3 ms·
Well, the basic problem is that the city councils of Valley "cities" (ie: overgrown, egotistical suburbs) keep refusing to build the kind of dense housing, mixe
by eli_gottlieb 12y ago
Well, the basic problem is that the city councils of Valley "cities" (ie: overgrown, egotistical suburbs) keep refusing to build the kind of dense housing, mixed-price developments, and mixed-usage buildings that make real cities function. In fact, they often explicitly refuse to build any new housing at all, insisting that transplanted tech employees just find somewhere else.
So the companies have to build their own damn housing.
Welcome to the outcome of NIMBYism.
- pconner 12y agoAs someone who will have to relocate to the bay area soon, all of this is incredibly worrying. I thought it was just SF that had major opposition to new development. I didn't realize that issue extended to the south bay as well.
- khuey 12y agoIt's much worse in parts of the peninsula (e.g. Palo Alto) than it is in SF proper. Mountain View just got a pro-development city council though, so there is hope.
- davidw 12y agoThat whole area has some pretty screwy politics. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bay_Area_Rapid_Transit#/media/File:BARTMapDay.svg http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bay_Area_Rapid_Transit#/media/F... - see how their rapid transit system excludes most of "silicon valley"? But on the positive side... I think it's worth spending a few years there. It's a very interesting experience in many ways, that I don't regret.
- akgerber 12y agoI don't have the exact statistics as hand, but SF has actually had moderate growth in the housing stock— the real issue is that there was essentially 0 housing growth in Silicon Valley other than San Jose.
- beat 12y agoMenlo Park is determined to protect its "village feel". They don't want to be a "real city". They won't even allow buildings over two stories tall in the quaint little downtown area. Trying to overlay dense housing and mixed-use buildings onto a wealthy "village" is incredibly difficult, and some giant corporation muscling the city council is likely to provoke the residential antibodies.
- eli_gottlieb 12y agoAnd precisely this is why I'm adamant about never, ever moving to the Bay Area. It's full of tech companies to work at, neat people to hang out with, and has an excellent climate with plenty of nature to bike through... and the local governments do their damnedest to ensure nobody will ever be able to afford any of it except for them.
- michaelochurch 12y agoMy issue with the Bay Area is that and the baseless professional downgrading that's usually involved with that move. Because you didn't do it in the Bay Area, they shave one or two ranks off your title and your salary suffers (and, presumably, you don't get the best projects). Sorry, but I know more than your VPs about technology and how to build a company, and so I'm not going to take a junior role for the "privilege" of living in California. If winter gets to me, I'll take two weeks and go to Mexico or Bonaire; problem solved.
- amyjess 12y agoThat... sounds like a perfect place for me to live. I'm just salivating at the thought of living in a town that doesn't allow buildings over two stories. If I didn't love Texas (and my current job) so much, I'd seriously consider moving there now. Hmm... I think one of my ex-coworkers from my last job is from that town. Maybe I'll ping her and ask her about it...
- _delirium 12y agoInterestingly San Jose has had some controversy over the opposite issue. The city has a bit of an inferiority complex about not being perceived as a "real city" despite having ~1m people, so has been trying to encourage more high-rise development and fewer sprawling office parks. The goal seems to be to turn itself into a globally known tech hub, rather than being perceived as just the southern suburbs of San Francisco. Part of the city (the North San Jose redevelopment area) is targeted as a new high-rise central business district adjacent to the BART extension, and part of that redevelopment plan included minimum height guidelines, in which new developments were supposed to be at least 14 stories tall. There was considerable pushback from developers, though, because they wanted to build office parks rather than 14-story buildings, so the guideline has since been waived.
- amyjess 12y agoAs somebody who lives in the burbs (in Texas, not SV), I live here because I actively prefer a suburban lifestyle, and the presence of the kind of developments you want would make me move out to the exurbs. I don't want to live in a "real city". I chose to live in the suburbs because I prefer suburbs.
- eli_gottlieb 12y agoFine! But you shouldn't be allowed to squat on desirable locations (ie: places where lots of people work), soaking up the property taxes from business growth while telling everyone who works at the business you love taxing to get out of your suburb. You want the suburbs? Fine: live in a real suburb with little to no industry, and let the rest of us know how you're keeping the schools and municipal services funded. Otherwise, let some housing be built, so that people have a place to live. Because the world isn't just about you: it's about everyone else, too.