5 ms·
Look at yesterday's top topic here, the new Facebook office "largest open floor plan office, ever". This sort of disrespect, this sort of complete dehumanizatio
by moron4hire 12y ago
Look at yesterday's top topic here, the new Facebook office "largest open floor plan office, ever". This sort of disrespect, this sort of complete dehumanization of the worker, it's the new normal. "Our employees are our greatest asset" is just something to print in the employee manual.
- nostrademons 12y agoEh, I don't see any problem with either open-floor-plan offices or with a lack of managers. And I assure you, I'm quite human. The main reason I wouldn't want to work for Zappos is because I don't give a damn about shoes. These sorts of moves are usually filtering functions on the types of employees you employ. They'll encourage everyone who doesn't fit the company culture to quit - which, ultimately, makes the company stronger. The beauty of our market economy is that you don't have to work in a company whose culture you find offensive, you can find one whose culture is more to your liking.
- comrh 12y ago> makes the company stronger maybe. or just an echo chamber of like minded drones?
- nostrademons 12y agoLike most things in life, it depends on how you look at it. If you see an echo chamber of like-minded drones, it's pretty likely you aren't looking very closely, as even the most homogenous cultures have plenty of room for individual variation. (Although they may not let you, as an outsider, see it.)
- comrh 12y agoSure, but you have to admit it can also product Enron like negative feedback loops where bad behavior is okay, and rewarded, due to culture.
- moron4hire 12y agoA company is not a nation of people separate from the people that comprise it, it can't have a culture unto itself. What people call "company culture" is just code-word for lazy management at best, discrimination at worst.
- nostrademons 12y agoIt certainly can - culture is just the sum total of the things that a group of people do without thinking too hard about them. Any group ends up with a culture, including companies. And when large numbers of people either leave or enter the group, the culture invariably changes.
- tbrownaw 12y agoThe beauty of our market economy is that you don't have to work in a company whose culture you find offensive, you can find one whose culture is more to your liking. <cue civil rights movement> <cue women's rights movement> Maybe for the most part now that those are done, but I'm sure there's a few things left. <cue religion-vs-LGBT flamewar> <cue women-in-silicon-valley flamewar>
- AlexEatsKittens 12y agoCould you expand on that thought a little? I'm not clear how Facebook's open floor plan is dehumanizing.
- moron4hire 12y agoIt treats people like cattle, thrown into the same homogeneous pen together. It can't possibly be about "collaboration" because private offices don't impede on collaboration. It's about fitting as many people into as cheap of a space as possible. And because Facebook has done it, now everyone and their brother is going to start implementing it in their startups, if they haven't already.
- onewaystreet 12y agoPeople used to complain about not having a corner office, then about having a cubical while the VPs had offices. Now no one has an office but people still complain. It's impossible for Facebook to give all of its employees offices, so what's the best solution? (People are overreacting to a single sentence by Zuckerberg anyways, the new Facebook headquarters has tons of conference rooms and private nooks.)
- iamcurious 12y agoIt's impossible for Facebook to give all of its employees offices, so what's the best solution? Why is it impossible?
- onewaystreet 12y agoBecause Facebook has thousands of employees. I suppose it might be possible to give everyone a closet sized office.
- sheepmullet 12y agoMicrosoft has shared decent size 2 people offices for thousands of developers.
- freyr 12y ago> This sort of disrespect, this sort of complete dehumanization of the worker, it's the new normal. When you decide to work for a CEO who called his own users "dumb fucks" for using his product, I'm not sure you should expect respect and humanization from the top.
- oh_sigh 12y agoI'm sure a lot of people who are 19 years old say dumb things . It's interesting that this is what you choose to remember.
- freyr 12y ago> It's interesting that this is what you choose to remember. Not really. Throughout its existence, Facebook has routinely made decisions that make me doubt whether it, as an organization, values people. I don't choose to remember the quote, I'm constantly reminded of it.
- oh_sigh 12y agoThen why not use a more relevant example than what a sophomore college kid flippantly said to a friend?
- freyr 12y agoSpecific actions are symptoms of the underlying problem, namely, the founder's low opinion of the people who use his service. That particular quote is an extremely relevant example. If you want examples that illustrate the effects of this mindset, you can find many here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_Facebook http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_Facebook The common theme is flagrant encroachment on the privacy rights of its users, which I don't believe Zuckerberg feels his users deserve. Presumably because they're dumb fucks in the first place for using Facebook.