5 ms·
The author only thinks his understanding of Dunning-Kruger is better than average. No, seriously. As others have pointed out, the meme is not that actual abil
by notacoward 12y ago
The author only thinks his understanding of Dunning-Kruger is better than average. No, seriously. As others have pointed out, the meme is not that actual ability and self-assessment are negatively correlated. It's just that ignorant people don't know how ignorant they are - i.e. that those at the low end of the scale overestimate their position relative to the maximum. That version is very well supported by the graphs the OP cites. He has scratched the iceberg of skepticism and now thinks he's enough of an expert to tell the rest of us that we're Doing It Wrong.
- logicallee 12y ago"Blogger misunderstands Dunning-Kruger, while demonstrating it dramatically"
- deciplex 12y agoHe, ah, also only shows three graphs in his post despite referring to four. He just shows one of them twice. This whole article is just a bag of fail.
- gd1 12y agoHmm, as he kind of points out, there is a difference between knowing your ability in something is poor and being willing to admit it to a stranger. The usual meme of Dunning-Kruger tends to refer to people who are oblivious to their own incompetence. But there are valid reasons for the perceived score compression. I'd wager the people in the bottom quartile of grammar performance are well aware that their grammar isn't very good, they just weren't willing to write 20 on the paper (out of shame) and went for 60 instead.
- philh 12y agoSo would you predict that people offered $100 for an accurate self-assessment would be well calibrated?
- philh 12y ago> the meme is not that actual ability and self-assessment are negatively correlated I don't think there's a single DK meme, but I do think that this is a common DK meme. Somewhat-serious suggestion: maybe people who actually understand DK, have a tendency to underestimate how well they understand it relative to everyone else, and so assume that everyone else understands it about as well as they do.
- msandford 12y agoI think it's hilarious that everyone piling onto this guy from being "so wrong" about Dunning-Kruger have a huge blind spot. Maybe they don't understand it as well as they think so, either. If it's possible that he's super-wrong, it's also entirely possible that they are too.
- army 12y agoI've definitely heard the negatively correlated variant of the meme. I'm not sure it's the predominant one or always explicitly expressed, but it's out there.
- anonymoushn 12y agoI see the "actual ability and self-assessment are negatively correlated" version of the meme a majority of the time. Maybe I just hang out on the wrong parts of the internet?
- RogerL 12y agoPeople roll out either depending on the situation. It is hand waving, not reasoning. IOW, you can explain anything away by taking one of the two sides of this argument. "You think you are good? Ha, no, dunning. Oh, you are not sure you are good? Ha, wrong, you must be great" type stuff. While these effects exist in large populations, you can't really use them to reason about any specific instance.
- drzaiusapelord 12y agoThis. I work with a support guy like this. He has, at best, a hobbyist's understanding of the technology we use. He tries to paint himself in meetings as this expert who often tries to correct us and says completely mind-numbing things. When discussing a fairly complex Drupal roll-out, "Oh, why even bother with this open source stuff? We can make an access database on the network shares and give people access to it! I hear it can do web now!" I've sat him down and patiently explained to him why we do these things, how they are common and best practices, etc and he just makes frowny face like I'm the one talking crazy and he doesn't seem to learn as he brings up the same suggestions over and over. Last week he was adament that a dedicated linux server for our Asterisk PBX was overkill and that WindowsXP running some windows freeware pbx on any old desktop would be better because PBXs need so little power and XP is a super lean OS. At my previous job where I worked and managed a few young-ish support and jr devs, I came accross a lot of the same attitudes. The funny thing is that two or three years in, they tend to shed those attitudes (at least the smart ones do). They realize that this stuff is a lot bigger than the limited experience they've gotten in school or in their hobbyist projects. Suddenly the "lets toss out everything and do it my way" motor-mouting gets turned down a notch or two, especially after I let them do things "their way" once in a while only to have it explode in their faces. Hell, 90% of managing young techies is controlling their D-K until they mature into imposter syndrome. Then you have to manage that, which is a million times easier to deal because you're not being know-it-all'd to death in every meeting. D-K is real. The graphs he points out literally supports it. Personally, I'm getting sick of this kind of uber-skeptic mentality that's popular here and on reddit. I think there's something ego gratifying for the INTJ male about being this loud-mouth contrarian who tells everyone they're wrong. Especially if its against some popular wisdom and if the argument is unusually pedantic and trivial.
- dang 12y ago> He has scratched the iceberg of skepticism and now thinks he's enough of an expert to tell the rest of us that we're Doing It Wrong. This sort of gratuitous negativity isn't appropriate in a Hacker News comment. It is unnecessary to make your point and pollutes the atmosphere for all of us. Please don't do that.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]