4 ms·
What difference would it have made?
by emodendroket 12y ago
What difference would it have made?
- matart 12y agoI would assume just media wise
- vaadu 12y agoAny evidence these 2 agents provided would be regarded as unreliable.
- tedunangst 12y agoWhat evidence did these 2 agents provide?
- gwern 12y agoFor one thing, the entire Maryland hitman case collapses if you can't use anything Force touched, because he ran it from start to finish as Nob.
- tedunangst 12y agoNo doubt the case they were working is probably tanked, but my question was meant to be pointed more towards the trial that's already happened, where evidence has been presented (past tense).
- CPLX 12y agoIt would cast a shadow of doubt over any and all evidence that these now discredited agents were involved in collecting and any testimony they made or influenced.
- john_b 12y agoIANAL, so hopefully someone more knowledgeable will chime in, but if you can show in court that a witness has comitted a crime you can show that they are not trustworthy and essentially impeach their testimony. There was so much evidence against Ulbricht that it probably wouldn't have changed the outcome, but the fact that this is only now being brought to light is very suspicious.
- fweespeech 12y ago> The Baltimore investigation resulted in an indictment of Mr. Ulbricht on a charge of murder for hire, but that case has remained pending and the evidence in support of it was kept out of the New York trial, apparently because of the investigation into the agents. They were part of a separate case against Ulbricht. The one he was convicted on wasn't based on their evidence and/or testimony.
- pluma 12y agoTrials have to prove someone is guilty beyond reasonable doubt. If agents involved in the investigations were caught misbehaving, that may very well add doubt to the validity of the investigation's results. Or at least it could delay the trial while the results are re-evaluated.
- emodendroket 12y agoWell, I took a high school civics class too, but I don't see these guys as having been central to the case against Ulbricht at all.
- pluma 12y agoI didn't (nor do I see what high school has to do with the most basic principle defining a state of law). And I didn't say they were central to the case, either. But depending on the lawyers and the judge, this could have been used to construct something that would have affected either the progress or the outcome of the trial. It's entirely philosophical anyway.
- emodendroket 12y ago> I didn't (nor do I see what high school has to do with the most basic principle defining a state of law). It was my way of trying to suggest that, like everyone with a modicum of education in the United States, I'm aware of the principle that accused persons are innocent until proven guilty in US law, and you didn't really need to point it out to me like it was something I hadn't thought of.