4 ms·
"One interesting scenario I saw pointed out that the entire idea of forcing purchase of coverage like this is very Constitutionally dubious." There is no direc
by Daniel_Newby 17y ago
"One interesting scenario I saw pointed out that the entire idea of forcing purchase of coverage like this is very Constitutionally dubious."
There is no direct way for it to be lawful. It has to be done indirectly using an actual authority of Congress. For instance, they could say "A person shall not engage in interstate commerce unless they buy a policy or pay the fine." I predict this is what they will do; those Congressmen really love that Commerce Clause.
But note that the nondiscrimination amendment requires them to treat all persons equally, regardless of place of residence or incorporation. This means foreigners! If a guy in Cincinnati can't call California without buying insurance, then neither can a Chinaman.
If enforced, this will instantly detonate the entire global economy.
If not enforced, then foreigners will be explicitly elevated over citizens. This is not a recipe for political tranquillity, to put it mildly.