3 ms·
The worst part about it is that Bitcoin won't even support pure capitalism as its supporters envision, but will precess into crony capitalism just as we have to
by mindslight 12y ago
The worst part about it is that Bitcoin won't even support pure capitalism as its supporters envision, but will precess into crony capitalism just as we have today.
Money needs to be anonymous. When it is not, redemption and transfer will be given special preference based on who you are rather than an independent value. When you perform a transaction and its effects aren't solely the transfer of value or you even need to file paperwork to report it (!), you're not really dealing with money. When a transaction can be reversed after it's been made, you're not dealing with money.
And while Bitcoin currently has these properties in that a name isn't tied to a transaction, the blockchain is simply a list of which psuedonyms gave what to who. It lacks the important property of "untraceability" which prevents malicious actors from tying nyms to your singular government mandated identity (cf Chaumian tokens) and therefore implementing these "features".
(And for the inevitable response, no, ad-hoc mixes are not a solution. They force the attacker to be active (eg pass laws) instead of just passively watching. When untraceability doesn't apply unconditionally to every transaction, then transactions which attempt it will be gradually more frowned upon. It's not hard to envision a future where types of Bitcoin users are progressively forced to register their wallets).
- skilesare 12y agoI flip this on its head. Would you hold some apple stock anonymously? Probably not. You want the dividend. We move value transfer to a 'no cash without capital' so that you really aren't interested in being anonymous anymore...or if you are you are forfeiting a significant future benefit. (I do propose a system of privacy pools for transactions that need to be private, but in general this isn't necessary.)
- Mtinie 12y ago> You want the dividend. Dividends can already be issued on some blockchain implementations. For example, https://nubits.com/nushares/introduction https://nubits.com/nushares/introduction
- kanzure 12y ago> Would you hold some apple stock anonymously? Probably not. You want the dividend. Oh, that is nearly trivial with some of these systems. Dividends can be spent to the same scriptPubKey (or other mechanism) that controls spending the stock itself. I mean, in a system where there is apparently a "stock" asset, naturally.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- task_queue 12y agoAnd if we look at how it's implemented in practice, anonymity ends at the handful of gatekeepers who control the exchanges.
- irickt 12y agoThis article makes the case strongly http://aeon.co/magazine/technology/on-the-high-seas-of-the-hidden-internet/ http://aeon.co/magazine/technology/on-the-high-seas-of-the-h... "... order in actual markets depends on threats of violence – whether the penalties embedded in the laws of the state, or the bloody interventions of mob bosses. In the absence of such arrangements, predators move in. The Silk Road’s business model worked only if genuinely ruthless people didn’t notice its critical vulnerabilities."