6 ms·
Flickr now offers Public Domain and CC0 designations
- adrusi 12y agoI don't like it. There might be appropriate circumstances for public domain designations, but I think it seems much more attractive to laypeople than it should. Most people should probably stick to licensing their artistic work with something resembling one of the creative commons licenses. It's always been possible to designate an image to the public domain on flickr, by pasting a designation into the description, but this gave it a level of overhead that I think discouraged people who hadn't thought about it much to avoid it. Edit: This is getting downvotes, which I'm not sure I understand, but I'll assume it's because I didn't explain the problems with public domain designations. If there are other reasons, I'd appreciate a comment explaining them. IANAL, but as I understand, there's some debate over whether works can be committed to the public domain at all. This makes some individuals, and a lot of big companies, hesitant to make use of anything with a public domain designation. Most people who try to commit something to the public domain rather than picking a popular non-restrictive license do so in effort to remove all obstacles to people using it, without realizing that there might be more obstacles with a public domain designation than a CC-BY license.
- dublinben 12y agoIf I am uploading historical photographs that are in the public domain, I should absolutely have an easy way to mark them as such. Not everyone uses Flickr like Instagram to share the last neat thing they saw on the street.
- adrusi 12y agoOK, I overlooked this use-case.
- jessamyn 12y agoYeah I think you may be focusing on the "creative art" aspect of this and less on other use cases. My mom is a retired photographer and she loves seeing other people use or repurpose (and yes even sell) some of the pictures she takes. In public libraries we want a way to share images the widest way possible and don't always have our own space to do that. I get that you're concerned that people don't understand the public domain, but I think the response to that is more (and better) explanations about what it is and why it's important, not disallowing people access to tools that they want on a platform they use.
- detaro 12y agoWhich is a case where she should use CC0 and not the public domain marking.
- toomuchtodo 12y agoDon't forget to put them in the Internet Archive!
- erikano 12y agodublinben, do you have any public domain photos of nuclear bomb test explosions?
- maxerickson 12y agoYour concern is why CC released CC0. They don't seem to be ambivalent about people using it.
- adrusi 12y agoActually I have no problem with CC0, as matt4077 explained in a sibling comment, it seems pretty solid. I'm just concerned that people who aren't that interested in licensing but want to make their work as available as possible will choose the public domain option (intended for photos whose copyrights have expired) over the CC0 option.
- maxerickson 12y agoSure. I was trying to point out why people might take issue with your comment. CC0 appears in the headline and URL, and one of the early paragraphs of the link says this: But we’ve heard from our community that we’re missing two important designations: Public Domain and Creative Commons 0 (CC0). Many members of our community want to be able to upload images that are no longer protected by copyright and correctly tag them as being in the Public Domain, or they want to release their copyright entirely under CC0. So it was odd for you to not mention CC0 at all in your comment. (I've edited the last paragraph in an attempt to be less abrasive)
- ghaff 12y agoOr, presumably, which were never copyrighted as in the case of "A United States government work is prepared by an officer or employee of the United States government as part of that person's official duties." http://www.usa.gov/copyright.shtml http://www.usa.gov/copyright.shtml It's probably also worth noting in this discussion that (as per the referenced link) subjects in the photos may have privacy or publicity rights for photos used for commercial (non-editorial) purposes.
- DannyBee 12y agoContractors that prepare works for the US government can own copyright, and since most of the work for the government is now contracting, this doesn't buy a ton.
- matt4077 12y agoThe CC0 has, iirc, a 'rescue' clause in it that specifies the license's intent to retain the least amount of rights possible. A much larger problem with any free license is that it's usually impossible to check a work's complete provenance. I. e. whoever attached the license might not actually be the creator.
- sp332 12y agoBeing able to put in things in PD depends on your jurisdiction. In some countries, the original author has certain rights or responsibilities that can't be signed away. But in the USA it's pretty uncontroversial (as far as I know).
- mosburger 12y agoIt seems like there've been a crop of small sites trying to build in a "public domain stock photography" niche (http://www.pexels.com/ http://www.pexels.com/, https://stocksnap.io/ https://stocksnap.io/, and https://unsplash.com/ https://unsplash.com/ to name a few). I wonder if this will kill them off. :-/ Right now http://www.flickr.com/creativecommons http://www.flickr.com/creativecommons (where I usually head to look for creative commons photos) lists zero public domain images.
- codingdog 12y agoMarc from StockSnap.io here! We honestly couldn't be happier that Flickr is doing this and we'll be sure to add their CC0 photos to our repository.
- mosburger 12y agoI have no idea why it didn't even occur to me that the sharing went both ways - totally makes sense now. :)
- cgimmer 12y agoThe benefit of these niche sites is the high level of quality. With Flickr, you'll need to sift through a lot of not so great photos.
- usaphp 12y ago> I wonder if this will kill them off. Absolutely NOT. Quite the opposite I think. Using Flickr now pexels, stocksnap, unsplash etc.. will be able to cherrypick the best and highest quality photos from thousands useless on flickr. The main reason I am using unslplash.com and other sites is the quality of photos. The other day I tried to use a CC photo from flickr I've spent most of my time just searching for a good quality photo.
- Asparagirl 12y agoProps to Flickr for the change, and a shout out to the woman who brought the issue to their attention, librarian Jessamyn West: https://medium.com/message/why-spacex-s-photos-are-now-public-domain-178f50a62218 https://medium.com/message/why-spacex-s-photos-are-now-publi... Jessamyn also invented the warrant canary. She is rad.
- jessamyn 12y agoJust publicized, did not invent! But thank you very much.
- Octplane 12y agoMaybe some day, Flickr will actually start to care about CC a bit and log licence changes from CC licences to other licence. Current workflow allows photographers to revoke these CC licences after a while and this effectively prevents many people from using CC pictures because nobody wants to be sent to trial because he's used CC pictures with correct attributions that have mutated to All Rights Reserved suddenly. This sucks. (ramblings of an old fotopedian)
- toomuchtodo 12y agoHit the Flickr URL with Archive.org, which should capture both the image, date+time, and the CC license present at time of archive. The Wayback Machhine has been used in court before, so precedent does exist. javascript:void(open('//web.archive.org/save/'+encodeURI(document.location)))
- JacobAldridge 12y agoWhen building www.everydaydreamholiday.com we cached and screenshot all the external images used (never build a scale solution because we never, um, scaled). Interestingly, we let the photographers know as well, for a variety of reasons including the possibility they had set CC unintentionally. Most were grateful - we woke up one morning to an irate barrage from one photographer who had uploaded his image to Wikipedia without appreciating what that meant. We just changed the photo we used, and sent him a link to the Public Domain Photo on Wikipedia and a dozen other sites he might want to contact who were also using it. He apologised immediately, which was neat. Given the amazing images available under CC (even for commercial use), it frustrates me when websites try to steal protected images and get away with it. If I can find a CC Commercial Use image of marshmallows toasting over lava in Guatemala [1], you can find a fully legal image of a sunset. [1] http://everydaydreamholiday.com/2013/01/24/pacaya-volcano-antigua-guatemala-toasting-chocolate-marshmallows-over-lava/ http://everydaydreamholiday.com/2013/01/24/pacaya-volcano-an...
- sgnelson 12y agoOnly about 10 years too late?
- rasz_pl 12y agoIs it because Elon Musk made all SpaceX media Public Domain? https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20150322/07190730399/elon-musk-says-spacex-photos-are-now-fully-public-domain.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20150322/07190730399/elon-...
- dwightgunning 12y agoI've been wondering how Aviate identify and curate their lovely background images. They all come from Flickr... but not sure what groups they'd be following, or search parameters they'd be using to narrow it down. Prior to this change... I presume they would be restricted to CC-attribution?