4 ms·
As a New Yorker visiting HK for the first time this week, it's hard not to walk away impressed. The NYC Subways are so completely inferior it's no wonder they
by Duhck 12y ago
As a New Yorker visiting HK for the first time this week, it's hard not to walk away impressed.
The NYC Subways are so completely inferior it's no wonder they operate at a loss.
I ride the A/C trains daily and my commute varies from 30-90 minutes depending on an unknown set of variables. At least 2 days a week I find myself cursing the subway for being late, running with delays, or getting me stuck underground somewhere without any notice or announcements.
Perhaps even more inferior than the actual train experience
is the wayfinding experience.
The MTR's letter/number exits (which google maps supports wonderfully) makes leaving the subway as great as riding it.
Even as a 7-year veteran NY'er I sometimes find myself trying to figure out which is the right exit to take at each station to get above ground. I usually say "ok I want to go south east, find the most south east exit I can" but as a tourist this must be so confusing.
It almost seems like a catch-22. If the MTA got their shit together and fixed up the subway lines to make them more reliable, maybe they'd be closer to breaking even, but since they are in a deficit (or are they? [1]) they can't actually fix things on time or properly at all.
I have to say the NYC subway is mostly pitiful (especially outside of Manhattan) and the MTR is nothing short of impressive.
[1] http://newyork.cbslocal.com/2013/09/28/mta-audit-reveals-unanticipated-surplus-of-nearly-2-billion/ http://newyork.cbslocal.com/2013/09/28/mta-audit-reveals-una...
- damon_c 12y agoWell... keep in mind that the NYC subway opened 110 years ago while the MTR started in 1979. It's brand new! But yeah, the signage is terrible. Paris's system is even older and even if you don't speak much French it's still easier to find the right exit than it is in NYC. Why can't we have nice things?
- hackerboos 12y agoFrench subway exits are mostly in...French. Look for the "sortie".
- smackfu 12y agoAlso keep in mind that the NYC subway has nearly 300 more stations than the MTR. Very hard to compare systems because of factors like that.
- locopati 12y agoThe NYC subway also has more riders (about 25%), more lines (about 2x), more stations (about 3x), and more miles of track (2-5x depending on how you count). It's also the only system in the world that I'm aware of that runs 24-hours a day, which impacts the ability to do routine maintenance. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MTR http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MTR [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_York_City_Subway http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_York_City_Subway