3 ms·
If you want to publish your own newspaper, you can. Nobody will stop you. Start your own online video news service, weblog or nes site - nobody will stop you. P
by simonh 12y ago
If you want to publish your own newspaper, you can. Nobody will stop you. Start your own online video news service, weblog or nes site - nobody will stop you. Post whatever you like to Reddit, or any other discussion platform.
In China and Russia you cannot do these things. Published mdeia are strictly monitored and censored. The state employs thousands of astroturfers to flood social media with pro-government messages, trash anti-government messages and even directly hook into messaging platforms to delete messages the government don't like. Be persistent at it, and you'll get a visit from the police, or just get beaten up a few times.
The very fact that the BBC could publish that report, and Noam Chomsky could publish his book, is strong evidence for freedom of expression in the west. There are no such equivalent sources published in Russia and China exposing their government's manipulations. Why do you think that is?
- psykovsky 12y agoYet that Guantanamo ex-prisioner has his book for sale everywhere except in the US... Care to guess why it isn't for sale in the US?
- simonh 12y agoA handful of books banned for a few individual legal issues does not make for a suppressive state. Are you seriously arguing that the USA is more suppressive of coimmunications and publications that China? Really?
- tripa 12y ago> Are you seriously arguing that the USA is more suppressive of coimmunications and publications that China? Really? He never was. And as seen from the outside, you're completely making his point.
- xentronium 12y ago> If you want to publish your own newspaper, you can. Nobody will stop you. Start your own online video news service, weblog or nes site - nobody will stop you. Post whatever you like to Reddit, or any other discussion platform. > In China and Russia you cannot do these things. It's not as bad in Russia yet. But we are going there.
- im2w1l 12y agoYou can lose your job if you post too wrong views too much. EDIT: I don't understand the downvotes. It is both relevant (it refutes that you can "Post whatever you like to Reddit, or any other discussion platform." without punishment), and correct.
- anon012012 12y agoI think because it is more a consequence of human nature than governmental activity (though in some measure they're intertwined, and so it's hard to say objectively).
- teamhappy 12y ago> [...] is strong evidence for freedom of expression in the west. Unfortunately there are less and less white spots in "the west." https://index.rsf.org/ https://index.rsf.org/
- colordrops 12y agoI won't argue with you that China is far more repressive and less free than the US, because you are correct in that assertion. I only state that the US is far more _manipulative_.
- simonh 12y agoThe U.S. media has nothing on Russian state television, they are quite consciously part of the government propaganda machine. They don't hesitate to use material like photoshopped 'satelite pictures' of Ukrainian fighter jets shooting down that Malaysian airliner and present it as validated evidence. They have presented 'proof' that American soldiers are fighting in the Ukrainian army, and debate outrageous conspiracy theories straight faced. Fox News has absolutely nothing on those guys.