3 ms·
Disclaimer: the following comes with a big "in my opinion" preceding it. Um, I think no-one finds every part of any given subject interesting to the same degre
by the_af 12y ago
Disclaimer: the following comes with a big "in my opinion" preceding it.
Um, I think no-one finds every part of any given subject interesting to the same degree. That's human nature. But also, maybe you already understand some parts and want to skip ahead to the more difficult parts. Sadly, in the excessively constrained format of video, sometimes the teacher will choose to focus on the topics you already understand, and neglects others. Such are the limitations of video format -- and indeed, of brick and mortar classes! Only the full, unabridged text gives you a (relatively) unconstrained explanation of all relevant topics. Of course, it also comes with some disadvantages: it can overwhelm the student, or present topics in the wrong order, or -- even -- focus on the "wrong" things, because after all written notes are also space-constrained. But I find it a way less constrained format anyway.
I find taking notes to be an uninteresting artifact of "live" classes. What truly matters is that you do the exercises and understand them.
If I gave the impression that I favored the "lazy" approach, I apologize. To be honest, I think watching the videos is both the lazy approach (only reading the notes seems like the serious approach to me) AND a time-waster. You are both more efficient AND gain a better understanding of the source material if you read the written notes/book and also do the exercises.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- brudgers 12y agoI took Odersky's class because I wanted to learn Scala and functional programming from Odersky. I trusted his judgement as to what was important and what wasn't. I could find programming exercises and Scala tutorials using Google. There are even free Scala ebooks and I own a hard copy of SICP. What I can't get on my own is Odersky. BTW, I found the format of the exercises for that class tedious and overly dependent on SBT. I walked away knowing some Scala and more functional programming but configuring the IDE to start a new very simple Scala project wasn't covered, unfortunately. I will also add that Odersky's videos were a bit confusing because they were disconnected from the bricks and mortar class where they are also used, apparently. Curtailing the subject matter for the MOOC may make sense, but the those videos show how tempting it is to avoid the effort that editing video entails. I think Grossman's class was much better designed. The slide based format without human body parts allows more flexibility with regard to editing. Taking body parts off the screen allows more flexible combination.
- the_af 12y agoI agree Grossman's class was much better designed. I think he is a great teacher. But in my opinion it was mostly because the course's notes were very comprehensive in the case of Programming Languages and somewhat poor in Odersky's courses (again: no disrespect meant for Odersky; just my opinion on the design of these online courses). With Grossman's course you can skip the videos entirely and miss nothing, whereas you cannot do that with Odersky's. In both cases, I found the exercises very engaging and for me they were the main "thrill" of taking the course, but I understand that other people found them very frustrating -- they were very vocal on the forums -- often for the reasons you mentioned: the tools were hard to configure or confusing.
- brudgers 12y agoFor Odersky's class, SICP is available for free on line and in dead-tree form so there was plenty of background material to support the lectures [not to mention the SICP video lectures]. I just found the exercises for Functional Programming in Scala to be drudgery. That wasn't the case in Grossman's class. Odersky's class was full of klunky complexity - SBT, IDE's, and Scala's compiler performance and the warts of working on top of the JVM. Formatting the exercises partially completed code just added to the mess [though the partially completed code idea is a useful pedagogical approach]. On the other hand, Grossman's use of Emacs was one of the reasons I took the course. I still use Emacs. I don't still use Eclipse or ScalaIDE.
- the_af 12y agoYou won't like the exercises in Reactive Programming then. Not only are they a confused mess that is difficult to relate to the source material, the source material itself is confusing and poorly motivated. PS: SICP is not written either by or for Coursera, or even particularly adapted to it. If you use it as the main supporting material, what is the point of Coursera at all? In contrast, Grossman's notes were written by him and directly support his course.