4 ms·
I fully agree videos shouldn't be the main way of giving lectures in MOOCs. Or more accurately: I don't find videos particularly useful to me. My experience is
by the_af 12y ago
I fully agree videos shouldn't be the main way of giving lectures in MOOCs. Or more accurately: I don't find videos particularly useful to me.
My experience is based on 3 programming courses from Coursera: Functional Programming Principles in Scala, Reactive Programming, and Programming Languages. In all three cases, the videos did little to improve my understanding of the material, and I preferred the slides. Unfortunately, because the videos existed, the slides were (in general) less complete; I'd rather the videos did not exist and the written material was more complete instead.
Videos frustrate me because the lecturer goes too slowly or chooses to focus on the parts I find less interesting. And because it's pre-recorded, I cannot ask him/her questions. Yes, I can skip or fast-forward the video (in one course, I was so used to playing every lecture at max speed, I was surprised to find the lecturer's voice at normal speed sounded completely different :P ), but I find it so frustrating I'd rather be reading detailed text instead.
The embedded interactive quizzes are fun and motivating, but I wonder if the videos are needed at all.
- brudgers 12y agoI've taken two of those courses. I often typed the example code from the lectures in or took notes as I would in a brick and mortar class. This meant slowing the lectures down or pausing them or rewinding them. That's great for me...but I'm on Norvig's ten year plan.
- the_af 12y agoWouldn't reading the source material (and copying from there) be even better for Norvig's ten year plan? Note that the pace of brick and mortar classes drove me mad back in my student days :) Also, the deadlines from Coursera and most MOOCs conspire against watching videos at normal speed. Most of us have day jobs and the only time we can read the lectures and do the exercises is a few hours a day, late at night. In that case, speed-watching and focusing only on the most interesting parts are the only options, especially if you want to get full credits for the course. (Of course, you can take the more relaxed approach of simply not caring about the credits, and getting things done at whatever pace you find comfortable, and that's completely valid!)
- brudgers 12y agoThe deadlines in a MOOC are no different than any other deadline. Cut scope, cut quality, or deathmarch are the options for meeting them. Death march is the only option for full credit. Cutting quality will let a person play the "points game" for a certificate. Cutting scope means learning whatever you learn in the frame of the class. One of Grossman's observations is that the length of the class correlates with completion rate. The longer the class, the more likely something will come up and throw everything off schedule. Knowing that fact means the longer the course, the more likely cutting quality will be necessary to earn a certificate. The underlying premise for skipping around to just the interesting parts is that the entirety of the subject does not interest the student. There's nothing wrong with that. But that's not really a good target audience for the design of a class. That student is already committed to partial disengagement. My take on programming has become that watching a programming video is like watching Jimi Hendrix play the guitar. A beginner learns almost nothing applicable because they don't have the mechanical technique as a basis for informing their seeing. A virtuoso will see new techniques and ways they could do them better. Watching Grossman type text into a box or Ullman do a proof is less informative until I had the mechanical experience of following along. We all tune out video because it is so ubiquitous. The courses on Coursera are real courses. The results of not taking notes during lectures are pretty much the same as not taking notes during a brick and mortar lecture: some geniuses will ace the test anyway and everyone else will do average, mediocre or poorly according to their nature.
- the_af 12y agoDisclaimer: the following comes with a big "in my opinion" preceding it. Um, I think no-one finds every part of any given subject interesting to the same degree. That's human nature. But also, maybe you already understand some parts and want to skip ahead to the more difficult parts. Sadly, in the excessively constrained format of video, sometimes the teacher will choose to focus on the topics you already understand, and neglects others. Such are the limitations of video format -- and indeed, of brick and mortar classes! Only the full, unabridged text gives you a (relatively) unconstrained explanation of all relevant topics. Of course, it also comes with some disadvantages: it can overwhelm the student, or present topics in the wrong order, or -- even -- focus on the "wrong" things, because after all written notes are also space-constrained. But I find it a way less constrained format anyway. I find taking notes to be an uninteresting artifact of "live" classes. What truly matters is that you do the exercises and understand them. If I gave the impression that I favored the "lazy" approach, I apologize. To be honest, I think watching the videos is both the lazy approach (only reading the notes seems like the serious approach to me) AND a time-waster. You are both more efficient AND gain a better understanding of the source material if you read the written notes/book and also do the exercises.