4 ms·
>when will the rest of the world kick China of the internet? One day we're advocating net neutrality and the next day we want to ban entire countries from the
by wongarsu 12y ago
>when will the rest of the world kick China of the internet?
One day we're advocating net neutrality and the next day we want to ban entire countries from the internet? I still prefer net neutrality, thank you.
- freshyill 12y agoI don't think banning countries from the Internet is the answer, but net neutrality seems like a completely separate issue.
- wongarsu 12y agoNet neutrality is about carriers treating all traffic equally. Banning a country from the internet is discriminating traffic by origin. That sounds like a net neutrality issue if there ever was one. Whether the discrimination happens in the hardware or in the software stack is a mere implementation detail.
- jasonwocky 12y ago> Net neutrality is about carriers treating all traffic equally If it was simply "about" that, then that would include DDOS traffic. Which no one in their right mind wants to treat equally.
- cubano 12y agoSure it is, but if some carriers are a state-sponsored arm of a bad actor and are told by their masters not to treat traffic equally, thus breaking the net neutrality pact, then what are the responsibilities of the the other carriers? Worms, meet can.
- vacri 12y agoSo because the Chinese government are being hostile, all the chinese companies innocently doing their own business should have their comms cut off as well? Chinese families should not be able to contact their travelling members? This is definitively the exact same issue - the Chinese government is not the only entity to use the Chinese intertubes.
- jfroma 12y agoI disagree with parent but I have learned from this case that anyone with access to a major CDN or the great firewall can take down any website. There is unbalanced power. What if I don't have access to the OPs team of github?