3 ms·
> Another is that you should never ever have any webpage configured to load any resources from a server hosted within China IP address space as it is vulnerable
by nailer 12y ago
> Another is that you should never ever have any webpage configured to load any resources from a server hosted within China IP address space as it is vulnerable to this sort of attack by the Chinese government.
Yep. Baidu are a NASDAQ listed company, while they may not be the malicious actor here, they still have a responsibility to ensure their networks are not used to attack others - which they don't seem to be taking seriously.
Until Baidu take steps to ensure their networks are not used to attack others, we should drop their packets: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9295617 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9295617
- paraboul 12y agoBaidu network is not used. The response is altered as the trafic goes out of China. The only thing they can do is hosting http://hm.baidu.com http://hm.baidu.com in another country.
- nailer 12y ago> The response is altered as the trafic goes out of China. By locating their network inside China, Baidu is allowing a malicious actor to leverage their network traffic - which indeed is a 'use' of Baidu's network. > The only thing they can do is hosting http://hm.baidu.com http://hm.baidu.com in another country. Most likely, yes. And until they do so, or come to another solution, their traffic should be blocked.
- teamhappy 12y agoSo what's the rule then? Block all packets coming out of countries with governments that do MITM attacks? Blame the companies for not locating their servers in other countries? Companies like GitHub? This is so hypocritical.
- nailer 12y ago> So what's the rule then? Block all packets coming out of countries with governments that do MITM attacks? Block packets from any company that does not take reasonable steps to stop its network from being used to attack others. This has been networking rule for a long time. - We block open mail relays - we block hacked Windows XP machines - we should block a company who's in a hacked data center where their upstream adds malicious JavaScript. Edit: 'we' = network administrators.
- teamhappy 12y agoI assumed you were talking about our governments when you said we. Who's stopping you from blocking whatever you want? Or from creating a public block list for that matter. You have to convince me to install it on my machines though. :P
- woah 12y agoI think they are addressing their fellow network admins with that comment
- ithkuil 12y agoIf their traffic gets blocked by other countries they could mitigate the revenue loss by having some capacity outside China and make sure that most accesses to their property coming from outside China goes to the servers hosted outside China (geo dns or anycast routing). This would restore their analytics infrastructure functionality and avoid being exploited by their own government for such kinds of attack, while being justified as an infrastructure scalability concern (to avoid backslashes by the Chinese government).
- acveilleux 12y agoThey probably should use a global, non-chinese CDN to avoid this. That and HSTS and HTTPS to pin certs.
- throwaway7767 12y agoDoes that mean we should drop everything coming from US prefixes also because the NSA uses them for man-on-the-side attacks?
- nailer 12y agoIf there is a specific infrastructure being leveraged by the someone to attack someone else, and the owner of the infrastructure is not taking steps to prevent its misuse, then yes, of course. Edit: yes, throwaway7767, this means any company. However LinkedIn, in this case, was being spoofed, and LInkedIn's infrastructure was not used: http://www.spiegel.de/international/world/ghcq-targets-engineers-with-fake-linkedin-pages-a-932821.html http://www.spiegel.de/international/world/ghcq-targets-engin... Edit 2: no, throwaway7767, Baidu's infrastructure - their bandwidth, their customers, and location within the Chinese Firewall are being used to attack GitHub. Baidu has control over where they locate their servers. Baidu are not exercising that control.
- throwaway7767 12y agoApparently I can now reply further into the thread, must be a timed thing. > Edit: yes, throwaway7767, this means any company. However LinkedIn, in this case, was being spoofed, and LInkedIn's infrastructure was not used: http://www.spiegel.de/international/world/ghcq-targets-engin.. http://www.spiegel.de/international/world/ghcq-targets-engin.... LinkedIn was indeed being spoofed, which is exactly what was being done to baidu in this case we are discussing. So it seems to be we now agree that blocking baidu would not be appropriate? > Edit 2: no, throwaway7767, Baidu's infrastructure - their bandwidth, their customers, and location within the Chinese Firewall are being used to attack GitHub. Baidu has control over where they locate their servers. Baidu are not exercising that control. And in what way is this different than the attack on LinkedIn we were discussing? Please be specific. I've already said I disapprove of these methods regardless of who applies them, but you have not seen fit to specifically state that companies like linkedin should move all their servers outside the US/UK/FVEY countries, reserving that course of action only for chinese companies.
- 12y ago