3 ms·
That silliness has more to do with raising awareness and being a reminder than actually something which actually conserves water --simply it's symbolic
by mc32 12y ago
That silliness has more to do with raising awareness and being a reminder than actually something which actually conserves water --simply it's symbolic
- aetherson 12y agoBut it's not symbolic, it's distracting. It focuses limited public attention on doing something that's mildly personally inconvenient instead of actually effective.
- baddox 12y agoIt also strongly implies that everyday human water usage is a significant portion of water usage, which it isn't. For people who aren't educated about the California water situation, it's likely "raising awareness" of falsities.
- bduerst 12y agoBut if you get enough public attention it can snowball into actually changing what matters. You tell everyone to think about the almond trees and it's so far disconnected that they tend to forget about it. If it's the third restaurant visit this month they had to ask for water, then they're going to be more accepting of policy to save water with the farmers (i.e. do their part).
- hueving 12y ago>then they're going to be more accepting of policy to save water with the farmers The policies are just saying that normal consumers have to save though. People would be plenty accepting of a policy that just said farmers have to cut back. There is no reason for shared sacrifice here. The small users (normal people) already pay a fair price. The elephants are the ones screwing everyone and we are wasting time discussing how the minority can cut back more. It's stupid.
- SilasX 12y agoI have never seen a notification card for these policies that suggested it was symbolic; they all make it sound like a legit attempt at conserving water. Do you have an example of one consistent with your interpretation of the policy?
- mc32 12y agoI don't think that it's officially recognized as such, but it can't be anything else. No one can seriously believe this measure would save any significant amount of water. Not when up to 30% of water is lost in the distribution system [1] due to leaks in decades past their useful life delivery pipes. If the utilities simply stopped the leakage that would have an enormous impact --but stopping leaks is not visible and it doesn't "mobilize" and it doesn't internalize. [1] http://growingblue.com/case-studies/leakages-in-water-distribution-systems/ http://growingblue.com/case-studies/leakages-in-water-distri...
- SilasX 12y agoI've learned that it's very easy to overstimate the sophistication of the average person's views. "When people support protectionism, it's because of slogans, not understanding the literature on optimal tariffs" and all that. How about this: can you give me an example of a conservation promotion card that's more consistent with "it's symbolic" than "this actually helps"?
- mc32 12y agoIt's hard for me to think of anything more symbolic than this which can also pass as believable (action). Perhaps gov Brown saying he'll skip a shower or two would be more symbolic but also transparent.
- aetherson 12y agoMost people (rationally) do not spend much time following policy debate. Most people (rationally) take the actions of the government at face value. There's just not a large contingent of people out there who are like, "Wait, this is obvious bullshit, OH now I understand that I've been directed to go figure out an actual way to save water." The people who understand that it's bullshit already know better ways to save water. The people who don't know better ways to save water just take it at face value that the government is providing them with reasonably effective approaches to save water. This isn't a knock on the intelligence of the general public. For the most part, government does work this way. They are correct about the general pattern. Environmentalism seems particularly prone to counterexamples. It is unreasonable to expect busy people who understand correctly that they have very little marginal impact on policy to have dug into policy wonkery enough to know that environmentalism is unusually prone to these kind of ineffective actions.