9 ms·
Why My MOOC Is Not Built on Video
- jrbeal 12y agoI'd be fine with a video-less MOOC. Just give me a textbook and tell me the chapters to study and what assignments to work on, and I'll be fine. It's difficult to do this on your own because you never know what to focus on without guidance. You're likely to waste valuable time down some unimportant or meaningless rabbit hole! Of course, I'd hope the MOOC would offer a support mechanism in case I needed help.
- freehunter 12y agoI was recently re-reading a textbook that I had in college and I realized just how much of the book we skipped in class when I noticed how many chapters were unfamiliar to me. I remembered how much we skipped around to put things in a more logical order and what questions we skipped in the tests as well... not sure why textbooks are often written to illogically that it takes a teacher to decipher them.
- fenfennek 12y agoI think Tim Ferris commented on this problem once in a Google Talk where the topic of the quality of (text)books came up: To a big part it comes down to the fact that ideas and chapters presented in books are most often structured and sequenced in a way that suits the author in writing it. Less about what would actually be the best way of presenting the material from a learner's perspective.
- the_af 12y agoI fully agree videos shouldn't be the main way of giving lectures in MOOCs. Or more accurately: I don't find videos particularly useful to me. My experience is based on 3 programming courses from Coursera: Functional Programming Principles in Scala, Reactive Programming, and Programming Languages. In all three cases, the videos did little to improve my understanding of the material, and I preferred the slides. Unfortunately, because the videos existed, the slides were (in general) less complete; I'd rather the videos did not exist and the written material was more complete instead. Videos frustrate me because the lecturer goes too slowly or chooses to focus on the parts I find less interesting. And because it's pre-recorded, I cannot ask him/her questions. Yes, I can skip or fast-forward the video (in one course, I was so used to playing every lecture at max speed, I was surprised to find the lecturer's voice at normal speed sounded completely different :P ), but I find it so frustrating I'd rather be reading detailed text instead. The embedded interactive quizzes are fun and motivating, but I wonder if the videos are needed at all.
- brudgers 12y agoI've taken two of those courses. I often typed the example code from the lectures in or took notes as I would in a brick and mortar class. This meant slowing the lectures down or pausing them or rewinding them. That's great for me...but I'm on Norvig's ten year plan.
- the_af 12y agoWouldn't reading the source material (and copying from there) be even better for Norvig's ten year plan? Note that the pace of brick and mortar classes drove me mad back in my student days :) Also, the deadlines from Coursera and most MOOCs conspire against watching videos at normal speed. Most of us have day jobs and the only time we can read the lectures and do the exercises is a few hours a day, late at night. In that case, speed-watching and focusing only on the most interesting parts are the only options, especially if you want to get full credits for the course. (Of course, you can take the more relaxed approach of simply not caring about the credits, and getting things done at whatever pace you find comfortable, and that's completely valid!)
- brudgers 12y agoThe deadlines in a MOOC are no different than any other deadline. Cut scope, cut quality, or deathmarch are the options for meeting them. Death march is the only option for full credit. Cutting quality will let a person play the "points game" for a certificate. Cutting scope means learning whatever you learn in the frame of the class. One of Grossman's observations is that the length of the class correlates with completion rate. The longer the class, the more likely something will come up and throw everything off schedule. Knowing that fact means the longer the course, the more likely cutting quality will be necessary to earn a certificate. The underlying premise for skipping around to just the interesting parts is that the entirety of the subject does not interest the student. There's nothing wrong with that. But that's not really a good target audience for the design of a class. That student is already committed to partial disengagement. My take on programming has become that watching a programming video is like watching Jimi Hendrix play the guitar. A beginner learns almost nothing applicable because they don't have the mechanical technique as a basis for informing their seeing. A virtuoso will see new techniques and ways they could do them better. Watching Grossman type text into a box or Ullman do a proof is less informative until I had the mechanical experience of following along. We all tune out video because it is so ubiquitous. The courses on Coursera are real courses. The results of not taking notes during lectures are pretty much the same as not taking notes during a brick and mortar lecture: some geniuses will ace the test anyway and everyone else will do average, mediocre or poorly according to their nature.
- karmacondon 12y agoSimply: The average person can read at ~300 words per minute, and listen at ~150 words per minute. I'm not a big fan of video as a tool for conveying information in general. Not only can I read faster than I can listen, but I can skim and skip around as well. There are situations where video is the best way to impart certain information, but those seem to be the rare cases. I hate it when websites make me sit through a 3 minute video in order to get an answer to one simple question, or to understand "What does this thing do?" I've never taken a MOOC course because I can't imagine having the time to watch X hours of someone talking at a camera. If this video-less trend catches on I might actually be able to benefit from online education.
- wyclif 12y agoYou can always speed the video up. While I realise that this is a suboptimal solution and I also prefer text, I don't think I've ever watched a MOOC video on normal speed.
- NhanH 12y agoPausing and thinking is extremely distracting. I've always feel like I tend to gloss over the details whenever I'm watching the videos, along the opposite that I'm being bored and distracted because it's too slow. Since both could happen in the same speed, moving speed up and down is not an option.
- axlprose 12y ago> I tend to gloss over the details whenever I'm watching the videos That's not necessarily a bad thing. If you think about how many times your reading is slowed down because you feel you have to re-read a passage to 'get it', audio/video sources totally help do away with that. It may sound like that weakens your learning, but if you've ever researched anything on improving reading speed, you'll know that it's better to not focus on 'getting' things on the first pass anyway, and instead continue plowing through the entire content just trying to get the jist of it, relying on multiple passes to really understand things better instead (this probably works for the same reasons spaced-repetition works). Obviously you can do that with reading as that's where the tip originated, but clearly auditory/visual input helps facilitate that if only because rewinding is less tempting than re-reading due to it being a chore. > along the opposite that I'm being bored and distracted because it's too slow Seems like a personal preference thing. To me, I get this with reading as well. It's just not stimulating enough for me, even when I read fast, cause it's easy for competing thoughts to take over and distract me. Audio/video on the other hand, work for me precisely because I can't think with that much stimulation going on. I'm too busy listening and watching to really have the resources to process any distracting thoughts, so it's easier to focus. Just my $0.02
- benkant 12y agoIn my experience, both with self-study and at university, the best way to gain and retain knowledge is by working problems. To do this you need: demonstrations of the concepts, problems, hints and solutions. Hints and solutions can be time consuming to obtain at university (office hours) and might be impossible if you can't find instructor manuals for self-study. Khan Academy makes the most sense to me. You work the problems until you can't, at which point you use the hints or watch the videos. Then continue. The only lectures that were useful to me at university was the first one, where they discussed how the class would run, and the last one where they discussed the exam. Labs and tutorials were useful if I wanted to get hints on how to work problems. I agree with TFA. Videos should by no means be the focus. They can be very helpful demonstrations. If the goal is to be able to solve problems, that's what you should be spending the most time doing.
- webwanderings 12y agoNot that I frequent many MOOCs, but I have not seen Khan Academy like techniques anywhere else, not even at edX. I think KA's got it right. They've got the best possible solution which will evolve things to the next level, if MOOCs are to stay afloat in the future.
- analog31 12y agoIn my experience, both with self-study and at university, the best way to gain and retain knowledge is by working problems. To do this you need: demonstrations of the concepts, problems, hints and solutions. Oddly enough, I found this to be the case, even in my humanities courses. I learned more about a subject by having to write about it, than from merely reading or memorizing for an exam.
- rhino369 12y ago>In my experience, both with self-study and at university, the best way to gain and retain knowledge is by working problems. I'm this way too, but I don't think everyone is. I think a successful program should include problem solving, reading, and audio/visual. Because people learn differently.
- rayiner 12y agoI'm surprised this is a surprise. I thought it was common knowledge that videos were a terrible medium for education. That was the lesson of the failed 1990's "multimedia education" push.
- penprogg 12y agoI agree with the author's sentiment 100%. As others have stated, the reason that video is worse than text for learning is because A. The rate at which you can read is faster than you can listen B. Video technology is often a hassle when you need to skip around. C. It's cheaper to write and revise text than video. D. Videos consume large amounts of data. But I'm going to add another point. E. Lecturers most often don't know what I as a student am struggling with. They may focus on things I understand easily and spend a majority of time discussing things I already know. However, if I decide to skip a portion of a video I could potentially miss a really important detail necessary for understanding the subject matter. With a book I can skim. Important information is often marked in a certain way to make it stand out from other data. It's also organized in sections and chapters so I can easily skip around. With videos this isn't possible. Also, what happens when all of this information is outdated? Now you have a bunch of videos with outdated and potentially false information out there and nobody will know. My ideal alternative would be to remove lectures entirely and to have interactive labs where teachers and TAs help students complete assignments based on assigned readings. The instructor for the course would be responsible for overseeing the teaching assistants and preparing the course outline. The TAs would help guide the students in completing the assignments or mini projects. Then a couple of time a semester there would be larger projects that tie together what the students have learned.
- davidbanham 12y ago> My ideal alternative would be to remove lectures entirely and to have interactive labs where teachers and TAs help students complete assignments based on assigned readings. The instructor for the course would be responsible for overseeing the teaching assistants and preparing the course outline. The TAs would help guide the students in completing the assignments or mini projects. Then a couple of time a semester there would be larger projects that tie together what the students have learned. _yes_. This seems so obvious to me. I am completely mystified as to why all universities seem to be ignoring it. I worry that it's just because videotaping lectures and putting them online is so much easier than actually re-evaluating the pedagogy.
- neaanopri 12y ago
- rajacombinator 12y agoWhile I agree with the author on the relative uselessness of lectures/video, I wonder how much this is related to individual learning styles. I definitely observed many classmates who benefited more from lectures than I did.
- kbrwn 12y agoRecently completed MITx 600.001 which had a fair share of lectures along with a textbook. The lectures were mostly just a rehashing of what was presented in the book but there was something about watching the code run that really made a difference. I also think that having "finger exercises" after a short video explaining a concept is quite helpful. Although it seems that could easily be achieved in book format as well. The live feedback after submitting code was what helped me the most. At the same time as this I took another course on a different website (coursera) Cloud Computing Concepts Part 1 which was entirely lecture based. The topic was extremely interesting to me and I have moved on to the next course in the series but I do find the all lecture format with quiz based homework to be less than ideal. I try to make up for the lack of a textbook by reading the documentation of concepts covered each week but often times it is hard to pick the most essential material. The edx platform is really stunning in terms of engagement and feedback from a student perspective. It is easy to imagine a course presented on it with little to no lecture if a strong companion text was provided.
- randomnumber53 12y agoMy favorite thing about the MITx MOOCs are that they have really well-designed, carefully-devised problem sets, which I think might be the most important factor of a great class.
- MollyR 12y agoI read faster than I listen/watch. But I absorb information more completely from video lectures. I often watch video lectures at 1.5 to 2x speed too.
- karmicthreat 12y agoSome of the most effective compsci related MOOCs I've found are the Udacity programming MOOCs that have live coding. You can just drop right into a python REPL and try using what you just learned. We need more of this in a variety of domains.
- douche 12y agoThere are a lot of bloggers (John Sonmez is the most notable), who I have stopped following because they have shifted to video. I really don't have the time to watch a video, when I can read the same content in text form 2-3x faster, and do a Ctrl-F to find any terms of interest later when I want to review the content. It's a singularly inappropriate form of communication for technical subjects. I imagine it has to hurt their Google rankings as well, especially when they don't include a transcript.
- douche 12y agoI'm a little surprised at the strong support this comment has driven. Haha, I usually use this account for opinions that I would think controversial.
- bramgg 12y agoI see this opinion voted to the top of Hacker News all the time. People seem to forget that watching something in video format is just so damn convenient, and requires little effort.
- _abattoir 12y agoNot sure about your definition of convenient, but to me, time is king.
- kranner 12y agoIf it's a technical subject and something genuinely new for the viewer/reader, comprehension and learning are probably the bottlenecks, not ease of consumption. If this opinion is popular, maybe there's a good reason for it?
- alashley 12y agoWatching a video does require little effort, but learning -- and subsequently retaining anything is where the real effort is required with technical subjects.
- brudgers 12y agoI've been watching the SICP videos this weekend with the goal of making it all the way through this time (I tried watching them about a year and a half ago after taking my first programming MOOC). What struck me this time was how much the emphasis is on practical software engineering rather than Lisp. That's what Ableson is so intensely passionate about in the video, not the theory. And so picking up the book and looking at the parallel text, I reread it in a whole new light. It was like rereading Eco's Name of the Rose after 25 years and not as the piece of pop fiction I thought it was the first time. Which brings me to my point that video is just another communication channel. It conveys particular information efficiently and other information less efficiently. Text is no different. Without the video I would never have picked up that SICP and Code Complete have many similarities in subject matter and one just starts with a clean slate and the other in the messy middle. Video does not need to be fancy to be effective. See Jeffery Ullman's Finite Automata on Coursera. It's PowerPoint and a small talking head and a red pen: And it's better than reading the book he wrote with Who because though dense, it's an order of magnitude less dense than the text. On the other hand, University of Phoenix operated its online courses with NNTP and was reasonably interactive though asynchronous. It's a matter of curriculum development I suppose. Dan Grossman at University of Washington compares developing a MOOC to writing a textbook and that probably captures the domain of possibilities.
- ARothfusz 12y agoThe video poison is spreading to software documentation too. I can't imagine a bigger waste of time than watching someone type code or work on a command line, yet I've gotten the request many times. For GUIs I can somewhat sympathize, especially if the software changes the layout with every release (I'm looking at you, Blender), and it really does take 1000 words to describe where to click. But typed, word-oriented communication does not benefit from videos. And unless you're Vi Hart, teaching mathematics probably isn't going to benefit from an all-video presentation either. So, kudos to the author.
- arikrak 12y agoI don't get why MOOCs are so focused on video. I think many people enjoy the relaxed experience of watching a video more than reading, but why ignore people who rather jump right into a text? A text is easier to skim search and reference than a video, and easier to keep up-to-date for the creators. However, I think the best option is a combination of text with visual and interactive content, such as graphical representation of complex ideas and manipulable formulas or code.
- bayesianhorse 12y agoOne advantage of videos is the emotional component. It seems like students do enjoy videos over whatever text the instructors provide. Another advantage is the subtle leakage of the instructor's opinions and thought processes. At least I perceive video to be slightly better in this regard.
- petercooper 12y agoA text is easier to skim search and reference than a video That's great when you're refreshing or referencing, but when you're learning something from scratch, text presents an easier opportunity to "skim" and miss things than video which sorta decides the speed of the treadmill for you. I'm the author of a book and the amount of queries I get that were answered on the previous page.. I think many people just don't read every word in books they read (but I sympathize, because neither do I).
- arikrak 12y agoRight, you need to learn by doing and cannot just passively watch a video or read a text. To learn a topic like programming, you need to practice it. So a good format is to combine a text with small questions and coding challenges. If the user is unsure of how to solve something, it's easier to look it up in the text they read than in a video they watched. And hopefully they'll recognize that the question is asking something they can answer on their own without emailing the author. (Though once the text is online, there should be some kind of forum there to ask questions anyways.) (PS - I'm actually looking for programming authors or bloggers who would be interested in publishing online with questions and programming challenges.)
- haberdasher 12y agoI agree with most of this and am the developer of Presentious. We believe audio paired with slides + a transcript with full-text search is better than video 9/10 times. You can see it all in action here: http://presentio.us/view/p1tcHs http://presentio.us/view/p1tcHs I'm actively seeking feedback and testers in the education space!
- vacri 12y agoIn fact, as far back as 1971, Donald Bligh concluded that “there is not much difference in the effectiveness of methods to present information.” Apart from 1971 having only nascent experience with educational videos, it's really hard to accept that the science videos of the 50s and 60s were no more effective at imparting information than a book. Seeing things move around as the presenter talks about them can really help to understand the topic. It really depends on the topic that's being discusses - sometimes a video is better, sometimes a book is better, sometimes you absolutely have to get your hands dirty. You can read a book all you want and watch videos 'til the cows come home, but neither will make you proficient in tying a ligature. I guess my problem with the statement is that it's absolutist. Some things are better in text, some things are better shown, some things are better done in person, not to mention other methods as well. Choose the appropriate tool for the job. And know your audience as well - the 'general public' is different to 'self-motivated autodidacts', for example.
- ufo 12y agoThe thing that bothers me more is how many of these MOOCS require you to sign up to be able to watch the lectures. Sometime I would just like to watch some of the lectures and not have to bother with assignments and quizzes.
- laex 12y agoThis reminds of the blog post by Adam Brimo, the founder of OpenLearning (http://www.openlearning.com http://www.openlearning.com) - a MOOC startup heavily focused around creating communities. It's short, so I'll just post it here: --BEGIN POST-- Every profession and every professional engages with teaching and learning in some capacity. Yet many individuals go through university or higher education degrees and fail to learn to their full potential. Why? Because the learning environment is focused on content delivery. In both online and offline educational settings, the structure of teaching and learning is primarily instructional: the lecturer delivers content and the student passively receives it. Lectures and tutorials are teacher-centred and teacher-directed; the teacher possesses the knowledge and power within the learning environment. There is rarely peer-to-peer learning, nor student handover or empowerment within the learning process. This of course incites some level of learning – if it didn’t, we would all still be stuck in first-year university – but it doesn’t promote that deep, conceptual understanding of a learning area that is the hallmark of rich learning. Despite the pervasiveness of the instructional model within higher education, how people learn best isn’t through passively receiving content. Rich learning occurs when students actively construct their own knowledge and understanding; when they connect new information with their own world and when they are intrinsically motivated in the process. This deep learning also happens through interaction, discussion and collaboration with others. Think about a topic you’re most excited and passionate about. Do you want to be actively involved in your own learning process? Do you want to discuss and share your experiences of the topic with your peers? Do you want to connect new knowledge with your current awareness through real world examples, to develop that deeper understanding? Do you want to be intrinsically motivated to learn? Do you want to be empowered? Or do you want to passively listen to an expert deliver a lecture? OpenLearning wants to change the current model of higher education, to align with how students really learn. We’re about empowering students in their learning process; where learners can actively construct their own knowledge that is relevant and meaningful to them. We provide an online learning environment that fosters deep learning, intrinsic motivation and collaboration with other students. We promote dynamic communication through fun and interactive learning communities; where students can discuss concepts, share relevant and meaningful media, and provide peer review, support and feedback in a safe and positive learning space. We are both the Learning Environment and the Student Hangout. Traditional educational models see these as mutually exclusive entities; we see them as the same thing. Students love doing courses through our platform, because we speak in their language. Individuals and organisations love running courses through our platform, because students are engaged, intrinsically motivated and productive. The OpenLearning philosophy promotes a lifelong love of learning that facilitates students reaching their full learning potential. --END POST-- Full Disclosure: I work at OpenLearning.
- pmontra 12y agoSome MOOC have both video and PDF slides. I remember a computer graphic corse on Coursera. The videos were obviously useful in many ways but the PDFs were better for finding the formulas when doing the tests.
- bayesianhorse 12y agoMoocs wouldn't have the same pull if they didn't do video. There are reasons why "E-Learning" never really took off before the MOOC movement. Some part of this is that text books tend to be written as reference material, and don't come with a "first learner's cut", a path through the material which is suited for someone just starting to learn the subject. Videos are a medium which seems to be easier to master for university instructors than really good teaching texts. Don't ask me why...
- mcbetz 12y agoIt's not only MOOCs that use videos a lot. There are so many self publishers who sell videos as a bonus to an ebook. At a premium price. Nathan Barry and Brennan Dunn may be the most prominent examples for this and Barry even advices this practice in his book "Authority" - and he is successful with this strategy. So obviously some customers perceive videos as an extra value and are ready to pay the premium price.