3 ms·
tl;dr: Interesting summary of the issues. Not much actionable at the end.
by JoeAltmaier 12y ago
tl;dr: Interesting summary of the issues. Not much actionable at the end.
- toothbrush 12y agoThe author does suggest tracking data. This seems like a good idea: when people get what promotions and raises, etc. This is to counterbalance our tendency to see what our bias wants us to see.
- alwaysdoit 12y agoI can see how this would work for larger minorities, but it doesn't seem to scale (down): the smaller a minority, the higher variance you will see in your data. I'm not sure it helps at all when you get down to the point where you have only a single member of a group in your population.
- proksoup 12y agoI think the actionable is get more people to read about the issues and the specifics of the issues. I'd rather have an author take the actionable instead of giving me one. Yay author!
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoYeah I'm not of fan of 'awareness' as a social mechanism. Its more of 'look at us; we're on the right side of this issue!' but doesn't move anything forward.
- proksoup 12y agoI find that difficult to understand. From my perspective the root cause of every problem is a lack of information and lack of awareness .... a plan of action can come only after that, and will on it's own.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoSo educate yourself, then ACT. Instead, folks have fairs and mailings and talks and races, spreading awareness, spending money. And then what? Mostly nothing.
- proksoup 12y agoThe culture doesn't change overnight, the long haul of changing the boundaries of the conversation can only be achieved through conversation. There are people you need to convince Joe, and you can't get them to take action until they enter the conversation as well. Not enough people are aware of the conversation or its boundaries to act yet, once they are, the action will have happened already. Your words make me think you think an individual can accomplish something without the group. That stupid people will always be stupid so educating them is pointless, some other "action" aside from education must occur. I worry you've given up hope on education and with no "action" to take you dismiss those who attempt to educate. I didn't hear the action you proposed, just that it must be an action and "awareness" and "education" is a lost cause before we've begun.
- proksoup 12y agoIf the problem is stated sufficiently and completely enough, we can talk about solutions. Without the awareness and the context, a "action item" is worse than "I'm right" it's "I'm right and do what I say" instead of "No one's right, here's the problems, can we discuss?"