3 ms·
A broad general education helps foster critical thinking and creativity. Indeed. But critical thinking and creativity are the things second least prized in US
by bediger4000 12y ago
A broad general education helps foster critical thinking and creativity.
Indeed. But critical thinking and creativity are the things second least prized in US classrooms, right after outright disobedience. So it's no real wonder that broad, general education has fallen out of favor.
- Jimmy 12y agoWhat countries do a better job of fostering creativity and critical thinking? Every culture has its sacred cows. The idea of an environment that's fully tolerant and welcoming towards any and all dissent is, as far as I can tell, a myth. Nonetheless, my experiences with US (university) classrooms have generally been positive. As long as it's relevant to the topic of discussion, students are free to pose a wide range of ideas without fear of social or academic reprisal. Although I must admit that some recent developments on college campuses with regards to freedom of speech are troubling.
- aianus 12y agoAt least here in Canada, it's too late by the time students get to university. The high schools have already selected for obedience and rote memorization skills when sorting their students for university admission. That and rich cheaters who can afford to purchase higher grades by taking accredited night classes.
- JoshTriplett 12y ago> Nonetheless, my experiences with US (university) classrooms have generally been positive. As long as it's relevant to the topic of discussion, students are free to pose a wide range of ideas without fear of social or academic reprisal. In university, yes, after 13 years of the exact opposite.
- mc32 12y agoThey also don't pay very well. One alternative is make GE a requisite part of any education. Graduating with a liberal arts degree leads to masses of dissatisfied students who pine of the job desirability and pay of STEM workers. in terms of creativity, I'm pretty sure science has lots of creativity. What does 'creativity' even mean? imagination, ability to create things? What have the liberal arts given society whereas sciences have brought forth the end of diseases, solutions for all kinds of maladies, shortcoming and ills of society. Critical thinking is paramount in science, but I think general education as an end in itself is an oversell. You don't see china and India rushing to shore up their GE gap, do you? No, I'm pretty sure they know what pays the bills and energizes their economies. Let me know when a liberal arts degree brings home the bacon.
- eropple 12y agoYour preoccupation with paying bills that are already well and effectively paid and economies quite energized seems to obscure to you that a very large part of the purpose of a university is to turn out well-rounded human beings. While I have a CS degree (which in my school was a liberal arts degree), I credit my decision to take as few in-major classes as possible, and spend as much time in the humanities as I could, to be why I manage somehow to do very well for myself and yet claim some understanding of literature, economics, and politics. A modern education is more than trade-school workmanship, and your rhetoric devalues it to such. You're right, in that China, India, et al. don't value that. But they as countries and cultures aren't at the same point on the cultural equivalent of Maslow's hierarchy as we are, and their actions in no way must determine ours.
- kazinator 12y agoWould your alma mater have graduated you with a CS degree if you had no humanities credits at all? Mine wouldn't have.
- eropple 12y agoIt would have graduated me with less than half of the ones I had, and significantly poorer ones--one learns very little in a 100-level but might open one's brain a bit better in the right 300-level and I pushed to be in the right courses. My university had a fantastic Honors College where I learned a ton I wouldn't have picked up elsewhere, too--I was the only CS student in my year of the program and the Honors College covered most of the gen-eds so quickly that I had enough time and credit space to take classes that were more interesting and more valuable. (None of them were in CS.) I didn't finish out at the Honors College, because the CS department wouldn't play ball as far as senior projects went and I didn't have the bandwidth to do two, but it's still my most treasured time at my university. The courses that were considered part of the humanities, at least as far as STEM folks go, were pretty questionable in general, too. My university thought "technical writing" was a good course to be part of the English curriculum for STEM majors. But "good writing" wasn't, if you follow? Nor was any sort of philosophy, more than the barest rudiments of history (in a country where primary and secondary history education is little more than heroifying the names everyone knows)...it was a dire scene. (Of the liberal arts courses I found, and continue to find valuable, only microeconomics was a required course. Incredibly valuable, though--literally every person should be comfortable with the basics of microeconomics and macroeconomics, and if anybody posting here isn't, you should drop everything and get there. It's Understanding Humans 101.) Even as I'm working with some people involved with the school to push for better technical literacy for non-STEM people--because that's important--I am pushing on the CS department to turn out functional humans as well. "We're tech people" cannot be an excuse for social, political, historical, and economical ignorance.
- com2kid 12y ago> Indeed. But critical thinking and creativity are the things second least prized in US classrooms, right after outright disobedience. Really? I never got downgraded for giving an answer that the teacher disagreed with, rather I was given good marks for being able to clearly present my side of a discussion. For the classes I took that were subjective, History, English (in regards to literary critiques), etc, it was made quite clear that what was most valued was our ability to made a well reasoned and well thought out argument. I had teachers who would frequently play devil's advocate and argue against any position a student took up, with the same teacher taking opposite sides of an issue for sequential questions asked. Highlights of Middle School include debating the supremacy of Roman versus Greek societal structures, studying major world religions past and present, and lots long form essays. High School and College history classes consisted of "well here is the truth about stuff, yeah it is nasty" and the breaking down of nearly every beloved trope and fetishism of American supremacy. But that is just my experience going through public school. :) (And of course anecdotes aren't worth much, but I don't think there is any sort of nation wide conspiracy to undermine critical thinking!)
- bediger4000 12y ago* don't think there is any sort of nation wide conspiracy to undermine critical thinking!* I don't happen to think so either. Sorry I gave that impression. I think that a bias against creativity and critical thinking exists as emergent behavior. Teachers and administrators have to get things done, there's tests to give and grade, forms to fill out, report cards to send out, and loads of standardized testing upon which schools and teachers are rated. Some random kid arguing against some question on a standardized test only disrupts the entire thing. There is a bias, I don't think you can deny it, and it's all emergent, a second order effect of other things.