5 ms·
I wonder how would you repell a state with sophisticated robot terminators war machines. Lawn-motor robots? Perhaps arduino-controlled pistol gun with belt fee
by kiba 17y ago
I wonder how would you repell a state with sophisticated robot terminators war machines.
Lawn-motor robots? Perhaps arduino-controlled pistol gun with belt feed bullets?
I am worried about the future ability of a population's to resist a technological tyranny.
- rms 17y agoIn the USA at least, the population has been completely unable to resist the state since the Civil War.
- philwelch 17y agoHow do you figure that? The Civil War demonstrated nothing of the kind. It only showed that if you split both the populace and the military establishment in two, the side that has more railroads, factories, and soldiers is going to win.
- nuclear_eclipse 17y agoI think the fact that the National Guard consists of nothing but fewer, lesser-trained soldiers with aging, outdated weapons/technology is a pretty good indicator that the population would never be able to take on the full might of the federal military branches.
- gaius 17y agoTwo words: Posse Comitatus
- krakensden 17y agoWhy do you think it would work like that? The model would probably be the IRA and gang warfare, not defined territory and set piece battles...
- philwelch 17y agoThe full might of the federal military had trouble with Iraqis and Vietnamese.
- jrockway 17y agoI think any attempt to overthrow the government would have to be an inside job. Then you get to use the government's stuff.
- ugh 17y agoThat is not how the real world works. If you put all the power the state can muster on one pile and that of the population on another, resistance against the state has been impossible – I would guess – for a few centuries (or more). But that is – again – not how it works. There are other players involved. Parts of the state might not be willing to use all that power. Other states (sometimes with vastly more power) will constrain the ability of the state to use all its power. And so on. The consequence of all this is that revolutions against tyrannies are possible without firing a single shot or using any violence at all. Even though, just looking at the raw power of the two sides, the state could easily crush the population. Just think of the fall of the Berlin Wall.
- asciilifeform 17y ago> I am worried about the future ability of a population's to resist a technological tyranny No one should consider themselves informed on the subject of robotic tyranny without having read this: http://vinay.howtolivewiki.com/blog/global/the-second-amendment-in-iraq-combat-robotics-and-the-future-of-human-liberty-820 http://vinay.howtolivewiki.com/blog/global/the-second-amendm... "...tell me, how good does a combat robot have to be to kick in your door, spray the house with mace, and hit anything that coughs with a taser until it stops moving and can be encased in spray webbing for later pickup and processing? How goes does a robot have to be to detain anybody who smells like pot? How good does a robot have to be to break up a political demonstration? Not that good. If a robot is good enough to fight wars, its good enough to do political policing. It might not solve crimes, but it can bust heads that protest and capture people who’s position is known and who have been identified as enemies of the state."