3 ms·
That sounds like a supreme court case waiting to happen. Why should companies have the right to tell employees what they can and cannot do in their own time? W
by Someone1234 12y ago
That sounds like a supreme court case waiting to happen.
Why should companies have the right to tell employees what they can and cannot do in their own time? What next, authorisation to have a child? Your employer signing off on where you live?
- chaostheory 12y ago> Why should companies have the right to tell employees what they can and cannot do in their own time Well that's the thing. If you work with an SO, doesn't personal time and issues inevitably bleed into working hours? I talk to my SO during work hours about non-work related stuff all the time (i.e. what to eat, vacation, "I love you", ...), though we don't work for the same organization. Also I'm not sure why I'm being downvoted for asking a question.
- smt88 12y agoCompanies can (and do) have the right to tell employees what they can and cannot do in their own time, especially if it has an effect on the company. There are many examples of people being fired for inappropriate posts on social media, committing crimes (or just being accused of them), and even smoking cigarettes. There isn't a ton of precedent for the smoking thing, but it might very well be upheld by a high judge. The legal basis is that, in many states, you can be fired for almost anything except your race, age, sex, or religion.
- wfo 12y agoRight but the argument isn't that it happens, it's that it's morally reprehensible. How dare employees of a company act like human beings or have any time to themselves where they aren't wholly and completely owned and controlled by their bosses/companies? The nerve of that working class scum, it's unbelievable.
- smt88 12y agoI agree, but there are counter arguments. Any employee (especially those featured in ads) can be perceived as representing the company or even acting on behalf of the company. If you behave badly, it can reflect badly on the company. There definitely are many wrongful termination suits that test the boundaries of what companies can do here, so I think we have a pretty good balance at the moment.
- venomsnake 12y ago> Companies can (and do) have the right to tell employees what they can and cannot do in their own time, especially if it has an effect on the company. That should be made illegal IMO. A company should be forbidden to have any interest in employee outside of the strictly work related stuff.
- krylon 12y agoIn theory, yes. On the other hand, there are cases where a certain degree of interest on an employee's private life might be considered legitimate. Consider a hospital that employs a surgeon who is an alcoholic (or a meth head). Even if he/she only works when sober, alcoholism does impact both the fine motor skills and the judgment needed for such a high precision job, and many people would agree that the hospital in such a case pretty much has to either fire that surgeon or get him or her into rehab. I agree with you that in general, what I do in my free time is none of the company's business, unless it affects my ability to perform my job. But if it does, I think a company has the right to tell me to either sober up or not bother coming back to work tomorrow. Then again, this quickly becomes fuzzy and can be abused in all kinds of ways. What if a hospital, say, run by the Catholic church told a gay surgeon to remain abstinent because of the risk of contracting HIV or some other STD?
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Why should companies have the right to tell employees what they can and cannot do in their own time? Do salaried employees have well-defined "working" vs. "personal" time?