3 ms·
Interesting format for this article. Introduction. Careful analysis of a commentary and observation. Lots of hand-waving and profanity. Back to the analysis. M
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
Interesting format for this article.
Introduction. Careful analysis of a commentary and observation. Lots of hand-waving and profanity. Back to the analysis. More profanity during a rebuttal. Drawing the analysis into a thread. Some toss-away scatology at the end. Coming to some sort of a conclusion.
I'm not sure I like it, but I really enjoyed reading the format when the author actually was getting to a point. Too many times once the "fucks" begin the author goes somewhere out on the deep end and never comes back. This looked like it had been rewritten a bit.
Having said that about the format, the content was mediocre. Maybe I've read so much commentary I'm swimming in it, but it just seemed to restate the obvious. Perhaps others got more out it.
I'm really interested to see if this style takes off, however. It might have some potential. Not a rant, but not exactly analysis either. Sort of a controlled rant.
- unalone 17y agoIt was actually a Hacker News comment that I wrote; the thread was deleted before I posted it, so I revamped it a little bit and published it, just in case it'd be something worthwhile of discussion. I'm still in the process of getting a new site launched; it's also been a handful of months since I wrote anything—my last blog, which was submitted a lot here, went offline in June—so I'm still trying to pick up what I'd developed then. My plan is to split the site into drafted articles and more polished releases, but that's not ready yet. I'm hoping within a week I'll have that. I don't think I'll be submitting it much to Hacker News, though. Even writing this much felt unnatural to me; I'm not deep enough into the stuff Hacker News is to write much that'd be of interest to the community. Hopefully I'll come up with a few things, though.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoI was just thinking that I'd like to write another well-researched and thoughtful piece for my blog but just can't seem to get excited about anything enough to start one. I'd like to see more from you, if you write any. I liked the edgy tone combined with the careful analysis and think you could make it into a nice style. A couple of times in the last week a comment has made me interested enough in a reply. There was a good thread this past week on the limits of quality in software. Is total quality always a good idea? I thought about blogging about it but taking the time to work up a good narrative and then cross-checking and rewriting several times is a major pain in the ass. So kudos for following up on this.
- unalone 17y agoYou could always subscribe (whoo, self-promotion!), but the stuff I'm interested in's a bit out there sometimes. I'm also trying to avoid the edge as best as I can. I wrote one thing in May that was submitted here without my wanting it to be, and a prominent blogger decided to freak out and rant about it. I'm trying to figure out how not to trip off stuff like that. Glad you liked this, though: That's what counts. EDIT: I just looked and these are the most-tracked posts from the last month, if that gives any idea of content: http://marinich.tumblr.com/post/200996589/talentless http://marinich.tumblr.com/post/200996589/talentless, http://marinich.tumblr.com/post/216821123/make-great-shit http://marinich.tumblr.com/post/216821123/make-great-shit, http://marinich.tumblr.com/post/220489097/art-school-blues http://marinich.tumblr.com/post/220489097/art-school-blues. So, as I said, it's a bit of a potpourri.