4 ms·
Honestly, this is the correct thing. Cars, once they're about 2-3 years old, have no real value. They all drop below $10k around here no matter the make or mode
by DiabloD3 12y ago
Honestly, this is the correct thing. Cars, once they're about 2-3 years old, have no real value. They all drop below $10k around here no matter the make or model (Maine winters are hard on vehicles, though, again, no one drives Mercedes around here either).
Buying a car is a sunk cost. Once you own it, getting rid of it before it cannot be driven anymore is wasting money. Once she bought that Mercedes, once it got too old, swapping it for a newer used vehicle would just give her a worse vehicle that would cost her more money in the long run.
I am poor. I've never been rich. I have a few nice things because I force myself to do the math on things. Other poor people hate me and threaten to report me to "the authorities" for owning nice things because somehow I cheated to get them.
I may not own many things, but the things I own do what I need them to do, and will do so for a very very long time. What this woman did, in my opinion, was the right thing.
Selling only makes sense if you can actually profit from it.
- jacquesm 12y agoA car is not only something that costs money to buy, it also costs money to maintain and run. That cost can be cut and if you are in trouble financially the first thing to go should be a vehicle that you can no longer afford to own and operate. It's a luxury item.
- Delmania 12y agoRegardless of how much trouble you're in, reliable transportation is needed. Cars are an expense, but in the situation described, the Mercedes was fully paid off. The cost of maintaining it (gas, repairs, insurance) is no greater than any other car.
- jacquesm 12y agoRepairs on an older Mercedes are actually quite expensive. I should know because I own one and if hard times would hit - unlikely, but you never know - it would be the first thing to go (and I'd replace it with an old VW Golf/Rabbit diesel).
- bryanlarsen 12y agoVW diesels are very expensive to fix when things go wrong, in my personal experience.
- jacquesm 12y agoThat's true, but on the plus side, things don't go wrong very frequently. I've run this beast: http://pics.camarades.com/v/jacques/cars/golf/ http://pics.camarades.com/v/jacques/cars/golf/ From '09 to '11 and it had more than 300K km on it by the time I was done with it (and it still brought me back more than I paid for it...). You have to be pretty sharp when you're buying them to make sure you don't buy one that has been maintained poorly. Fuel pump and turbo are the most important things to check. That car cost about $750 to buy and another $200 for fixes required right after buying it to get it through the 'MOT', after that it ran without a hitch for two years.
- bryanlarsen 12y agoAnd I put $1500 - $3000 into my VW diesel 3 times over a 7 year period. Every car is different, even if well maintained. They said their Mercedes is reliable. An American car is probably better for a poor person than any German car. Sure, you may have to repair it more often, but parts and labour are a lot cheaper. Even if it costs more in total, for poor people a large number of small bills are often easier to deal with than a single large bill.
- jacquesm 12y agoI'd go for a (gasoline) Toyota if I was in the states and reliability and operating costs were my main concern. $1000 / year on average for maintenance is definitely on the high side, but of course it needs a bit more info before I could state that one way or the other with certainty (mileage driven during that time, overall mileage on the car, state of maintenance when you bought it, whether you bought it new or not). The newer diesels have insanely high injection pressures, I have a campervan that has one of these engines (the 2.5L) and I really hope that there will never be a problem with that because it will make your $3000 look like pocket change if it fails in a serious way. In a pinch I think I'd rely on the older and much simpler models rather than to go for one of these hyper efficient versions. They seem to trade efficiency in fuel for a much shorter life-span and a higher repair bill. The government here puts an insane premium on fuel consumption without taking into account the effect of all those fuel saving measures on the total-costs over the lifetime of the car. At a rough guess it is a toss-up, what you gain in fuel efficiency you lose in expensive repairs.
- HarryHirsch 12y agoA car a luxury item? In suburban America? Wish it were so, so I could get rid of the polluting money-sink! Near where I live, the advertisements on the bus stops say "USD 500 and you ride!" because a functional car means access to work opportunities, i.e. money.
- jacquesm 12y agoLet me tell you a little story: One fine winter in the late 90's I got a job for a company in Minot, North Dakota. I flew there by way of a bunch of flights from Amsterdam, checked in to the hotel and reported to the front desk of the company that hired me the next morning at 8:30 am. Huge flap, they'd apparently called the police to do a manhunt because I had started walking to work and everybody knows that you can't possibly walk to work in weather like that (at the time: about 15 celsius below zero). I really didn't get what the big deal was until I realized that absolutely nobody walked, and that this was why the sidewalks were just about non-existent. Suburban America is a design error with grave repercussions down the line, but since it was designed by and for the affluent assuming multiple vehicles per family and things like bicycle paths and public transport are either not present or just about un-usable you're going to have a problem if you don't have access to a vehicle. But quite a few people do not have access to vehicles today (for instance: children, quite a few elderly people, everybody too poor to own cars) so maybe it's time to start fixing this problem? Two cars for every family is long term un-sustainable, and two cars for a family without income to me sounds like it is an impossibility. Even so, there are ways to use only one vehicle, even in a family where two people are working, figure out who keeps the car with them during the day, either drop off the other at work or at the nearest public transport hub (assuming that one exists). That should take care of the bigger problem. Having two cars when you can't afford your food is really not good.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- DiabloD3 12y agoFor those that don't want to do the math, -15c is 5f. I grew up in Maine (moved here when I was 6), I've walked to school in the morning in that, while it was snowing, I consider 40f warm enough to walk a mile without a jacket and maybe just a tshirt if its sunny out, long sleeve shirt if not. I find their reaction a bit strange without further context.
- fnordfnordfnord 12y agoWith the exception of cities like New York, a car is not a luxury item in the US; it is a necessity. We might quibble about the kind of car but, without learning more about hers I'm not sure we could come to a consensus.
- jacquesm 12y agoIt's their second vehicle. You can do a lot of fixing on a Honda for the cash value of that Mercedes, alternatively, trade both for a reliable one that is a lot cheaper to own and operate. A Mercedes is a reliable car if it is maintained well and if you're living on food-stamps and are unemployed that value will drop very rapidly because you can no longer afford to maintain it. Once it stops running its resale value is nil, so better sell it before then. See: http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2012/03/19/top-10-cars-for-smart-people/ http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2012/03/19/top-10-cars-for-sm...
- jklinger410 12y agoYou should tell the government that.
- yabatopia 12y agoYou have to keep an eye on the long term. You can be in financial trouble now, but next month you can find a job and you need a car. Then what? Buying a less reliable car, paying for a new registration and taking an unfavourable loan to finance it? Selling all your assets at once is almost never the best way to manage debt.
- jacquesm 12y agoYou could replace the two cars they had (one: expensive to maintain, worth something, the other: unreliable) with something reliable and affordable.