3 ms·
The expectation (of the court, and the bank) was you get 6 years on the note, and 20 years on the mortgage. Now we have a novel theory where the court is findin
by zaroth 12y ago
The expectation (of the court, and the bank) was you get 6 years on the note, and 20 years on the mortgage. Now we have a novel theory where the court is finding it's actually a 6 years limit for the note and the mortgage.
The homeowner never made a single monthly payment on the mortgage, from the very first month they were in default. And now, the mortgage is effectively discharged. There's no question as to fact here, the homeowner is stealing the home.
The question is, is it lawful? It's appropriate for the court to express disgust when the law leads to blatantly bad outcomes.
- jacquesm 12y ago> The question is, is it lawful? Apparently yes. > It's appropriate for the court to express disgust when the law leads to blatantly bad outcomes. Then they should find different jobs. The law working 'bad' happens quite frequently and I have yet to see such a blatant preference for one side over the other in official court documents. It degrades the court. The homehowner is not 'stealing the home', the homeowner has found a legal loophole in a situation that could have turned against them quite easily and the court had to confirm that the loophole is indeed legal. Liking or disliking doesn't enter into it. The bank probably had ample opportunity to avoid this happening but in the end trusted too much in the judge siding with them because of the fundamental unreasonableness of the request, forgetting that it was the legality that mattered. If it there is any doubt about this being legal then you can be sure the case will be appealed. Contractual law is usually dealt with quite strictly when the tables are turned, for once it is the homeowner that ends up with an advantage, it's a foregone conclusion that future contracts will be re-written to rule this possibility out so the damage is limited and that the bank(s) will be much more careful about letting things get even close to the statute of limitations. I wonder how many homeowners are in a position to continue to exploit this given the fact that the banks are now warned.
- zaroth 12y agoApparently it's not uncommon, although anecdote is not data, so I stress apparently. I forwarded this story around, and my brother knows a woman in Florida who has done this. Twice. She calls the trick "quiet title". I guess you could think of it as a form of welfare, and another example of the war on the middle class.
- jacquesm 12y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quiet_title http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quiet_title Interesting.