3 ms·
Pikketys contribution is not his conclusion but the data that backs up the conclusion. Most people already knew what Pikkety concluded, they just didn't have e
by ThomPete 12y ago
Pikketys contribution is not his conclusion but the data that backs up the conclusion.
Most people already knew what Pikkety concluded, they just didn't have evidence for it. Now we do and until someone shows better evidence it's hard to claim Piketty is making mistakes without most probably being politically motivated to do so.
His solution on the other hand was an unnecessary but understandable addition to the book.
And I say this as a European style liberal.
- hnnewguy 12y ago>it's hard to claim Piketty making mistakes without most probably being politically motivated to do so. Precisely. The media and punditry love to emphasize that economic models didn't see this or that crash, or can't explain this or that phenomena. Yet this guy writes an incredibly well researched, deep book, and the same people pile on because his conclusions don't model reality to a tee. Economics doesn't work that way. All researchers can do is attempt to get incrementally closer to "the truth". We're going through some interesting times of awareness of wealth inequality globally, so both the "socialist" side and "capitalist" side have exaggerated his conclusions, and thus the guy can't stay out of the news.
- soneca 12y agoPlease correct the typo note for not; because this is most correct thing that can be said about Pikkety's work. His conclusions are arguable, and can even be dismissed. But the data he collected and organized can and should be taken seriously and reworked. Yes, revised, treated with different assumptions in mind. But dismiss his whole work because he might be wrong on his final politic suggestions is a disservice to the science (no matter how small amount of science there is in Economics). If you want to make Economics learn some things from hard sciences, you should take Piketty's data seriously.
- ThomPete 12y agoCorrected and thanks for the catch!
- vanderZwan 12y ago> But dismiss his whole work because he might be wrong on his final politic suggestions is a disservice to the science (no matter how small amount of science there is in Economics). Not in the least because he himself appears to be very open to criticism, as a proper scientist should be.
- slowmovintarget 12y agoUnless the data itself is suspect, which it is. http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/c9ce1a54-e281-11e3-89fd-00144feabdc0.html http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/c9ce1a54-e281-11e3-89fd-00144feabd... http://www.nytimes.com/2014/05/24/upshot/did-piketty-get-his-math-wrong.html http://www.nytimes.com/2014/05/24/upshot/did-piketty-get-his... http://www.wsj.com/articles/alan-reynolds-why-pikettys-wealth-data-are-worthless-1404945590 http://www.wsj.com/articles/alan-reynolds-why-pikettys-wealt... It's interesting to see how many people so dearly want his assertions to be true.
- ThomPete 12y agoNot at least you :) Those claims have been discussed here before and they don't change anything substantial.