4 ms·
Third party authentication should be the norm. Leaving authentication to providers that absolutely know their shit, just like we leave payments to third party s
by scrollaway 12y ago
Third party authentication should be the norm. Leaving authentication to providers that absolutely know their shit, just like we leave payments to third party services.
Of course, that requires a decent protocol, and Mozilla is doing the world a disservice in not marketing Persona better seeing as it's the right solution....
- santosha 12y agoMajor privacy issues, single point of failure etc etc. We leave payments to third party services because nobody wants to deal with the compliance nightmare that PCI-DSS is, not for security reasons. Payment is also mostly less sensitive to availability and latency issues than authentication.
- scrollaway 12y agoSo in a world where PCI-DSS isn't a thing, you're fine entering your credit card data directly on the forms available on random websites? Why's a password so different, seeing as most people reuse those passwords? Why do we essentially allow (and yes, I am excluding those that use password managers in this statement, I'm one of those) access to our webmail and other critical services to random websites on the internet? What makes this right? > Payment is also mostly less sensitive to availability and latency issues than authentication. That's patently untrue. Latency issues are nonexistant in both areas, and availability issues are critical in both areas.
- makeitsuckless 12y agoYes, I have no problem entering my credit card data directly on the forms available on random websites. Credit card payments online are so ludicrously insecure that it baffles me it's even legal. I only use them when dealing with the US (although some of the major retailers like Apple have finally started accepting 21st century payment methods), and I simply assume my credit card info has been leaking all over the place for ages. The whole basic premise of credit cards is "we know it's totally broken, we'll just refund you the money because it's cheaper than fixing the problem".
- jasonlotito 12y ago> So in a world where PCI-DSS isn't a thing, you're fine entering your credit card data directly on the forms available on random websites? Yes. It might be a hassle should someone misuse it, but the status-quo effectively means if I didn't make the purchase I'm not responsible for it. More importantly, this was proven before PCI-DSS was a thing.
- mike_hearn 12y agoYou mean like how Authy specialised in two-factor authentication, but still managed to have basic string concatenation bugs that rendered their entire 2FA system bypassable?
- scrollaway 12y ago... no? no I don't mean like Authy.
- yellowapple 12y agoHuh? This is the first I've heard about this, and searching for "Authy concatenation bug" isn't turning up anything useful.
- drewwwwww 12y agoi believe he's referring to this: http://www.scmagazineuk.com/authy-patches-after-2fa-bypassed-in-poc-hack/article/403743/ http://www.scmagazineuk.com/authy-patches-after-2fa-bypassed...
- zaroth 12y agoHere's the write-up from Homokov. The guy is a pen-testing genius: http://sakurity.com/blog/2015/03/15/authy_bypass.html http://sakurity.com/blog/2015/03/15/authy_bypass.html But if you just want the money shot: http://sakurity.com/img/smsauthy.png http://sakurity.com/img/smsauthy.png Yes. Typing '../sms' in the field bypassed the 2nd factor. Just, wow.
- yellowapple 12y agoHuh. Well now I know. Thanks! Amazing what you can do with improperly-implemented input sanitation :) This probably could've been prevented by disallowing non-number inputs, no?
- zaroth 12y ago"In fact the root of the problem was default Sinatra dependency 'rack-protection'". They were doing the input sanitation, but it wasn't the very first thing in the processing pipeline, since "best practice" was to pipe everything through 'rack-protection' first. Homokov was first to state, this was really a black-swan type bug which 99.9% of the time makes it into production. Apparently, they were doing the "right thing" and still got burned.