16 ms·
Fantastic, but that amounts to an ad-hominem attack on Snowden that doesn't reduce, in the least, the impact and validity of the data he released. We could do
by Karunamon 12y ago
Fantastic, but that amounts to an ad-hominem attack on Snowden that doesn't reduce, in the least, the impact and validity of the data he released.
We could do with more "attention seekers" willing to blow the whistle on illegal activity.
- DonHopkins 12y agoAn unsubstantiated ad-hominem attack. As long as he promises "Ill try and dig up the link(s) but" and never gets around to it, he can accuse Snowden of anything he wants to make up that fits his narrative. If he had any proof that countered the message he's trying to divert attention away from, he'd provide links to that, instead of just promising and failing to provide links that supported his unsubstantiated attack on the messenger. It's ironic how irishcoffee wants to divert attention away from the facts and instead towards Snowden himself, much more than Snowden himself wants the attention. It's a textbook example of "narcissism by proxy". Snowden isn't a narcissist just because irishcoffee wants him to be the center of attention. Ill try and dig up the link(s) but I'm not full of shit so here it is: http://www.homelandsecuritynewswire.com/dr20130609-edward-snowden-an-nsa-contractor-employee-says-he-is-the-source-of-nsa-leaks http://www.homelandsecuritynewswire.com/dr20130609-edward-sn... Snowden also told the Guardian that he does not want his personal story to divert attention from the larger story revealed by his disclosures. “I know the media likes to personalize political debates, and I know the government will demonize me.” “I really want the focus to be on these documents and the debate which I hope this will trigger among citizens around the globe about what kind of world we want to live in.” He added: “My sole motive is to inform the public as to that which is done in their name and that which is done against them.”
- irishcoffee 12y agoI'm a single dad working full time. Time is hard to come by, I'll post the damn link when I have time to find it.
- DonHopkins 12y agoYou said people were misinformed, then you changed the topic to Snowden's personality and high school record. Just what misinformation are you referring to, and can you provide some non-anecdotal evidence to correct the misinformation? Are you saying that it's Snowden's personality and high school record that people are misinformed about, or the NSA? Who was misinformed and who was spreading misinformation when Clapper directly lied under oath when he was testifying in front of congress? How about focusing attention on the content of the leaks, and the misinformation the NSA itself is spreading, instead of Snowden's personality? I'm more interested to know how your DoD friends think about what was leaked, and what Clapper lied about, than who leaked it.
- irishcoffee 12y agoI said "dates back to high school." The 'dates back to' phrase, in general English, is a phrase that serves to establish the start of a time-lined pattern of behavior. I don't think you're doing it intentionally, and I may have poorly phrased my quick response, but I feel like you took my response quite a bit out of context. Everyone was trying to figure themselves out back in high school. I'm not judging that at all. I can't speak to Clapper, only he can. I don't think its a far stretch of the imagination to say that there are far, far bigger things at play than his testimony. Have you ever visited the NSA museum? It's open to the public. The US actually intercepted the message the night before the Pearl Harbor attack happened, but didn't have the resources to decode it in time. (https://www.nsa.gov/about/cryptologic_heritage/museum/virtual_tour/museum_tour_text.shtml https://www.nsa.gov/about/cryptologic_heritage/museum/virtua... ctrl+f 'harbor' should be the 3rd/last result). The point being, perhaps there are bigger things at play. I can't speak for my 'DoD friends' as you ask, mostly because they don't talk about the specifics of their work. I asked a buddy once if they monitor US citizens. He said something to the effect of: "we don't need to monitor people, they monitor themselves via facebook, twitter, and instagram. How hard do you think it is to find publicly available information?" After I was 'enlightened' to that, it made sense. People literally put what they cooked for dinner on the internet. Finding out information about someone is not hard, because the information is volunteered. No laws are broken, no rights are violated. If you care about your privacy, get off social media. Also, as much as this may annoy you, NSA (as is my understanding) doesn't care about domestic information at all. That is the jurisdiction of the FBI. This is one of the things my friends find so amusing, people seem to not understand this. That being said, if a packet goes from DC to GA to CN to CA tp US, the foreign hop means: its not domestic traffic. As we have very recently seen, CN has very little issue mucking with traffic that crosses their direct sphere of influence. Perhaps its much harder to tell what kind of foreign traffic should be inspected, and maybe the initial location of origin was spoofed, and its not that easy to figure all this stuff out. Perhaps the smartest people employed by the DoD aren't any smarter than the people that frequent this site, and there are insanely large-scale peoples to be solved, and their fucking hard to solve? I don't think you're going to like anything I've just said, but just think about it. Do you really believe that the DoD cares about people that are not a direct threat to national security? Do you really think the DoD has the resources to actually monitor, in real time, the general US population? Perhaps, unless you get a satellite phone call from Pakistan, you're not even interesting enough to get your area code noticed? The government can hardly pass a damn budget. They're not that organized. How many people lie on their tax returns every year and get away with it? If the government can't effectively audit the almighty dollar, do you really think they're Big Brother? Edit: I can't edit my parent response, this is the best I can do. I am looking for a specific article that detailed Snowden from highschool up to his current life. I really will try my best to find this article, and will update as soon as I can find it. My 1 y/o daughter just went to bed, and I will quickly be following suit. I would honesly be willing to do some sort of silly HN-style AMA if people are interested. I'm not some internet troll. I went to Chesapeake High school, which is in the same athletic district as Arundel High school, Where Snowden went. I have no desire or reason to grandstand about anything.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoWow talk about ad-hominem, that's a brass-bound example right there. Just post the link without the running commentary on another contributors character, please.
- scintill76 12y agoI'll agree it was a bit mean, but I have sympathy for the annoyance that prompted it. irishcoffee responded to a thoughtful comment about how culture can shape attitudes, with a one-line quip about how his DoD buddies say communities like HN are clueless, following up with specific but unsourced claims about Snowden being an attention-seeker, and ultimately plays the card "I'm a single dad working full time. Time is hard to come by" as an excuse for why he didn't source them. IMO then it's not fallacious to expose that for the lacking and possibly deliberately disingenuous argumentative tactic that it is. If he chooses to post actual evidence, we should move on to discussing that. As long as he only presents his "hominem" (in the form of secondhand claims from his friends, what he supposedly read once, and what the other demands on his personal time are) as evidence, ad-hominem is the only response he'll get and deserve.
- irishcoffee 12y agoI appreciate your candor. I would like to back up my claims, and given the time, would do so at my lunch break/free time tomorrow. I have no reason to lie and nothing to hide.
- scintill76 12y agoThanks. I realize I may have sounded like I was definitively accusing you of lying or manipulating us. I'm not, but a more accurate description would be that so far your behavior looks suspicious and you haven't given very solid information. Although I tend to "side with" Snowden, I would not be surprised if there is more to him than meets the eye, so I would be interested in seeing if he has a history of grandstanding. (On the other hand, as others have pointed out, if what he has released is correct and against the will of the citizens/law/human rights, does it really matter if the disclosure fits a pattern of attention-seeking from the messenger?) P.S. What may be irking some commenters is that HN threads are so "time-sensitive." In another hour this thread will probably slip off the front page and out of mind. So some people may be anxious to see a source before that happens. Or they downvoted so agressively, so that unsourced claims will be seen by fewer people during the small period of time the thread is active, while it could legitimately take you a few days to find a source.