8 ms·
Intel’s Powered-Up Core I7 Broadwell Mini PC
- callumjones 12y agoThose haphazardly slapped on stickers push the point home how much we don't need these slapped things on computers and pushed in consumer's faces.
- nodata 12y ago(That is your comment?!)
- jeswin 12y agoIt is a very good point. Although they have equally good or better innards than the Mac mini, these stickers add to the cheap knock-off look in the pictures. People like attention to detail, they want to buy stuff a team was proud of building.
- lqdc13 12y agoI very much prefer the stickers to a huge glowing logo of a brand. These can be easily peeled off if unwanted.
- jeswin 12y agoOn the other hand, I am more likely to assume that a similar level of deliberation would have gone into thermal design and component choices.
- mattkevan 12y agoNot wanting to appear pedantic (well, a little), but the logo on a Mac Mini doesn't glow...
- emsy 12y agoI've never met a person that was bothered by the Apple logo. Quite the contrary, people even put stickers of the apple logo on their stuff. There are even studies that show that the presence of the logo in the work area can increase creativity. I'd argue that this is not the case for the ugly Intel stickers.
- pgeorgi 12y agoThere are people who put stickers on top of the Apple logo (some care must be taken to prevent it from shining through). I guess they're not too happy with it.
- deckiedan 12y agoOur company has a logo which is roughly circular, so one guy who has a plastic cutter has been selling overlays which make our logo glow on the back of apple laptops. Pretty cool, and very popular. :-)
- protomyth 12y agoDNA Lounge has a sticker made for the placement over the Apple Logo. http://www.dnalounge.com/store/stickers.html http://www.dnalounge.com/store/stickers.html
- DanBC 12y agoI dislike the glowing Apple logo.
- dagw 12y agoI've never met a person that was bothered by the Apple logo. Hi, nice to meet you. Love my macbook air, best laptop I ever owned. If I had the option to get one without the logo on the lid I'd happily pay $50 extra.
- emsy 12y agoHi! I wouldn't argue that there aren't people who are bothered by the logo (at the very least, it's also a security concern!). But many wear it proudly. This isn't something you usually see with Intel/Asus/Lenovo or whatever stickers.
- Lio 12y agoNot to disagree with you but the thing with the glowing logo on Apple laptops (as apposed to Apple desktops which don't have it) is that I, the user, don't have to look at it. When it's open there's no actual branding on case of a MacBook Pro, even the words MacBook Pro have been removed. At a push you could count the keyboard layout I suppose. It's been a while since I last pulled the stickers off a laptop but do they still leave a sticky residue behind?
- nodata 12y agoThey come in the box, the attention to detail is from the person who stuck them on.
- RexRollman 12y agoExactly. I have the feeling that the ARS reviewer wanted everybody to really believe there was an i7 inside.
- gadders 12y agoThey could at least put them on straight. That is really bugging me.
- bitL 12y agoI guess that's ArsTechnica's fault; other NUCs come with non-applied stickers in the box so I guess with 5i7 it's the same as well...
- bhouston 12y agoAccording to PassMark, a CPU benchmarking website, the Intel Core i7 5557U isn't that fast: https://www.cpubenchmark.net/cpu.php?cpu=Intel+Core+i7-5557U+%40+3.10GHz&id=2502 https://www.cpubenchmark.net/cpu.php?cpu=Intel+Core+i7-5557U... Now it only has a single sample, but a rating of ~5000 is a third of the performance rating of a top of the line Core i7 5960, which comes in at 15969: https://www.cpubenchmark.net/cpu.php?cpu=Intel+Core+i7-5960X+%40+3.00GHz&id=2332 https://www.cpubenchmark.net/cpu.php?cpu=Intel+Core+i7-5960X... This is not what one considers a powerful CPU.
- userbinator 12y ago5000 was pretty good 6 years ago: http://www.cpubenchmark.net/cpu.php?cpu=Intel+Core+i7+860+%40+2.80GHz&id=6 http://www.cpubenchmark.net/cpu.php?cpu=Intel+Core+i7+860+%4... The TDP is much lower on the 5557U though, at 28W vs 140W for the 5960X and 95W for the 860. Thus, the 5557U is not a leader in raw speed but several times more power-efficient.
- lqdc13 12y agoThose are multiplied by the number of cores. This one only has 2 I think. The top one has 6 cores. The CPUs in the first link that are faster are laptop CPUs with 4 cores. So per core this one is much faster than the other ones. Also has a good amount of L3 cache per core. The main problem here (imo) is the RAM, because you can't go past 16gb.
- bitL 12y agoNot just RAM but also TDP - 28W for that form factor is a bit too much. Current i5 NUC IMO hits the sweet spot - it's pretty powerful and can be made silent with the stock fan. I hope in the future Intel can squeeze i7-U into a Baytrail power envelope ;-)
- wishiknew 12y agoWhat do you mean by 'can be made silent'?
- wishiknew 12y agoGeez, I built an overpowered and heavy desktop for twice the price a few months ago when all I needed was something like this.
- sdrinf 12y agoUse case: Due to moving countries, I've recently dumped my powerhouse desktop ( http://blog.codinghorror.com/building-a-pc-part-vii-rebooting/ http://blog.codinghorror.com/building-a-pc-part-vii-rebootin... ), and am laptoping around various places; a lifestyle I will probably continue to do so for the foreseeable future. There are few, if any, performant laptops, that could get even close to the sort of performance I've used to using that machine. However, as long as deployment time is <~3 minutes, I don't necessarily need it to be a laptop; but can settle a middle road in some variations of these.
- jamespo 12y agoWhat are you doing that a specced up http://www.pcspecialist.co.uk/notebooks/optimusV-17/ http://www.pcspecialist.co.uk/notebooks/optimusV-17/ couldn't handle?
- sdrinf 12y agoChrome.exe ,no, srsly. Specifically, when doing deep infodiving, it's not uncommon to juggle (that is, actually apply ops within 30-min intervals to) 80+ tabs; 2 visual studio in the background; local number crunching: large-ish data / machine learning sandboxes; one-click virtual-machines ("wonder how this looks like in a mac?"); and the occasional steam round. 2x4 vCPU cores usually humming along at ~10-40%, 20-something GB ram usage, no swap. These reqs bias me towards performance, even at _some_ expense of mobility.
- gh02t 12y agoWhy not a remote setup? I have a high performance workstation that lives in my office- dual 12-core Xeons, 256GB RAM, Tesla etc. I have a dirt cheap Lenovo laptop (~$300 + an SSD) running OpenBSD that I use to connect over OpenVPN + SSH for doing any serious computation. You'd probably want something with a higher-res display and Windows-based, but if it's possible that sort of setup might be easier. I long ago gave up on "workstation class" laptops. You just don't get enough bang for the buck IMO. Incidentally, if you're buying small-scale HPC hardware I highly recommend ThinkMate. Their prices are far far better than Dell/IBM/etc. and their support has always been superb.
- cmrdporcupine 12y agoI have been looking for a machine to stick under the TV to run Dolphin to replace my Wii, and do stuff I use the PS3 for too. Something with enough CPU and GPU heft to do run the Dolphin emulator at high frame rates. This might do it.
- exelius 12y agoThe CPU in these things aren't really all that powerful. It's certainly better than a Raspberry Pi, but then it costs 15x as much. I don't know if they're adequate for Dolphin, but when most people talk about gaming on the NUC, they're talking about Steam in-home streaming (which works spectacularly on the NUC, btw). The NUC makes a great HTPC overall though; you can even VESA mount it so instead of sticking it under the TV, you just stick it behind the TV.
- aguki 12y agoAt that price point (~$500), one can get a i7-4XXXT in a fanless barebones setup off Aliexpress, though which CPU you get is entirely dependent on available stock. http://www.aliexpress.com/store/product/Fanless-Mini-Compact-PC-Computer-Barebone-PC-i7-with-Intel-Quad-Core-i7-4770T-2-5Ghz/800900_2046044868.html http://www.aliexpress.com/store/product/Fanless-Mini-Compact... The case seems to be an Akasa model, or an OEM variant, which rates passive cooling CPUs up to 35W TDP, so 45W cpus offered seems to be pushing it. I'll probably get one of these, or a Broadwell version when released, once my Novena arrives, to run any x86/Windows only software.
- xorcist 12y agoI can recommend (no affiliation) HD-Plex passive cases, if that's what you're after. It cools 65W, which is not enough for the most powerful desktop CPU's, but gives you much more power than the Akasa box. It's sold as a barebone to the HTPC crowd but has worked great for me as a general workstation (with no moving parts if you go for an SSD).
- johnohara 12y agoHey, thanks for posting this. Very nice.
- zantana 12y agoIndeed. I bought the i3 nuc to run my home lab and have been very happy. I really want something with more cores/memory which won't break the bank. I keep hoping for another nuc in that space, but it looks like I will have to start browsing those chinese sites.
- GreaterFool 12y agoCould wait a bit and build a small and fanless Xeon D (8 cores, 16 threads) server. Don't need a GPU for that, just ssh, for programming. OTOH fanless i7 NUC is going to be tiny (quarter of the size of fanless mini ITX?). I could take it with me when I travel and that might be worthwhile. Shame it's not quad core. And I agree the performance isn't too impressive. But tiny fanless PC that's still faster than my laptop might not be a bad idea.
- falcolas 12y agoOur company uses two of these as monitor servers in offices - they monitor the local switches, internet connections, and regional availability of our various services. We also cache Debian packages on them, making Vagrant box rebuilds much less painful. They work great for these purposes, and we rarely have to think about them.
- michaelbuddy 12y agoI got the higher end mac mini recently and it's larger than this but I'm very happy with it. Once you add all the necessities into the NUCs, you end up approaching Mac mini prices. I do like that you have more control over the drives inside.
- dman 12y agoAny idea if there is a NUC that supports triple displays employing displayport mst? Ive been wanting a small form factor pc / motherboard with three displayports ideally.
- TacoSundae 12y agoYes the NUC will do 3 displays through MST
- johnohara 12y agoWhile the article only mentions them briefly, the Gigabyte Brix is a very nice platform as well. The specs for the Brix Pro did very well too. I recently installed four (4) BXi5-4200's (w/SSD's and 8GB) into the operatories of a local dental practice and they have been rock solid. 1080p video, crystal clear images, and great audio. While they seem a little pricey at first, there are few maintenance issues -- mostly software related. These NUC style devices are the sleepers of 2014-2015.
- jareds 12y agoI've looked at these to replace my 5 year old AMD desktop but the 16gb of ram is a dealbreaker for me. I'd like the option of 32 gb of ram do to running multiple virtual machines, does anyone know of a small form factor desktop that will support this?
- MollyR 12y agoI wish these were steam boxes with a good video card. The size factor is great, I would love to use these as a console replacement. One day, hopefully . . .