17 ms·
I think people often underestimate it, but one of the biggest influences you can have -- I mean you, the HN reader! -- may be cultural. People who work on buil
by schoen 12y ago
I think people often underestimate it, but one of the biggest influences you can have -- I mean you, the HN reader! -- may be cultural.
People who work on building surveillance, people who have done it, people who may do it in the future, are your classmates in your CS program, your colleagues in your startup, your neighbors, your fellow conference attendees, you.
Folks who work at NSA (and all the other places that don't get so much press) read xkcd religiously, they go to DEF CON, they have Linux and math t-shirts, they read HN, they are reading this thread right now, and all the other threads.
If people like you in the cultures that you're part of decide that surveillance is cool and exciting, that's more talent to take the billions of dollars and vast intellectual challenges of figuring out how to eliminate the vestiges of privacy. If they decide it's uncool and sketchy, that's more talent that goes elsewhere and does something else.
There are many overlapping subcultures in technology and they don't all understand or talk to each other that much, and plenty of technology employers are recruiting out of many different subcultures, so you can't assume that the culture you create in your circles will control the path of technology. But the cultural attitudes of people in the tech world can have a powerful effect on what people decide is worth working on.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- pron 12y agoThat's quite a battle to wage, considering that at least two of Silicon Valley's largest companies are built around surveillance and invasion of privacy, and their core business model is selling their user's private information.
- discardorama 12y ago> I think people often underestimate it, but one of the biggest influences you can have -- I mean you, the HN reader! -- may be cultural. > People who work on building surveillance, people who have done it, people who may do it in the future, are your classmates in your CS program, your colleagues in your startup, your neighbors, your fellow conference attendees, you. Exactly. I wish more people here would realise this. The powers-that-be do realize this, and are concerned about it. I remember when the "Fifth Estate" movie came out (which was critical of Assange), everyone in our company (a large tech company that I won't name) was given free tickets (and the afternoon off) to go see it. First time ever we were given such free tickets; I wonder why?
- oskarth 12y agoThat's absolutely ridiculous. I assume the same didn't happen for Citizen Four (which was actually a real movie as opposed to a thinly disguised hit piece). You should name and shame the company, even if you do so anonymously.
- jacquesm 12y agoNo, he doesn't have to name and shame any company. It's enough to know that such activities happen.
- Lawtonfogle 12y agoI'm not going to turn in the theif. It is enough to know that people will steal. (The difference here being that in one case the government is the judge/jury/executioner and in the other it is the realm of public opinion.)
- jacquesm 12y agoNo, it's not that. It's that it may very well be possible to trace this conversation back to a single person and that could easily jeopardize that persons employment.
- Create 12y agoWe begin therefore where they are determined not to end, with the question whether any form of democratic self-government, anywhere, is consistent with the kind of massive, pervasive, surveillance into which the Unites States government has led not only us but the world. This should not actually be a complicated inquiry. http://snowdenandthefuture.info/events.html http://snowdenandthefuture.info/events.html
- Lawtonfogle 12y agoThat is a separate (and I personally think far more valid) argument. My protest was against the argument, not against the outcome.
- ethanbond 12y agoSerious question: Do you include those working at Google and Facebook under this group? Or equivalently ad-driven services? Those two companies (and their siblings) are certainly the most fruitful of trees for surveillance organizations (government or otherwise) to pluck information from. Further, they're not collecting this data for any purpose – vague, questionable, and slippery though it may be – of doing "good" or "protecting our country." They're doing it, solely and without an attempt at justification, for ad revenues. And they're taking tens of thousands (if not hundreds?) of some of the brightest minds in tech away from things like drug discovery, climate change, energy research, etc. Not trying to start a flame war, nor am I drawing equivalencies between Facebook and the NSA. I'm actually just legitimately curious how you think we can segment this spectrum.
- nemothekid 12y ago>And they're taking tens of thousands (if not hundreds?) of some of the brightest minds in tech away from things like drug discovery, climate change, energy research, etc. Taking them away from those things? I doubt it - the top talent will always be sold to the highest bidder and its unlikely "climate change research" is a segment that can support thousands of of mid-high six figure salaries. Next while these companies do collect a large amount of personal data - their purpose is clear and as is their boundaries. There is a strong effort to keep adopt data secure - if a user was found using private facebook data to stalk loved ones[1] I don't doubt thats activity that would (1) noticed by their systems they have in place to prevent data from ending up in the wrong place and (2) they would be fired for. Lastly with Google and Facebook you have a choice - its still in your control - if you want to use these services or not and it doesn't require a secret court to challenge them. [1] http://www.slate.com/blogs/future_tense/2013/08/23/bloomberg_report_nsa_employees_have_deliberately_abused_their_power.html http://www.slate.com/blogs/future_tense/2013/08/23/bloomberg...
- MichaelGG 12y agoFacebook's trying to take that choice away by getting ISPs in some countries to give free Facebook access. I see billboards in Guatemala hyping up that if you're out of credit on your account, they will still allow you to use Facebook and WhatsApp. So for many low-income people, where having to pay $10 or so for some light data plan isn't possible, their only choice to be online is Facebook. Sure, it's a choice. Just like using the Internet is a choice. Like using phones is a choice. Like choosing automobiles over walking is a choice. But not all choices are equal.
- Taek 12y agoI have a few friends who either work for the NSA or have worked for the NSA, and there's a stigma that follows them around. They get shamed for it (under the guise of humor), and people are clearly uneasy talking about things like drug use around said friends. At least in my community, there's a strong negative pressure and stigma associated with working for certain parts of the government. And I guarantee that this impacts the NSA's ability to recruit from our talented pool of developers.
- oxide 12y agoShh, Jim is coming. hide the PCP.
- tomjen3 12y agoGood. What can we do to make the stigma harder?
- pekk 12y agoAnd what if the same stigma tactics are used against you in the workplace because you are for gay marriage, or are pro-abortion, or agree with gun control? Suddenly it does not sound so good any more.
- tomjen3 12y agoEthics stances are not value neutral, there are right and wrong decisions and there should be a stigma for being against other peoples freedom.
- Kalium 12y ago> Folks who work at NSA (and all the other places that don't get so much press) read xkcd religiously, they go to DEF CON, they have Linux and math t-shirts, they read HN, they are reading this thread right now, and all the other threads. I know some. I called them coworker and in some cases still call them friend. A feel sorry for a great many of them. They are highly skilled network attack specialists, with basically no way to apply their skills other than working for the NSA. Even if they want out, they have no viable alternative. It's terrible.
- totalrobe 12y agoPen testing not a viable alternative?
- Kalium 12y agoPen testing is a viable alternative in the same way that driving a car is an alternative to designing an engine. When your specialty is in finding novel exploits, there's not much of a market for you outside the government-o-sphere. In practical terms, pen tests are typically not focused on finding novel exploits. Nevermind the vast difference in career expectations between salaried government work and consulting.
- totalrobe 12y agoThat is a good point. Ex military often have trouble finding jobs that match their skillsets as well. Not many civilian jobs encourage you to annihilate the denizens of under-developed, resource rich regions.
- Kalium 12y agoThere's actually quite a lot of value in finding and fixing exploits. It's just that many companies prefer the illusion that $1k is a reasonable bounty for SQLi.
- count 12y agoIn the same way that being a local cop is an alternative to being in the Special Forces.
- irishcoffee 12y ago> ...they are reading this thread right now, and all the other threads. No, I don't work for the DoD. I live in the Washington-Baltimore metro area and know people who work for government agencies under the DoD. N = 1 sample size, all the people I know employed by DoD agencies highly amused at how misinformed places like HN are about places like NSA.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- bjelkeman-again 12y agoOf course, we will not be informed, as it is Secret, with a big S. But, after Snowden, we are somewhat better informed than we were. And this is good. We should be even better informed and this should be about how we want to structure our society in the future. But that doesn't fit the current political climate and possibly will not, for quite a while.
- irishcoffee 12y agoN, that is my whole point. People are very much misinformed. Horribly misinformed. Ill try and dig up the link(s) but snowden had a history of grandstanding that dates back to highschool. He was not a noble whistleblower, he wanted attention. edit: typo
- jacquesm 12y agoTime for one of your friends to step forward and correct the record then. You know, for the 'greater good'.
- Karunamon 12y agoFantastic, but that amounts to an ad-hominem attack on Snowden that doesn't reduce, in the least, the impact and validity of the data he released. We could do with more "attention seekers" willing to blow the whistle on illegal activity.
- trose 12y agoOne issue I've heard from a couple friends that worked for the NSA is that they have no idea what they're working on. One friend said he would just get specifications for input into a module and what the module should output. He wrote tests around the specs and wrote the module but had no idea what it was part of. I've also met programmers who are just out to get a stable job. I bet the NSA looks for people like this. "Sit here, do your job, get this paycheck"
- jacquesm 12y ago> One issue I've heard from a couple friends that worked for the NSA is that they have no idea what they're working on. http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0123755/ http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0123755/
- claytonjy 12y agoWhen I was getting my math degree, the department head frequently suggested we should work for the NSA for two reasons: they are the single largest employer of mathematicians, and you can't take your work home with you. I graduated before the Snowden revelations; not sure if he has changed his tune or not.
- Kalium 12y agoI expect both those reasons still hold up. Ethics-driven unemployment sounds great until you start getting hungry.
- Peaker 12y agoThe NSA is looking for top talent. For them, the alternative is not hunger, but a slightly worse salary or less interesting job.
- Kalium 12y agoMy understanding of the job market for mathematicians is that it's not nearly as friendly as that for programmers, but I'm far from knowledgeable here.
- bootload 12y ago"If people like you in the cultures that you're part of decide that surveillance is cool and exciting, that's more talent to take the billions of dollars and vast intellectual challenges of figuring out how to eliminate the vestiges of privacy. If they decide it's uncool and sketchy, that's more talent that goes elsewhere and does something else." And why you shouldn't work for the NSA. This scene from 'Good Will Hunting' comes to mind ~ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UrOZllbNarw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UrOZllbNarw
- pekk 12y ago> I think people often underestimate it, but one of the biggest influences you can have -- I mean you, the HN reader! -- may be cultural. By the same reasoning, people can haze each other (in school, the workplace, etc.) for their positions on things like abortion as a "cultural influence." Is that ethical, though? If I personally, on reflection disagree with you about Julian Assange, should I be blacklisted from the industry? Serious question.