3 ms·
Companies can't "force" countries to do anything, the idea is hilarious. Countries have police and jails and armies. Corporations have got nothing. Corporation
by prawn 12y ago
Companies can't "force" countries to do anything, the idea is hilarious. Countries have police and jails and armies. Corporations have got nothing.
Corporations have got media clout/ownership, threats of capital flight, lobbyists and so on.
- mike_hearn 12y agoThe vast majority of all corporations don't own any media. Lobbying isn't some magic form of mind control: it's just them presenting their case to the government, which is free to ignore them and routinely does. Threat of capital flight is really just "if you screw us over we'll try and leave" which is hardly any power at all, especially as often companies can't leave because they have huge fixed assets there. Really, corporations have no power at all. They have the power to speak and maybe to leave. Whereas governments can do whatever they like.
- Retra 12y agoThat's really unrealistic. Governments are run by people -- who can be influenced fairly easily.
- prawn 12y agoI live in Australia. We could've used the Minerals Resource Rent Tax to build a sovereign fund similar to Norway's StatOil during our so-called mining boom. Instead, mining companies and business interests threatened to invest elsewhere and the tax was ditched. Capital flight is a very powerful tool.
- mike_hearn 12y agoStatOil is a state owned oil company. Australia could have created a state owned mining company, if that had really been a problem. I guess it preferred not to.
- prawn 12y agoAnd how would that have gone down with exactly the same opponents?
- mike_hearn 12y agoIt wouldn't, but who cares? If they weren't willing to mine, then Australia could have built its own mining company. It would have taken longer but state owned resource extraction companies are common, it's clearly not politically or technically impossible.