3 ms·
You know, I wish I could believe that in the context of "aerospace" or "Defense Department". After working in aerospace in the mid-80s, I came to believe that c
by bediger4000 12y ago
You know, I wish I could believe that in the context of "aerospace" or "Defense Department". After working in aerospace in the mid-80s, I came to believe that certification was more about barrier-to-entry than anything else. Ever notice how the seat-belt buckles on passenger transport planes look like a 1948 design? They're certified, and it costs way too much to certify a new design or process. Sorry to be cynical, but I just don't believe the public justifications of "certified" any more.
- foobarqux 12y agoFirst, I was correcting the putative point of the audit which the grandparent erroneously claimed was a cost audit. Second, I'm sure big corporations take advantage of certification process to keep smaller players out but certification is extremely important, suppliers would not follow many of the safety requirements otherwise.
- rdtsc 12y ago> I came to believe that certification was more about barrier-to-entry than anything else Still the case with most government procurement processes. If you manage to jump through all the "certification" hoops, you can mark up your product to an insane rate and then lobby for certification to be expanded. Then the government has a list of "approved" vendors who are basically in the "certification" club and sometimes you can only find a product of a particular type only by a particular company and when you ask them for the price, your jaw drops (especially if there is a 20x cheaper COTS one on the market at the same time).
- HeyLaughingBoy 12y agoYou can add Medical to that list. Need a USB thumb drive for a Medical Device? That'll be 10x the cost of the exact same one you can buy on Amazon. OK, so maybe the vendor guarantees traceability. So now you just paid 10x the price to be safe in the knowledge that you and Amazon are buying from the same guy in a basement in Shenzen.
- dingaling 12y ago> They're certified, and it costs way too much to certify a new design or process That buckle is a standard UI across every commercial aircraft in the World. That is very important in emergency situations. Billions of people know pull-to-release. There is really no advantage to changing the design unless we also change to three-point harnesses as in cars. But that won't happen for cost reasons ( ' safety is our number one priority, profit is our zeroth' ).