3 ms·
Couldn't you just allow cross-state insurance pools, insurance portability, require direct payment and encourage the states to have their own pooling solutions,
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
Couldn't you just allow cross-state insurance pools, insurance portability, require direct payment and encourage the states to have their own pooling solutions, much like some states currently do with automotive insurance?
I don't think it's an either-or question -- pooling/mandate or not -- at the national level. Sure, I think lots of folks would like it to be that way, but it doesn't have to be. It doesn't have to have a centralized answer for it to have a solution. Co-ops, for instance, have been left on the floor so far.
- tptacek 17y agoCross-state insurance seems like such an obvious proxy for insurance de-regulation that I'm surprised its advocates don't just come out and say it: "we should work with the minimum possible regulation on insurance companies". I'm wholly ambivalent about whether states or the federal government should operate the government-sponsored risk pool. You already know where this discussion is going to go with me, so think about whether you want to wade into it. Pick your poison: government by the Government, or government by the insurance companies. I'm not wild about what the federal government is coming up with (though not because of the mandate, which seems sensible), but the major insurance companies are both inept and actively evil, and the system we have today is rigged to favor them decisively whether we regulate or not.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoWe have a system where the cost of cool things to extend and improve your life is greater than your ability to pay. The problem here is that somebody is going to have to say "no". Right now the evil insurance companies are saying "no" in order to control costs. Those damn capitalists! Describing a new system as a deal where "you are guaranteed not to pay any more into it, but there's no limit for how much you get out of it" as I just heard the speaker describe is completely crazy. Our national politicians are great at a bunch of things. Cost control isn't one of them. Government has a role in defining open markets. Right now the product of insurance is so confusing and convoluted that there effectively is no market. Defining what policies are, where policies can be sold, or how long you can keep them -- that makes a lot of sense. There's a lot of other things that government can do that make a lot of sense. Trying to legislate a new solution to a problem of the pool of uninsured? Its like trying to create a startup to suddenly manage 40 million customers. It's crazy. Large systems don't work like that. It's completely idiotic. You can try to slant this as "government" or not, but it's a lot more nuanced than that. The choice isn't just "minimum possible regulation" -- and nobody said it was. This is about problem-solving versus ideology. This is about what types of systems work best for problem-solving.
- tptacek 17y agoGive me a break. You're talking to someone with firsthand experience of the arbitrariness of the health insurance system. "Those damn capitalists!" refused to insure my wife, despite any actual pre-existing condition, even with an exemption on the policy. Women of childbearing age are routinely screwed by the system we have now. That's just one example. You really think this is your best argument? Sticking up for Blue Cross and Kaiser? The government does a fine job providing insurance to many millions of people. Private insurers do a calamitously bad job, and moreoever are part of a collusive system to simultaneously jack up the cost of care and fund it with a private shadow tax on everyone who works for a large company. I'll go with the devil I can vote out of office every couple years, thanks.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoYou had a bad experience. Thanks for sharing. I had a bad experience with government-ran health care. You want we should compare belly-buttons? Or talk about the underlying issues? Because anecdotes are free and plentiful. Nobody is sticking up for anybody. The government is currently going broke providing the existing programs. As much as the plan is supposed to be "save $500 Billion in Medicare" it's a historically unsupportable standpoint. So the same guys that are spending more than they make in retirement, healthcare for seniors and poor people is now going to suddenly become as efficient as ten thousand possible insurers and insurance co-opts? Would you take the largest, poorest-ran insurance company and force another 20x into their customer lists? If you have anything more than angry hand-waving I'd like to hear it. Perhaps I'm smoking crack. Been wrong many times before. But you're not making your case so far.
- tptacek 17y agoMy bad experience refutes your claim about what the insurance companies are doing. They aren't simply minimizing costs by saying no to unreasonable treatments. Way to move the goalposts there, friend. We should stop discussing this. You'll never convince me of anything. I know what your politics are. I'll never convince you of anything. You know where I stand. Fortunately for me (I believe), my side's winning.