4 ms·
IQ tests come with a lot of social and cultural bias. So, for example, immigrants tend to do more poorly and members of an outclass tend to do more poorly (for
by Mz 17y ago
IQ tests come with a lot of social and cultural bias. So, for example, immigrants tend to do more poorly and members of an outclass tend to do more poorly (for example, historically this meant Black Americans tended to test poorly). I would think one thing going on here is a kind of harm to the social orientation of the test-taker. If everyone "hates" you, what's your motivation for being "agreeable"? And if your answers stop "agreeing" with what is socially valued, your test score can be hurt.
Does this mean you are dumber? Not necessarily. It's common for extremely intelligent children to test poorly because they are unable to gear their answers towards the test's expectations. One simple example: A child may fail to classify the picture of a "whale" as a "W" word because they know the type of whale it is (such as "Blue Whale") and aren't sophisticated enough to know that the test makes the assumption that children of a certain age won't have such specific information. A very socially savvy child may do better on such a test than a child whose interests are more "technical" (so to speak). Anecdotally, very socially savvy and socially oriented kids of high IQ often do a wonderful job of hiding how smart they are in order to fit in better. They may routinely shoot for roughly average even though they may be capable of substantially better performance than all their classmates. If no one likes you or accepts you and there is no fixing that, why bother? And if not bothering means you classify the "blue whale" as a B word instead of a W word because you feel that is more accurate and precise, your score may suffer.
- Alex3917 17y ago"It's common for extremely intelligent children to test poorly because they are unable to gear their answers towards the tests expectations." That's so weird. I distinctly remember this happening to me in third grade, but I never knew that it was an established phenomenon.
- Mz 17y agoI know that from participating on email lists for many years. I don't know how much of that type of information is in the standard literature. Tests are only a tool. The conclusions drawn from them are only as wise as the person(s) administering and interpreting them.
- tokenadult 17y agoI don't know how much of that type of information is in the standard literature. There is a HUGE standard literature on IQ testing. What email lists are you talking about? My experience after reading much of the scholarly literature on IQ testing is that most participants on email lists about IQ testing never visit academic libraries and never seem to change their default Google searching over to Google Scholar or Google Books where they might have a chance to sift through the online chaff to find some grains of careful research.
- Alex3917 17y agoThe problem is that unless you already know the name of that specific phenomenon then Google scholar is useless.
- Mz 17y agoI have no doubt that most email list participants do not read the scholarly literature. I also have no reason to believe that most "professionals" are that well versed in it. Email lists have been a source of personal stories about bright kids. Kids that are 2e may only be recognized by the school system as having handicaps and learning disabilities and never get recognized as also being very intelligent. The anecdotal evidence indicates that the brightest kids are often a poor fit for the public school system and are often not recognized as "the best and brightest" while in school. One of the most famous examples of this is that Edison's mother pulled him out of school and homeschooled him after the teacher pronounced him addle-brained.
- barry-cotter 17y agoObCryptonomicon: The scene where our code-breaking genius spends the entire time devoted to taking the Armed Forces IQ equivalent test to one question on a boat floating one way while you pass in the other direction on a train. He proceeds to attempt to account for turbulence and many, many other complex things and completely fails the test.
- barry-cotter 17y agoSo, for example, immigrants tend to do more poorly and members of an outclass tend to do more poorly (for example, historically this meant Black Americans tended to test poorly). And that's why Californian Japanese-Americans are well known for their "shifty, work-shy attitude, and tendency to drift into crime"
- Mz 17y agoThe same basic thing has been said about many immigrant groups and IQ tests were at one time used as a means to try to back up the assertion that immigrants were inherently "retarded" and thus well-suited to menial labor and should basically quit their bitchin and be grateful to have a job as a servant.
- tokenadult 17y agoCitations, please? What is the source of the spelling example you mention? That's not (DEFINITELY not) an IQ test item, although it might possibly be an achievement test item for lower age levels.
- Mz 17y agoAnecdotal story. It does not surprise me that it's not a question on an IQ test. I chose it because it is shorter than the other story I remember, which I think was from IQ testing. A child was asked who discovered America and was unable to answer the question because "America" did not exist to be discovered by Columbus. The child launched into a long, detailed history of how Columbus discovered the New World in X year but it wasn't called America until Y year after Amerigo Vespucci...etc. The story ended with the child asking "Um, what was the question again?" For a very bright child, the questions asked on various standardized tests often sound like bogus questions, kind of like the court scene in My Cousin Vinny where the prosecution tries to voir dire the witness played by Marisa Tomei and she says the question cannot be answered: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hvotE-beoaI&feature=related http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hvotE-beoaI&feature=relat...