4 ms·
The same thing that happens when a service or product you depend on shuts its doors or gets bought out. Why is this so exceptional? What would we do if twitte
by mc32 12y ago
The same thing that happens when a service or product you depend on shuts its doors or gets bought out.
Why is this so exceptional? What would we do if twitter folded tomorrow? things like this happen all the time. There is nothing special about it, except Wired wants to make money taking this tack.
I mean, it'd be nice if we could depend on things to be there forever and it'd be nice if companies shuttered gracefully, but it does not happen all the time.
What are they saying in essence? Don't depend on closed source services? Don't depend on non-creative commons Wired articles for your news as they may shut down one day? People make a calculus. This option is closed source, but offers this advantage. I know, as any business, they may disappear and I'm left holding the bag, but I'm willing to take that chance, given the advantages. This is also the case for open source software, but, yes, OSS has the advantage that someone with sufficient need and resources could resurrect the project.
Fine, they have a preference for open source. That's great. We could all hope all was open source but short of that, we use the tools that are available --with the understanding they could disappear tomorrow.
- saganus 12y ago> We could all hope all was open source but short of that, we use the tools that are available --with the understanding they could disappear tomorrow. And even then, open source projects get abandoned all the time or get shut down as well. So in essence we as humans would probably be better off expecting things to disappear instead of the opposite maybe? Not sure I can do that, but still, seems like a more fitting strategy.
- jasonlotito 12y ago> And even then, open source projects get abandoned all the time or get shut down as well. I can continue improving an open source project that gets abandoned.
- mc32 12y agoIn theory anyone can, but only large projects tend to get picked up.
- Frondo 12y agoBut the magic of free software is, if your business depends on it and you can hire someone to work on it, you can keep using that source code for as long as it makes business sense to.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- treve 12y agoI don't think they're saying anything in particular. The conclusions you take from it are yours.
- mc32 12y agoI think they are trying to say something, especially when they add the 'apple' part. As if apple makes this especially egregious. I know, apple is the top dog to aim for in tech now, so they are a nice whipping boy. Oooo, what happens when Oracle buys a company you depend on (Sun/ZFS). What happens when SAP buys a company you depend on. What happens when Cisco buys a company you depend on (any number of Hw companies). What happens when Amazon buys a company you depend on (robotics), what happens when a free software you depend on shuts down (TrueCrypt) Wired is just capitalizing on an anti-apple wave. I'm not an apple fan, but, it's not as if they are much worse than others. They could have just said "What happens when the products you depend on disappear?" But that's not sexy. It also does not fit their "narrative".
- rsync 12y ago"I mean, it'd be nice if we could depend on things to be there forever" When I read that, I immediately thought of craigslist, for some reason.
- nickysielicki 12y ago> Why is this so exceptional? Because code isn't a good that spoils. When someone shuts their door to my favorite restaurant, the presumption is that they were losing money, and needed to close the doors. When my favorite SaaS service shuts down, it's the same deal. This is different. They're just being selfish because they got some money, giving the middle finger to everyone. That same code is still sitting in a git repo somewhere, and that's frustrating as hell to anyone that trusted them. It would be no sweat off their backs to at least scale down support over a year to let people transition. But let's not place the blame on them. It's probably not their choice to fuck over all of their users. I guarantee this is coming from Apple, and you should all remember that when you line up to buy this new fancy 1 port macbook: Fuck Apple, they don't give a shit about open source. They're embrace/extend/extinguish just as Microsoft. They just operate on Unix so it feels like they give us more. It's okay though. Someone inside will realize they're sitting on a goldmine of information on how to make good software, they'll leave the hellish work environment that is Apple, write an open source version, and it will be superior. >We could all hope all was open source but short of that, we use the tools that are available --with the understanding they could disappear tomorrow. There is no "short of that". Demand open source for everything you do. It's not unreasonable. The modern computer ecosystem IS open source. You are very much overstating the similarities from open source developers disappearing and a closed source software company leaving you up to dry. One can live on, and one has no hope.
- dlu 12y agoAngry much? You lost me with the "code isn't a good that spoils" line. It is a great phrase, but perhaps you could re-explain?
- jsprogrammer 12y agoA restaurant requires continuous inputs: fresh food, labor, electricity. Code is a purely digital good. What was in the repo a few days ago could be released at no ongoing cost to FoundationDB/Apple and it will stay exactly how it was, forever.
- 12y ago
- sliverstorm 12y agoAt least you usually have runway. If your favorite OSS project closes its doors, you probably have a year or three until bitrot finally closes the doors. Same goes for many closed-source softwares, and physical products. With a closed-source service on somebody else's servers, they can turn it off tomorrow and it's just gone.
- logicallee 12y ago>Why is this so exceptional? What would we do if twitter folded tomorrow? things like this happen all the time. obviously you're not an actuary but lay some odds that twitter folds tomorrow. (literally; overnight.)