French equivalents to modern technology terms. A few examples: - Cloud Computing -> Infonuagique - E-Mail -> Courriel (vs. France's mél... how the hell do you pronounce that) - Hashtag -> Mot-clic (it is indeed a keyword, "mot-clé" that you can click) And a whole lot more...
- _delirium 12y agoAccording to their current explanation, the Académie française proposes "Mél." (with period) only as an abbreviation for use on e.g. business cards, coined by analogy to the abbreviation "Tél." for telephone numbers. For usage in sentences they suggest either the full message électronique, or borrowing courriel from Québec, which they officially approved in 2003. http://www.academie-francaise.fr/la-langue-francaise/questions-de-langue#26_strong-em-courriel-ml-em-strong http://www.academie-francaise.fr/la-langue-francaise/questio... Mot-clic is humorous; I had not seen that before.
- reblochon 12y agoDon't forget the wonderful "pourriel" mixing "poubelle" (trash can) and e-mail to designate spam, If only it would have crossed the ocean.
- vmarsy 12y agoI always thought pourriel was from "pourri" (rotten/lousy) + "courriel". Both convey a correct meaning for spam!
- realusername 12y agoSometimes they are even counter-productive. People are not using the English word anyway and they want to replace the French word people are using with another one. Example: instead of 'offline', the academy recommends '(mode) autonome' but people are already using 'déconnecté' or 'hors-ligne' instead, so it does not make sense at all.
- pervycreeper 12y ago
- Jun8 12y agoHere's an interesting question: How do the French decide on gender (and hence the article to use) of imported English words (same question can be asked for many of the European languages that have grammatical gender, e.g. German)? This Guardian note provides some answers (http://www.theguardian.com/notesandqueries/query/0,5753,-1251,00.html http://www.theguardian.com/notesandqueries/query/0,5753,-125...), in French imported words are mostly masculine. Some examples I pulled from this (http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/archive/index.php/t-391745.html http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/archive/index.php/t-3917...) thread for the gender of Internet in various languages: * Spanish: Generally assumed to be masculine but the Real Academia Espanola page lists it as "amb", i.e. undecided gender (http://buscon.rae.es/drae/?type=3&val=internet&val_aux=&origen=REDRAE) * Russian: Интернет - masculine * Welsh: rhwngrwyd - feminine (but that's because "net" (rhwyd) is feminine, itself borrowed from Latin neuter rete, retis "net.") * Czech: masculine * Hebrew: masculine, although the more commonly used "net" (reshet) is feminine. It's commonly taught that grammatical gender in languages (at least in IE languages) is semantically meaningless, i.e. they are just arbitrary classifications. this may not be totally true. If you have 10 minutes this article (PDF file: http://lera.ucsd.edu/papers/gender.pdf http://lera.ucsd.edu/papers/gender.pdf) by Lera Boroditsky has an in-depth discussion on this topic. French and German native speakers: Can you provide examples of English borrowed words that have feminine gender?
- realusername 12y ago(French here). The only one I can think of is that a lot of people are saying "La WiFi" (feminine) instead of "Le WiFi" (masculine). For some brands, it can also be quite random since all the game consoles I can think of are using the feminine gender.
- alricb 12y agoThere are regional variances: In Québec, we say "une job", but in France they use "un job", but it's "un suprise party" here, versus "une surprise party" in France. Sometimes, when the translation is obvious, we'll use the gender of the original word, e.g. "une backdoor" (porte dérobée).
- 12y ago
- ErnestedCode 12y agoSo...they surrendered?
- gregoire 12y ago"Mot-dièse" isn't even a correct translation. It is literally translated as "sharp-word", so there is a confusion between 2 distinct signs: - #, the "croisillon" sign (hash) - ♯, the "dièse" sign (sharp) Therefore the literal translation should be "mot-croisillon", not "mot-dièse". And on the subject of the the Académie Française, the Commission générale de terminologie et de néologie and the Délégation générale à la langue française et aux langues de France (DGLFLF), the problem is that they often try to find translations to words that, in my opinion, shouldn't be translated. For example, the DGLFLF has a website [0] where people can suggest french translations for english words. Here are some words from the website that it is pointless to try to translate: - BitTorrent - barcamp - Facebook As a result, the proposed translations are often ridiculous (filoutage, langage à objets, offre groupée). Another problem is that the people working there are not technology-fluent. That's why they come up with wrong translations such as "accès sans fil à l’Internet" ("access without wire to the Internet") for Wi-Fi, which is incorrect as a Wi-Fi connexion does not always imply an Internet connexion. That said, some english words have a great french translation : - firewall -> part-feu - mailing-list -> liste de diffusion - byte -> octet [0]: https://wikilf.culture.fr/ https://wikilf.culture.fr/
- jstoiko 12y agoI grew up in France and my favorite (french) literature teacher (and best one, IMO) once told me that it was in the nature of languages to evolve. This was especially true with French as a result of the abondance of cultural exchanges throughout the centuries. Over the years, French has had influences from many languages including Arabic, e.g. the word "Abricot" (the fruit) comes from that language. It also provides an indication as of where a given new word has been originated. He also said that it is up to the people to dictate the usage of new words. Some new words have been suggested by the Académie Française to replace words that had been taken from other languages. But in the end, if people dont use that replacement, then it is the (foreign) word that will be adopted in the dictionary. He gave the example of "shopping", a word taken from the English and widely used in France but reluctantly used in Quebec for cultural (political?) reasons.