9 ms·
While your points are valid and I personally don't like the inefficiencies, the challenge is that credit card companies are good at hiding these details from co
by dottrap 12y ago
While your points are valid and I personally don't like the inefficiencies, the challenge is that credit card companies are good at hiding these details from consumers.
1) Rules are in place so merchants can't markup products when using a credit card so the standard displayed price already includes the markup and cash paying customers are typically not rewarded.
2) An annoyance for customers, but it is mostly the credit card companies on the hook. The credit card companies know this but calculated the money lost to fraud is still outweighed by consumer convenience. Also, we are seeing things like Apple Pay starting to address the credit card number.
3) But there is an advantage to people who do know how to stay within a budget and not overspend. First, if money is stolen or their is a dispute, then the credit card issuer is on the hook and they have a strong incentive to resolve the issue quickly and fairly. When money is taken from your bank account as in a debit and there is a problem, you may have liquidity problems as you wait for this to be resolved. Liquidity problems can cause huge problems for people.
4) Yes, they are inefficient, but banks deal with this (mostly), generally not consumers (unless you are talking about ACH or wire transfers). (The exception is 'what credit cards do you accept here' if the answer isn't all of them.)
5) Yes, though since currencies fluctuate, it is kind of a messy problem and credit cards at least made it convenient.
Bonus) I'll also add that credit cards have both reward incentives and protection policies, which most people seem to forget about. (I usually have to remind people that if they used a credit card to purchase a computer and it broke just out of warranty, they probably have an extra year of extended warranty through their credit card.) And people seem to go crazy for frequent flier miles and such rewards, even though it may not be totally cost effective in the end.
- smt88 12y ago> I'll also add that credit cards have both reward incentives and protection policies My most-used card (American Express Blue Cash Preferred) gives me 6% back on groceries and 3% back on gas. It also has tons of purchase protection and insurance benefits. So not only do I not care what merchants have to pay to accept my card, AmEx is paying me lots of money every year to use their card. Those are some high hurdles to get over.
- jedmeyers 12y agoAnd those "groceries" might as well be Amazon gift cards purchased in a grocery store.
- dottrap 12y agoOne more thought on the "one currency" issue. At least in the US, legal tender (monopoly) laws punish anything used that isn't dollar based. You are required to accurately report capital gains you acquired from currency value fluctuations. This is an IRS/accounting nightmare for most people, hence multiple currencies are avoided by most people.
- toomuchtodo 12y ago> Rules are in place so merchants can't markup products when using a credit card so the standard displayed price already includes the markup and cash paying customers are typically not rewarded. This is no longer true. The Dodd-Frank Reform Act now allows merchants to charge a surcharge for using a credit card.
- dottrap 12y agoState laws still trump that. Credit card surcharges are prohibited in California, Colorado, Connecticut, Florida, Kansas, Maine, Massachusetts, New York, Oklahoma and Texas. Thus in those states, the markup will be added/absorbed into normal price and you will pay the credit card markup whether you use a credit card or not. (Some states may still allow explicit cash discounts, but very few merchants use that.)
- toomuchtodo 12y agoWell that's disappointing. A merchant should never have to absorb those costs.