13 ms·
Trying Something New on Immigration in Colorado
- codeonfire 12y agoThe university can't discriminate based on country of origin, which is exactly what is being proposed: "we are particularly focused on international entrepreneurs." It doesn't matter if you give the money to CU and then the university hires someone "international." It's still discrimination at a public institution. Personally I don't understand why they insist on having someone non-American on H1B or why they absolutely must travel to the US to start a start-up. Give someone money where they already live. Don't exclude Americans. What's so hard about that?
- pmorici 12y agoThe Supreme Court has said that making employment decisions based on citizenship status doesn't qualify as discrimination under the civil rights act because citizenship status is not the same thing as "national origin" which is what the law prohibits discrimination on. ESPINOZA v. FARAH MFG. CO., 414 U.S. 86 (1973) http://caselaw.lp.findlaw.com/scripts/getcase.pl?court=US&vol=414&invol=86 http://caselaw.lp.findlaw.com/scripts/getcase.pl?court=US&vo...
- codeonfire 12y agoRegardless, what is the motivation to want to discriminate? The only thing I can see is that having someone in the US under H1B gives them power over that person.
- chetanahuja 12y ago"having someone in the US under H1B gives them power over that person." Wow... way to not only completely misinterpret the intent but to completely reverse it. Before this program there were exactly zero legal avenues for a not-already-rich aspiring startup founder from another country to come here with the express purpose of starting a business. Now there is one.
- codeonfire 12y agoI'm not misinterpreting the intent. I know perfectly well the stated intent to 'help the helpless random immigrant founder.' I'm suggesting an alternative intent that needs to be discussed. And I'm not the one reversing it. In this case Mr. Feld is showing a clear preference for H1B's before having any specific foreign entrepreneur in mind.
- tonymillion 12y ago"exactly zero legal avenues" In this day of age you very rarely need to be permanently physically present in the US to own and run a US business, and once your business passes the threshold of actually being viable theres multiple routes to getting a Visa. There's the whole E2 Visa system specifically designed for this. In addition after a year in business there is a L1a route too, assuming the business goes anywhere. Admittedly theres very little room for a "starving devpreneur who is making some social app that doesn't make any money", but assuming such an app can take off then the investment they could raise would instantly get them to quality for a visa too.
- rtpg 12y agocompletely agree on the fact that the H1B is messed up. I think here this person is trying to act in good faith, and unfortunately this is the easiest way to get people into the country. I hope for everyone's sake that this is genuine. H1B visas are the reason that immigration can cause lower salaries. They're anti-free market in every sense of the word
- davidw 12y ago> I hope for everyone's sake that this is genuine. He's paying a bundle of money out of his own pocket to help people out, I don't see how much more genuine it could be.
- codeonfire 12y agoHe's paying a small amount of money 4x$25k to get some 'founders' in control of millions of investment under control of threat of cancelled visas.
- sparkzilla 12y agoThis is the worst comment I have ever read on HN. There are already plenty of opportunities for Americans to get support for their startups. The US visa system makes it extremely difficult for foreign entrepreneurs to start businesses in the US, and Mr Feld's attempts to improve the situation should be applauded.
- codeonfire 12y agoI see...You believe the cause is so noble that it's obvious drawbacks are beyond discussion. Then lets discuss something else. Why don't you tell us why you think it's so important for foreign entrepreneurs to start businesses in the US. Do you feel the same about US entrepreneurs opportunities in foreign countries?
- davidw 12y ago> Why don't you tell us why you think it's so important for foreign entrepreneurs to start businesses in the US Let's see: * Google * AT&T * Goldman Sachs * eBay * Yahoo * Nordstrom * DuPont * Kraft foods * Pfizer For starters. The list goes on. Immigrants are beneficial: http://journal.dedasys.com/2014/12/29/people-places-and-jobs/ http://journal.dedasys.com/2014/12/29/people-places-and-jobs... > Do you feel the same about US entrepreneurs opportunities in foreign countries? Certainly! Other countries should also make it easier to attract talented people, or for that matter, anyone who is willing to work, and not a criminal.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 12y ago"Another Goldman Sachs" is just about the best possible argument you can make for closed borders.
- wavefunction 12y agohear hear
- lazaroclapp 12y ago
- wahsd 12y agoYou should realize that America is being deconstructed into a corporate entity. Being American really doesn't even matter any more, you are a head of cattle on Big Sky USA Ranch Inc. where the upper sliver of society is the only net beneficiary while Americans are cast aside at the drop of a dime if there are profits to be made by some other means. Especially here, foreign fools are going to cheer this type of policy on, because they can then self-extract their talents out of their own society and come to the USA to build up our corporate masters' relative domination while their home countries and societies atrophy. Brain drain is starting to become an ever greater issue for even advanced societies, especially the ones that pay for their citizens' education. The tax payer is footing the education and then, at the first chance, many of them, under the spell of America's formidable marketing and PR machine, dispatch to the USA with sparkles in their eyes; all along, not realizing they are just a cog in the wealthy's machine. With every immigrant, whether skilled or unskilled, the inflation eats away at the earnings and progress of the average American like an endless treadmill that the wealthy have dangled an image of the American dream in front of. Yes, come to America, everyone. Make me more wealthy by increasing the population, make me more wealthy through inflation, make me more wealthy by pushing down labor rates and cheapening salaries, make me ever more powerful by draining your talents and labor from your home societies, culture, and economy.
- mfringel 12y agoParse error: Rant did not include word "sheeple".
- terravion 12y agoThis is fantastic! I hope it soon makes moot many of the immigration restrictions on talented technologists. We make it so hard to recruit great talent in this country and so hard for talented entrepreneurs--who often don't qualify for work or family based visas--to get a visa.
- jabo 12y agoConsistent with university policy and applicable law, entrepreneurs in the program will be free to work on their existing entrepreneurial ventures or start a new company in one of the best entrepreneurial communities in the world. Isn't the requirement for a H1B visa that the "non-immigrant alien" not work for any other company/institution other than the one that sponsored the visa? How does the program get around that?
- pandaman 12y agoFull-time employment is also a requirement (and I believe 20h per week is not considered full-time in the visa context) so either they've found a way around the law or the USCIS is going to bust them.
- chetanahuja 12y agoI don't think full-time employment is a strict requirement of the H1B visa. It's just that most companies wouldn't go through the hassle of H1B sponsorship (and it's a huuuuge hassle for both the employer and the employee) for a part time employee.
- pandaman 12y agoI stand corrected, it's not a requirement per se, it's just a part-time H1B still has to meet the prevailing wage requirement, which is established for the full-time job.
- therealwill 12y agoIANAL but as long as money does not change hands they should be in the clear. There is nothing stopping someone on an H1B doing a "hobby" and then pitch that "hobby" to investors to get seed money to form a startup. The investors would then have to sponsor their new H1B.
- Lawtonfogle 12y agoH1B and Immigration should be kept separate. Personally I'm pro-immigration and anti-H1B because of the potential for the H1B relationship to be abused in ways that are a detriment to both the one with the H1B and to the general employees in the same field. Personally, I have the skills to compete with an Immigrant for a fair paid position. I do not want to be competing for depressed wages against a H1B worker who has legally enforced company loyalty lest they be deported.
- davidw 12y agoThat's understandable, but perhaps also something of a "perfect is the enemy of the good" situation, since there seem to be large swathes of the US populace that do not want a more liberal worker immigration policy of any kind.
- Lawtonfogle 12y agoI'd prefer no policy change over an increase in H1Bs. This is more of a "nothing is better than bad" situation in my view. I may even go so far as to suggest that significantly increasing H1Bs could hurt general immigration policy. Companies would rather have more H1Bs than immigrants with the ability to defend their rights and the general population will see the damage caused by H1Bs (and with some well place propaganda) instead blame immigration. But this is a thought I have just thought and have not yet given full thought to.
- davidw 12y ago> I'd prefer no policy change All else being equal, sooner or later, that will cause enough problems for companies that they'll start going elsewhere, and then it will be you filling out the immigration paperwork if you would like to move there to work with the best and brightest.
- Lawtonfogle 12y agoEven that is better than opening up more H1Bs. I would rather have to completely globally in places that have worker rights than have to compete domestically against an individual who has to remain loyal to the country lest they be deported.
- krrishd 12y agoThis is great to hear, I know Craig has spent upwards of a year making this happen and it's awesome to see it come to fruition. Hopefully this kind of thing moves beyond Boulder into other places.
- wooyi 12y agoIt's great to see individuals/institutions being innovative on this front. I applaud Brad, his wife and CU for this. For Americans afraid of immigrants (H1B or other types) stealing your jobs - research shows that you'll likely be better off in the long run. http://www.nytimes.com/2015/03/29/magazine/debunking-the-myth-of-the-job-stealing-immigrant.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2015/03/29/magazine/debunking-the-myt... Entrepreneurs don't steal jobs - they create jobs.