7 ms·
I own a Surface Pro 3, and when I first got it I'd describe the experience as just mediocre. However Microsoft has been aggressively updating the software as ha
by Someone1234 12y ago
I own a Surface Pro 3, and when I first got it I'd describe the experience as just mediocre. However Microsoft has been aggressively updating the software as has Intel, and as a result of those effects the SP3 has really stepped up and is now quite a good little tablet/ultrabook combo.
I only have two remaining concerns with the SP3: My i5 version continues to get extremely hot near the middle of the device (e.g. when gaming or using a lot of CPU, like BitTorrent). Worryingly hot in fact. And the Magsafe like connector fails right near the magnet (the wire un-twirls), see Amazon's reviews of the power supply for examples and photos.
I think this new 10.1" could be interesting form-factor for this device and a top end Atom CPU really distinguishes it from the SP3. The naming is getting a little confusing, I checked the posting date to make sure this wasn't an old announcement for the SP3. Surface 3, Surface Pro 3, Surface 2 RT, uhh...
PS - Does anyone else keep seeing a completely white screen when visiting Microsoft's web-sites. It goes completely white for like 5 seconds and only then does any content load. I am using Chrome retail latest.
- Throwaway1224 12y agoI'm confused... You say you own "a Surface Pro 3" but MSFT is only just announcing "the Surface Pro 3". Some other people are saying they own a Surface Pro 3. How can this be? It's too early in the morning for this...
- SmellyGeekBoy 12y ago> PS - Does anyone else keep seeing a completely white screen when visiting Microsoft's web-sites. It goes completely white for like 5 seconds and only then does any content load. I am using Chrome retail latest. Yes, this has been happening to me as well for the past week or so. Also on Chrome latest.
- danieldk 12y agoSurface 3, Surface Pro 3, Surface 2 RT, uhh... Well, at least it is better than before, when people bought a Surface tablet expecting it to run regular x86 desktop applications, because Windows. Having nearly the same name (Surface RT vs. Surface Pro) didn't really help.
- martijn_himself 12y agoMicrosoft has taken a leaf out of Apple's book and simplified product lines and names, and are up front about availability and configurations. Other PC and laptop manufacturers seem to go out of their way to make things as confusing for the consumer as possible. I was briefly contemplating getting the Asus Zenbook UX305 but it is available in different configurations in (different) global markets, with the European market seemingly getting a very raw deal in terms of RAM and SSD size. As always it is unclear where I should buy them (obligatory nonfunctioning map with resellers on their website) and when they are available. They also have way too many different models available. I swear I will never buy anything again from manufacturers that do this.
- stinkytaco 12y agoI feel like Apple's fallen of the wagon on this one, however. Look at the iPad line. From what I can tell there are at least 6 different models and all of those are available in different storage capacities and with different connectivity options. Additionally, there are 3 different iPhone models. If you're a consumer walking into Best Buy for an iPad, I can definitely see you getting a raw deal if you don't already know what you want.
- gress 12y agoThere are 5 iPad models. What have the 3 iPhone models got to do with buying an iPad?
- biot 12y agoiPhone model likely refers to iPads with cellular data.
- npunt 12y agoI respectfully disagree, there's only two raw deals I see with your example: buying a 16GB model, and going to Best Buy. There were always 6 SKUs for any given region (3 size options and 2 connectivity), and now there are 3 colors, and the iPad Mini form factor. That's a lot when you add it all up analytically, but that's not how consumers experience it -- they're not presented with 36 different iPads and asked to figure it out. The consumer experience hasn't fundamentally changed since the original iPad, because each option is understandable by the user rather than buried under a confusing set of names [1]. iPads with cell radios are really only for people who already know what it is and want it, so that choice point is reduced. The form factor (iPad or iPad mini) is something the consumer can hold in their hands and figure out, as is color. Those are tangible, immediate, human choices. RAW DEAL #1: Storage, and specifically the 16GB model, is the biggest issue with iOS products because later you'll find you can't download many apps or have too many photos before storage fills up. Bad user experience. See past iOS upgrades for outrage. > if you don't already know what you want Apple has invested huge amounts in iPad's branding and awareness, that translates to consumers understanding more and walking in having at least a vague understanding of which form factor and color they would like, with a visit being more of a confirmation of the choice. Note that Apple's other branding reinforces this, by sharing color across iPad, iPhone, and now MacBook, meaning more possibility for consumers to come in closer to having made a choice. Same with storage capacity if they evaluated iPhones. They also don't name it something different each time they launch a new one, they reuse the name [2]. The brand value/awareness of 'iPad' alone is probably 100x+ that of Asus or Surface. Brand awareness persists between products, so with 800m iOS devices out there, each SKU represents maybe 20m iOS devices worth of brand recognition that precedes it [3]. RAW DEAL #2: Walking into Best Buy -> raw deal. For. sure. There's a reason Apple built stores - its to control the experience and reduce choice anxiety through consistent messaging, better presentation of products, positive sales experience, few choices, etc. Best Buy shits that away and you wind up in a chemical-smelling store filled with crappy products that subtly increases paradox of choice, talking to a spikey hair drone that doesn't understand the product, forcing comparison to unlike products, putting pressure on you to buy the replacement plan or accessories or shit you don't need, with flashing images from a wall of TVs nearby sucking your attention away from your purchase decision like the TV with a skateboarding video on at the bar you're at with friends that keeps pulling you away from the conversation you were just having. Ugh. Best Buy. [1] Apple made this mistake in the 90s with the Performa brand, introducing too many models causing consumer confusion (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Macintosh_Performa http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Macintosh_Performa). Thus, iPad is iPad, and specs do not play into the name of the product the user buys. Most other competitors such as aforementioned Asus Zenbook UX305 just don't get it. [2] Because people think in years, not obscure model numbers ('oh thats the iPad from two years ago' vs 'oh thats the Zenbook umm... UX31A? UX42VS?'). [3] Yeah this is a super janky way of representing brand awareness, its just to illustrate how much more carrying capacity the brand has for variations relative to others. Marketing budget might be another way, except that doesn't account for people's actual purchases and their sharing with friends, plus the ridiculously valuable free marketing you get from the media talking about the device. Hence, the big unveil strategy.
- freehunter 12y agoIs it any different from from the Macbook versus Macbook Pro? Massively different devices. The odd duck out is the Surface RT line, which seems to be abandoned now, removing that confusion.
- mikeash 12y agoI don't think the MacBook [Pro] is a flattering comparison. Apple is rapidly falling away from their traditional simple and obvious product lines, and the current MacBook lineup is extremely confusing to a lot of people.
- rickyc091 12y agoApple actually makes a good way of differentiating the products on their site (http://store.apple.com/us/mac/compare http://store.apple.com/us/mac/compare). On top of that their sales people will generally ask you what your purpose for the laptop is as to not oversell you on something you don't need.
- kaolinite 12y agoMy dad went into an Apple Store intending to spend £1000 on a MacBook. He ended up coming home with a £400 iPad which suited his needs better (and which he loves). I couldn't respect the sales staff more for that.
- tim333 12y agoYeah - one of the nicest things about the Apple stores. Presumably the staff are not on commissions pushing them to make sales. You can go in and just check your email and no one bothers you. In contrast I used to live opposite a Sony store and tried wandering in to check if they's invented any cool stuff lately and there would be a sales guy in my face with 'which model are you interesting in buying sir?' within about 20 seconds. Shame really. Scared me off and presumably other people who like Sony as the store was empty and closed soon after.
- 12y ago
- daphneokeefe 12y agoNo delay on Microsoft.com in the Mobile Mercury browser nor Chrome 41 on iPad.
- aasarava 12y agoAmazon's Kindle Fire naming is equally painful. There's a Fire HD 7 and a Fire HD 7". Try buying accessories for the right one.
- freehunter 12y agoBut then again, try buying accessories for the Kindle Not-Fire. First off, you have to figure out how to search for Kindle without Fire results coming up. Then you have to try to figure out which generation you have, when Amazon themselves don't tell you that anywhere.
- Corrado 12y agoMaybe hardware manufacturers should do like car companies do and use a model year. "Yea, I have a MacBook Pro 2015 but its about the same as my Surface Pro 2017".
- mikeash 12y agoThat's actually how Apple does it. For example, the official names of the various Mac Pro models are "Mac Pro (Late 2013)," "Mac Pro (Mid 2012)," etc. It's a bit confusing because they don't show the year part prominently, so you have to do some legwork to figure out what you're buying or what you already have, but it works out OK.
- Raptor22 12y agoI think you can find this in About this Mac.
- josefresco 12y agoI'm curious, what specifically about SP3 improved your experience?
- wlesieutre 12y agoWifi drivers for one. They were awful at launch.
- Someone1234 12y agoToo many to list but... - WiFi/Bluetooth drivers (they were terrible at release) - Intel HD graphics drivers (improved battery usage, responsiveness in some applications, and also seems to have reduced heat slightly (when running on battery)) - They improved the touchpad's auto-disable thing while using the keyboard (so it actually worked!). - Touchscreen accuracy improvements both for pen and finger. - More pen customisation (with associated app) - Several crash bugs fix (e.g. BSoD during shutdown) - A bunch of sleep specific fixes (e.g. faster entry and exit from sleep, a crash bug here too, and so on). - Others... Here's a full-ish list: http://www.microsoft.com/surface/en-us/support/install-update-activate/pro-3-update-history http://www.microsoft.com/surface/en-us/support/install-updat...
- dworin 12y agoI had the same issue with the power connector, and when I contacted Microsoft support (I used the online chat), they sent me a new one right away. It looks like the new one is designed slightly differently so that the fraying won't happen. For what it's worth, I had the fraying problem on my old MacBook Air charter too.
- sliverstorm 12y agoWorryingly hot in fact. It may not actually be a problem at all. CPUs can run safely up to ~70C or so, which is 160F. This means thin tablets are becoming constrained by what you can safely touch, rather than what is safe for the CPU. http://www.colorado.edu/engineering/MCEN/MCEN5166/supplementary/Good_Thermal_Smartphones_06249032.pdf http://www.colorado.edu/engineering/MCEN/MCEN5166/supplement...
- quotedmycode 12y agoOnce they get to that temperature, which can happen in a matter of minutes if you are doing something cpu intensive, they throttle the cpu, thus slowing everything down, which is counter productive if you are doing something cpu intensive. They can spread that heat over a larger area, thus heating up the whole device, or they can put in active cooling, or they can put in a cpu that doesn't get that hot. The Atom is a cpu that shouldn't get that hot. It's probably not as fast as the i5, but it can certainly run Chrome and other apps though probably games would suffer. The issues we see with Surface Pro 3 overheating is where it's not expected to overheat, such as using Chrome. Using IE is fine, but when you use Chrome it overheats. Turns out a lot of the time it's related to ABP (adblock plus). Switching to uBlock seems to resolve most of the overheating of Chrome.
- smcg 12y agoChrome on Surface has always been a giant mess. Not that Google has an incentive to fix it.
- nacs 12y agoThose temperatures are OK on a desktop or sometimes even a laptop but having something running that hot in your hand / lap is not so comfortable.
- sliverstorm 12y agoThat's the point. He says "worryingly", I'm saying you probably don't have to worry. There's probably no risk of internal damage at "warm/hot to the touch" temps
- rbanffy 12y ago> My i5 version continues to get extremely hot near the middle of the device This non-pro is Atom-based. I like to say while the i3/5/7 are optimized for price/performance, the Atoms are optimized for low thermal dissipation (which can be painful if you spend your day in Eclipse). But if the Pro is mediocre, that doesn't speak well of the plain 3...
- JBiserkov 12y ago>Intel has been aggressively updating the software Indeed. With the January update to GPU drivers, the SP3 is able to drive a 4k monitor @ 60Hz while still having the built-in display on, also @ 60Hz. Not all 4k monitors though, only the older, MST ones. See https://www.reddit.com/r/Surface/comments/2v7te8/reduce_cpu_usage_by_utorrent/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Surface/comments/2v7te8/reduce_cpu_... For gaming, get an USB fan.
- john_other_john 12y agoOh boy.... Pro 2 user here, and to better understand it for work reasons, I made it primary machine for over 8 Hurst / day since last April. Until I guessed I had reached the point no software updates were likely. I am genuinely disappointed. Despite the initial impression of execution was positive enough for me to have a eight week or so honeymoon. I think the idea has legs longer term. For me, of many many issues I encountered, it is IE tablet / touch version which has been become what in hindsight ought to be a showstopper. There is no alternative for touch use without contortions. Yet IE left to far too much grief. I guess here nobody will freak if I had 50 or more tabs open. Not a usual search decision list to keep handy. But without respite, IE would seize and redraw, reload no matter how cache sized (which pretty much needs a trip to the registry) and commonly crash. I was heavily reliant on a 3G mifi connection during most of this time. It is beyond my comprehension how a browser in theory close to OS that knows I am using a metered connection in particular with long latency, can be shipped with a addiction to cache miss reloads. I would close down tabs carefully and exit IE (touch). Reboot and .... The entire past session and even sometimes earlier sessions would reload. I found that bookmarks did not store or persist. It just goes on and on from there. This is merely the highlight commentary. But within nearly 80 single spaced pages of description, not solely concerning IE behavior, I realized I had been building a "not fit for purpose" complaint. I did not exclusively encounter the IE problems with only a few tab open, either. I actually do think that the shipping state of the Pro 2 would, if I had understood beforehand, guaranteed I did not purchase it. I don't maintain a web presence or have access to a appropriate place to publish my extensive review. But I am thinking what to do about that, right now. Although I speak very casually about what ought to touch upon different memory models for touch aps from Metro thinking, the process sumps I ran, API monitoring, attempts at querying NTFS to find "lost" writes and a determined effort to seek out any possible corruption of the SSD writes.... all of which were reasons in terms of finding free time which delayed my formal complaint so far beyond when I first became incredibly frustrated, I hope I may be permitted here a modicum of credibility that I did at least have a fair go at figuring out anything that might be otherwise wrong. I very much like this format. This new 3 might be just the ticket for lightweight moments needing a x86 device I can carry substitute another tablet. Yet, the sad ending to this, is that in my private but professionally minded quest to bring a 5th decade brain out of atrophy and into the current device world, this is the punching: I bought a Sony Xperia Z3 Compact. For everything I commonly did with my Surface Pro 2, exception anything requiring long concentration, I suddenly found myself using the Z3c for entire days and continue to in cactuses it primarily. Even when I have a environment up to write and edit, how exactly can it not plain suck to be fighting with a browser when piling through API refs or SO to check out whichever. That was simply a concentration breaker. I probably will check out the new one as above. But I have rarely found anything so frustrating in primary use as intended or advertised....\ And I get done faster with my Z3c, for too many tasks. I almost feel bad at the tome I am about to dump on Microsoft,
- john_other_john 12y agoOh boy.... Pro 2 user here, and to better understand it for work reasons, I made it primary machine for over 8 Hurst / day since last April. Until I guessed I had reached the point no software updates were likely. I am genuinely disappointed. Despite the initial impression of execution was positive enough for me to have a eight week or so honeymoon. I think the idea has legs longer term. For me, of many many issues I encountered, it is IE tablet / touch version which has been become what in hindsight ought to be a showstopper. There is no alternative for touch use without contortions. Yet IE left to far too much grief. I guess here nobody will freak if I had 50 or more tabs open. Not a usual search decision list to keep handy. But without respite, IE would seize and redraw, reload no matter how cache sized (which pretty much needs a trip to the registry) and commonly crash. I was heavily reliant on a 3G mifi connection during most of this time. It is beyond my comprehension how a browser in theory close to OS that knows I am using a metered connection in particular with long latency, can be shipped with a addiction to cache miss reloads. I would close down tabs carefully and exit IE (touch). Reboot and .... The entire past session and even sometimes earlier sessions would reload. I found that bookmarks did not store or persist. It just goes on and on from there. This is merely the highlight commentary. But within nearly 80 single spaced pages of description, not solely concerning IE behavior, I realized I had been building a "not fit for purpose" complaint. I did not exclusively encounter the IE problems with only a few tab open, either. I actually do think that the shipping state of the Pro 2 would, if I had understood beforehand, guaranteed I did not purchase it. I don't maintain a web presence or have access to a appropriate place to publish my extensive review. But I am thinking what to do about that, right now. Although I speak very casually about what ought to touch upon different memory models for touch aps from Metro thinking, the process sumps I ran, API monitoring, attempts at querying NTFS to find "lost" writes and a determined effort to seek out any possible corruption of the SSD writes.... all of which were reasons in terms of finding free time which delayed my formal complaint so far beyond when I first became incredibly frustrated, I hope I may be permitted here a modicum of credibility that I did at least have a fair go at figuring out anything that might be otherwise wrong. I very much like this format. This new 3 might be just the ticket for lightweight moments needing a x86 device I can carry substitute another tablet. Yet, the sad ending to this, is that in my private but professionally minded quest to bring a 5th decade brain out of atrophy and into the current device world, this is the punching: I bought a Sony Xperia Z3 Compact. For everything I commonly did with my Surface Pro 2, exception anything requiring long concentration, I suddenly found myself using the Z3c for entire days and continue to in cactuses it primarily. Even when I have a environment up to write and edit, how exactly can it not plain suck to be fighting with a browser when piling through API refs or SO to check out whichever. That was simply a concentration breaker. I probably will check out the new one as above. But I have rarely found anything so frustrating in primary use as intended or advertised....\ And I get done faster with my Z3c, for too many tasks. I almost feel bad at the tome I am about to dump on Microsoft, but I felt strongly enough about the potential utility to me of this device format, I am not writing any consumer report complaint. I very much want my observations, which had me regularly disrupted from my flow even of corridor meetings, to be appreciated. I am to concerned by my experience to plump for a new model without most definitely being certain I can get refund after sufficient time to go the necessary test distance. And absolutely no way will I let myself think a future update will solve anything. That last point, the confidence that updates will resolve glaring problems, is the kind of issue that would have me shut the entire teams to standstill (per Toyota System) until this was understood. At present, the market for any Surface is small and tolerant and sophisticated. But this is if unsolved, a PR problem that could shut down regular consumer retail dead. I may exaggerate, and as well two years ago I thought neither Lumina WP nor Android phones (I tested a variety from mid to flagship) were persuasive, but the change in experience since then has blown my mind. Still yet so much I would do on WP or 'Droid. But the complete experience is entirely impressive. Not only that, but my very elderly family members who are most immune to me thrusting new toys into their hands in ever desperate attempts to connect our diaspora family, are finally impressed. Because above all the response of apps is good enough to prevent a kind of "Senior Valley" in which UX and app latency makes them just pause enough to think they "did it wrong". The story will continue nevertheless.... it feels like the second or wherever we are counting, Act, is not the dramatic finale but having introduced the Dramatis Personae, we are getting some action sufficient to appreciate full blown characters.