2 ms·
> No one should get a $5000 ticket. Why not? This http://www.businessinsider.com/a-millionaire-in-finland-got-a-60000-speeding-ticket-2015-3 http://www.busine
by adamnemecek 12y ago
> No one should get a $5000 ticket.
Why not?
This http://www.businessinsider.com/a-millionaire-in-finland-got-a-60000-speeding-ticket-2015-3 http://www.businessinsider.com/a-millionaire-in-finland-got-...
seems pretty fair to me.
- djf1 12y agoIf person A and person B commit the same fineable offense, it seems fair to me that the fine should be the same for both people. After all, shouldn't the fine be, in expectation, equivalent to the damage caused by the offense?
- adamnemecek 12y agoDo you think that it would be a good idea to have a fixed amount tax? I'm not talking about a flat tax, I'm talking about making everyone pay the same amount.
- ptaipale 12y agoBecause it creates a situation where it becomes stupidly risky to be affluent; people do make mistakes with e.g. speed limits - not everyone crosses them intentionally - and paying a € 50 000 fine for doing 21 km/h over a speed limit really makes people consider emigrating and taking their businesses to a more reasonable place. It also makes it more difficult to attract high-income workforce from abroad, thus having a negative impact on high-tech industries.
- tomohawk 12y agoIt just puts more pressure on people to move their wealth into corporations. How would you fine someone with no income or wealth, but who controls corporations that have plenty? Also, a persons wealth has nothing to do with the crime. Punishment should be based on the crime, not on a person's status.
- maxerickson 12y agoOwnership of corporations should show up as personal wealth. The corporate structure might slightly obfuscate the details, but if you try to hard to hide wealth in the corporation you quickly get to the point where fraud is being committed. I guess you can have the corporation own the vehicle, but you get around that easily by fining the driver.