10 ms·
the "evil, scary China" narrative A friend is studying journalism. Last week he told me about 90% of western media on China follows that narrative, and around
by contingencies 12y ago
the "evil, scary China" narrative
A friend is studying journalism. Last week he told me about 90% of western media on China follows that narrative, and around 30% of international headlines in recent months have been about China. Sad. Then again, media in China on the west is not exactly impartial and well researched, either.
- mliker 12y agoMedia in general is not well researched, no matter which country it's in. They're mostly meant to generate headlines.
- jusben1369 12y agoWell the New Yorker and NYTimes are more liberal and left leaning vs conservative so have less of a hawk/defense agenda to push. So I think you do yourself a disservice dismissing articles like this out of hand under a broad umbrella of "generic China narrative"
- eru 12y agoThe intra-American political labels are probably less relevant on a global level than American vs eg Chinese.
- ninjayi 12y agoI kinda start to think is this article related to people Xi trying to crack down in China. Very similar to pervious Bloomberg stories, the sources and timings are very suspicious. Not saying the story is false or anything.
- kylebrown 12y agoNot sure if paid shill or just biased? The Bloomberg article was about the wealth amassed by Xi's extended family.[1] This New Yorker piece cites an article by Geremie Barme which points out that of the 48 highest-profile corruption cases, none were targeted at "second-generation reds" (aka princelings)[2]. Note that the very high profile case of corrupt princeling Bo Xilai was just prior to Xi's appointment. The ostensible anti-corruption crusade embarked on afterward was targeted at scapegoat officials "from ‘commoner’ 平民 families." Indeed, Barme's article quotes numerous princeling Party officials extolling the inherent virtue of "bureaucrats from the Red Second Generation" and their naturally-born resistance to vice and corruption (Bo Xilai is an exceedingly rare anomaly). Instead, the real danger is "Bureaucrats who come from extreme poverty in youth easily fall prey to vile excesses of corruption, whoring and gambling." > It goes with saying that, in the murky corridors of Communist power, an impressive number of party gentry progeny, or the offspring of the Mao-era nomenclatura, have been implicated in corrupt practices, but word has it that, like the well-connected elites of other climes, they’ve enjoyed a ‘soft landing': being discretely relocated, shunted into delicate retirement or quietly ‘redeployed’. It’s all very comfy; and it’s all very much business as usual. 1. http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2012-06-29/xi-jinping-millionaire-relations-reveal-fortunes-of-elite http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2012-06-29/xi-jinping... 2. https://www.thechinastory.org/2014/10/tyger-tyger-a-fearful-symmetry/ https://www.thechinastory.org/2014/10/tyger-tyger-a-fearful-...
- LiweiZ 12y agoYou know the game better than most of people here. Are you from mainland China as well? Or can read Chinese?