4 ms·
Can Github ask for US Government help with it, since it's an attack by [presumably] foreign sovereign entity? It's paying taxes in US, right — so it may expect
by golergka 12y ago
Can Github ask for US Government help with it, since it's an attack by [presumably] foreign sovereign entity? It's paying taxes in US, right — so it may expect some kind of protection, isn't this what taxes are about?
- fixxer 12y agoThat service only extends to the MPAA /s
- est 12y agoWell, the DDoS target, github.com/greatfire is funded by US government. So US government is fueling the DDoS in certain aspect.
- pjc50 12y ago""Cybercrime"" and ""cyberterrorism"" resources are only deployed (a) for securing more funding (b) for expanding US surveillance or sometimes (c) on behalf of big donors like the copyright industry. The US has no interest in saying "international cyberattack should be illegal" because then other countries might insist that it stop. They could go for a trade war escalation, but that would at some point have Apple as a casualty.
- diminoten 12y agoThat's not true at all, what the hell? Realize you're talking to folks who do this kind of stuff for a living, rather than just the random Internet denizens of most other websites. The FBI will regularly inform and assist companies who've been breached, for example. The US government is very interested in protecting US companies. That said, they don't quite have any guidance from congress on how to do that, so right now the assistance is limited. It is most certainly there, however, and your tinfoil-hat nonsense doesn't really fly.
- srj 12y agoWhen I was an admin of an IRC network we regularly reported large scale DDoS attacks to an FBI agent assigned to us. He didn't care. Some of those attacks took the network down for a while and resulted in many users moving to other networks. In at least two cases we even figured out the identity, address, and phone numbers of the people doing it and there was no movement on it. Then one day one of the people we had the identity of boasted on how he had briefly brought down the website of one of the democratic primary candidates. We forwarded that information and our case was reassigned to another agent and the person was arrested immediately. I absolutely think it's true that the US government is only interested in protecting established and powerful figures. I suspect the reason is career driven - defending the little guys isn't glamorous and probably has no promotion impact.
- jebblue 12y agoHow did the new agent perform for other cases? Was he/she more attentive than the first agent?
- nolanhanz 12y agoIts a matter of finance more than anything - if the people of the United States are paying you to protect national interests that is exactly what they should be doing. I can't speak for your specific situation but my time on the internet leads me to believe they have bigger fish to fry. Sorry though man I know that had to suck.
- RogerL 12y agoPlease don't write such baseless assertions; we are trying to keep the post quality high here. Your other responder works in this field, and I have been on the other side (worked for a company that got this sort of help). We also regularly had the FBI come in and give talks on the sorts of things they were working on in this space.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- snowwrestler 12y agoI would be shocked if the Feds were not helping GitHub in some capacity, and I would also be shocked if either GitHub or the Feds talked about that.