6 ms·
It is worth noting that "Running on 100% Renewable Electricity" most likely only addresses grid electricity, not other form of fossil fuel use, such as cars, tr
by SideburnsOfDoom 12y ago
It is worth noting that "Running on 100% Renewable Electricity" most likely only addresses grid electricity, not other form of fossil fuel use, such as cars, truck, boats and trains. 100% Renewable Electricity in the grid is a great milestone, but it's not 100% of energy use as the title might suggest.
- static_noise 12y agoGrid electricity is only about a third of primary energy consumption. Renewables and nuclear power only make up about 10% and 6% of primary energy consumption worldwide [1]. In the coming years we have to ramp those fractions up globally A LOT in order to become CO2-neutral. Also from the low fraction of 6% we can see that nuclear could be switched off today without making a big difference for CO2 output, renewables already generate more power. [1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Primary_energy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Primary_energy
- brrt 12y agoThen it is also worth noting that electricity generation is the biggest single source of carbon emissions globally :-). And that transport is actually a relatively tiny part of global carbon emissions: http://www.epa.gov/climatechange/ghgemissions/global.html http://www.epa.gov/climatechange/ghgemissions/global.html In other words, this is a bigger deal than your post seems to suggest.
- de_Selby 12y agoI did a summer internship project with our national electricity supplier here in Ireland when I was a student - the aim was to asses he environmental impact of their fleet of vehicles. The management weren't terribly happy with the presentation I gave at the end of the summer where using a few simple models I showed that even their smallest power station was polluting on a scale that was orders of magnitude greater than the impact of their entire fleet. We have mostly coal and peat powered plants here. Nuclear is completely off the table for political reasons, but there is a huge untapped wind energy resource. This really is great news for Costa Rica. I think we should also be exploring Nuclear energy more to bridge the gap in most other countries though.
- brrt 12y agoWe're getting offtopic, but peat powered plants? In this day and age? What the hell? I do hope that is not being sold as sustainable or renewable? But yeah, automobile emissions in general are relatively limited in comparison to other sources.
- Tarang 12y agoDon't be mistaken. In many developing nations there is a thirst for power. Renewables aren't up to it when it comes to the scale and speed required (even though the countries involved are on the equator). I don't advocate for the use of coal in generating power but this is what seems to be going on. The largest (MW/GW wise) expansion projects in terms of power generation are all coal projects as far as I'm aware on the entire African continent. Typically each unit/turbine generates close to 1 GW. It's hard to find something with the equivalent cost (including the use of a small amount of space) with renewable energy. Even the best geothermal well in Kenya, on the rift valley geothermal reservoir, only gives out near 5 MW. The renewable scaling issue is something that needs to be faced. Costa Rica truly has achieved a milestone much larger than it sounds. It is possible I'm not saying its not. The three gorges dam hydroelectric plant is able to produce near 22 GW, also the largest power plant in the world (including non renewable energy)
- brrt 12y agoI am under no illusions about the need for power :-). In fact, I agree with just about everything in your post. However, I would add: Coal plants use only a relatively small local surface area, but when you add the size of the coal mines, the infrastructure required to ship those tons of coal, the space required to store the tons coal ash produced each day (often contaminated with heavy metals; it's earth we're burning after all).... that becomes a very different discussion. I'm unsure why people are so keen on geothermal, though. I thought it was relatively well-known that geothermal generates power in the order of milli-watts-per-square-meter, thus much smaller than solar (hundreds of watts per square meter), or even hydroelectric.
- deleted 12y ago
- logfromblammo 12y agoFurthermore, within the "transport" category, the largest container ships emit more combustion products than every car. If you combine the tailpipe emissions of every car on Earth, that accounts for less atmospheric pollution than just 16-24 gigantic ship engines, burning bunker fuel. And furtherfurthermore, coal-fired electricity plants are by far the worst polluters among electricity generating facilities that burn fuel. This is a big win for Costa Rica, but the rest of the planet would be hard-pressed to replicate the achievement without going bankrupt. That accomplishment would be surpassed many times over by even one technology that could be used to refine coal or bunker fuel to make it cleaner-burning in the existing infrastructure at or near the same price per ton.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- asn0 12y agoEPA Chart: Global Emissions by Source • Energy supply: 26% [...] • Transport: 13% (certainly less, but "a relatively tiny part"?) • Buildings: 8% • Waste & wastewater: 3% (definitely a tiny part) [updated for formatting and clarity]
- lolo_ 12y agoAnd that's where electric vehicles come in :) Also I find it really dismaying the degree to which nuclear has been downplayed. It has risks, but what are those risks against the certainty of global warming?
- webXL 12y agoWhile I believe both are real risks, I also believe catastrophic anthropogenic global warming (CAGW) is only certain for those who have something to gain from the immediate actions to combat it. Ice is melting, seas are rising, storms are getting more powerful. But, are we not able to adapt? Under Kyoto, the forgone economic growth would put us in a much worse position to do something about adapting (rebuilding, relocation, drought assistance, etc.). And who knows, there might be other things we will have to adapt to besides changes in climate in the future. Improving our living conditions and technology is the best option. Out of that will come solutions to CAGW. Despite a couple of bad preventable accidents, Nuclear is safe and the only clear economic solution to the CO2 emission issue.
- mb_72 12y agoAnother issue is disposal of waste. Living in Australia it seems pretty clear to me there's lots of land here where such storage / disposal could be implemented, yet the outcry from various groups over 'abuse' of areas where no-one lives or visits has to be seen to be believed. And one reason I stopped supporting Greenpeace (some years ago now) was because of their staunch and irrational opposition to nuclear.
- oh_sigh 12y agoI have a feeling that many new car buyers figure out a way to get around the import tax - probably by driving them in through Panama or Nicaragua.
- allendoerfer 12y agoOn that note, consider this sentence: >And the country's economy relies on tourism and agriculture, not energy-sucking industries like manufacturing. Of course tourism is energy-sucking. Its just not grid electricity and most likely the energy use is attributed to European or American airlines and passengers.
- shangxiao 12y agoThe title "Running on 100% Renewable Electricity" in no way suggested to me that they are talking about anything other than grid electricity.
- jacquesm 12y agoObviously 'electricity' is not 'all energy' and the title does not suggest that, it very explicitly uses 'electricity'. Also, quite a bit of Costa Rica's rail is electrified: http://www.ferrolatino.ch/en/reports/costarica/ http://www.ferrolatino.ch/en/reports/costarica/ And then there is 'off-grid' electricity, local installations of solar power. These are typically smaller but there are quite a few of them.
- mattlutze 12y agoWell, the title doesn't say "100% of Costa Rica's Electricity is Now Renewable", it says "Costa Rica Is Now Running on 100% Renewable Electricity." That translates out to "What Costa Rica runs on is 100% renewable." It's likely pedantic to discuss it, but I will wager that no, the construction of that title was less than explicitly mindful. The ambiguity is reinforced multiple times throughout the article.
- jacquesm 12y ago> That translates out to "What Costa Rica runs on is 100% renewable." No it doesn't. You changed the meaning.
- SideburnsOfDoom 12y agoThat's pretty much correct. The article's title at first glance looks like it says (Costa Rica Is Now Running on) (100% Renewable Electricity). This is a subjective grammatical nitpick, but it would be foolish to say that it's not there at all. Further, the article text isn't mindful of the distinction either , so I'm happy that I raised the topic, with the resulting discussion around the share of total energy used for transport vs grid, and with my original wording of "as the title might suggest". (emphasis now on "might". YMMV. )
- mikeash 12y agoThat title can just as easily mean that Costa Rica's electricity is 100% renewable as it could mean that all of Costa Rica's energy is 100% renewable electricity. Given two equally correct meanings, choose the one that actually makes any sense in context.
- dedward 12y agoThat's exactly what it means - grid power. I don't know why everyone thinks it means we somehow, under the radar, stopped using gas vehicles and stoves and stuff... obviously that's not the case. And it's not a milestone.. it's a sensationalized headline. As much as I'm proud of my little adopted country - this doesn't represent some new investment or initiative. We had more rain than usual this year so ran on renewables longer than average this year (dropping electricity prices 10% for a while, which is fantastic).
- dedward 12y agoThat's exactly what it means - grid power. I don't know why everyone thinks it means we somehow, under the radar, stopped using gas vehicles and stoves and stuff... obviously that's not the case. And it's not a milestone.. it's a sensationalized headline. As much as I'm proud of my little adopted country - this doesn't represent some new investment or initiative. We had more rain than usual this year so ran on renewables longer than average this year (dropping electricity prices 10% for a while, which is fantastic).
- dedward 12y agoThat's exactly what it means - grid power. I don't know why everyone thinks it means we somehow, under the radar, stopped using gas vehicles and stoves and stuff... obviously that's not the case. And it's not a milestone.. it's a sensationalized headline. As much as I'm proud of my little adopted country - this doesn't represent some new investment or initiative. We had more rain than usual this year so ran on renewables longer than average this year (dropping electricity prices 10% for a while, which is fantastic).
- higherpurpose 12y agoIt does say electricity, not energy.
- kenrikm 12y agoIf I recall Costa Rica has a 100% import tax on cars. Not everyone has or can afford a car there. What would be really interesting is if they were to remove or lower that tariff for electric vehicles it could for example make a Nissan Leaf the cheapest new car you could get in the country.