3 ms·
Very hard to feel bad for the banks in this, since it's only the epic scale of foreclosures that allowed anything like this to happen, and the scale of foreclos
by zaroth 12y ago
Very hard to feel bad for the banks in this, since it's only the epic scale of foreclosures that allowed anything like this to happen, and the scale of foreclosures is a direct result of non-existent underwriting.
However, the problem is, it's not the banks footing the bill, it's the taxpayers. As usual, the less you pay, the more you get, and now apparently that includes the wholesale American Dream of home ownership.
What I don't understand from a legal perspective, is how statue of limitation can possibly apply. The time limit would have to be filing of the case, not conclusion right? I know there were issues with robo-signing and all that, but did the loan servicers really drop the ball so badly? (Edit: The answer is in the actual case PDF I found and linked to below -- the original foreclosure was dimissed without prejudice because the bank couldn't produce the necessary documents, namely an original copy of the mortgage.)
Mortgage servicing is outsourced by the government in fairly lucrative contracts. The bank you get the loan from is almost never (credit unions are the obvious exception) the company that collects your payments each month. I would have guessed it's up to the loan servicer to handle the foreclosure... the article simply doesn't have enough details behind the catchy headline.
Also so good to know they won't even have to pay tax on the income... </s> http://www.irs.gov/Individuals/The-Mortgage-Forgiveness-Debt-Relief-Act-and-Debt-Cancellation- http://www.irs.gov/Individuals/The-Mortgage-Forgiveness-Debt...
And here's the actual case... so much for "NOT FOR PUBLICATION": http://noonanandlieberman.com/media/pdfs/washington-11-6-2104.pdf http://noonanandlieberman.com/media/pdfs/washington-11-6-210...
Secion I. Introduction:
“No one gets a free house.” This Court and others have uttered
that admonition since the early days of the mortgage crisis, where
homeowners have sought relief under a myriad of state and federal
consumer protection statutes and the Bankruptcy Code. Yet, with a
proper measure of disquiet and chagrin, the Court now must retreat
from this position, as Gordon A. Washington (“the Debtor”) has
presented a convincing argument for entitlement to such
relief. So, with figurative hand holding the nose, the Court,
for the reasons set forth below, will grant Debtor’s motion for
summary judgment.
Edit 2: The lawyers for the bank seem like complete neanderthals?! The statue of limitations is 6 years from the date of maturity, which was accelerated, so debtor claims it's been 6 years since the accelerated date. But the statue specifically says the bank can extend the date of maturity by written instrument. So... write a note de-accelerating the acceleration by 1 year, and re-file the foreclosure.
It's also not even clear the statue in question was effective in this case. The judge assumes that based on a prior statue which did say it was to be effective for all foreclosures filed after that date, but the law in question says no such thing.
And a final closing remark, as I just got to the last sentence in the PDF:
"The Court will proceed to gargle in an effort to remove the
lingering bad taste."
- x0x0 12y agoIt's hard to stomach any actor in the court system who whines about gargling to remove the bad taste when the law works out to a homeowner's advantage but doesn't bring up how any large bank is treated with kid gloves by the sec. They're never prosecuted, they're given fine after fine after fine and allowed to treat it as a cost of doing business with no real consequences, etc. There's voluminous coverage, but just a bit: http://blogs.reuters.com/felix-salmon/2014/04/09/yes-the-sec-was-colluding-with-banks-on-cdo-prosecutions/ http://blogs.reuters.com/felix-salmon/2014/04/09/yes-the-sec... http://www.rollingstone.com/politics/news/the-9-billion-witness-20141106?page=5 http://www.rollingstone.com/politics/news/the-9-billion-witn...
- jackmaney 12y agoAs much as it pains me to admit it, I agree with you here.
- jacquesm 12y agoThat court sounds like it is anything but impartial. Language like that favouring one party in a dispute where the court apparently has no other way out than to come down in favour of the other party should be ground for a pretty strict reading during a performance review or whatever is the local equivalent. Disgusting, and I'm saying that even though I am neutral about the case (not having a dog in the fight). Such language simply has no place in a ruling and suggests extreme partiality on the part of the court, something that should be avoided at all costs.
- zaroth 12y agoThe expectation (of the court, and the bank) was you get 6 years on the note, and 20 years on the mortgage. Now we have a novel theory where the court is finding it's actually a 6 years limit for the note and the mortgage. The homeowner never made a single monthly payment on the mortgage, from the very first month they were in default. And now, the mortgage is effectively discharged. There's no question as to fact here, the homeowner is stealing the home. The question is, is it lawful? It's appropriate for the court to express disgust when the law leads to blatantly bad outcomes.