2 ms·
I was thinking of exactly that absolute sense. I consider that sense trivial, in that it won't ever affect our economic situation. (I assume we'll have some oth
by jessaustin 12y ago
I was thinking of exactly that absolute sense. I consider that sense trivial, in that it won't ever affect our economic situation. (I assume we'll have some other way of making plastics centuries from now when extraction tech finally stops improving.)
- jacquesm 12y ago> I consider that sense trivial, in that it won't ever affect our economic situation. It is already affecting our economic situation in a very real sense and it has done so catastrophically on several occasions in the past. Imagine a world where oil costs $500 / barrel and you're looking at a totally different world than the one we live in today. That would completely alter the balance of power.
- jessaustin 12y agoWell, let's not bicker. If you're contemplating sustained (not temporary spikes!) $500/b then you don't agree with TFA's claim that "energy prices are going relentlessly down", although you state above that the feasible extraction "border keeps on shifting". Presumably you envision some factor that will stop innovation in extraction, which would be interesting to learn.
- jacquesm 12y agoWe are awash in energy, that's not the problem. The problem is in capturing that energy and that energy comes in many forms and only oil currently allows you to project power on a global scale. "It's raining soup, and all we have is forks" And energy prices for say electricity could be going down while energy prices for petroleum could be going through the roof. Utility pricing for energy is historically coupled to the oil price but that won't be sustainable as an ever larger chunk of the energy consumed electrically is generated by renewables or nuclear. The big wildcards are: - ITER - further dramatic reduction in solar panel pricing - mass transportation using electricity - battery technology - the first successful long range electrical airplane
- YokoZar 12y agoImagine a world where there exists a perfect substitute for oil at $150 / barrel through some form of magical synthesis using renewable energy sources. Today, that world would look almost identical, since oil has never been expensive enough to justify using such a hypothetical technology. But it would never look like the naiive "oil is a finite resource and must therefore always increase in price" world foretold by peak oil doomsayers.