5 ms·
Calling this an "accident" is entirely too kind to Comcast. They're happy to claim they'll serve almost anything within particular geographic areas, whether or
by eropple 12y ago
Calling this an "accident" is entirely too kind to Comcast. They're happy to claim they'll serve almost anything within particular geographic areas, whether or not they can or will.
(He mentioned DSL providers, too, which are their own brand of fun.)
- mikeash 12y agoOnce I was getting fed up with Comcast, so I called Verizon to see if they could give me DSL, how fast it would be, etc. Their response was basically that they had no idea, but they could put in an order and see what happened. They literally could not tell me whether or not they could provide the service at all.
- 300bps 12y agoThey literally could not tell me whether or not they could provide the service at all. As silly and frustrating as that is, "I don't know" is a much better answer than, "Yes, absolutely" that turns out to be false. "I don't know" would've saved OP tens of thousands of dollars that he will soon be paying to sell a house he just purchased.
- mikeash 12y agoOh yes, you're totally right. Just illustrating another small way these companies can be ridiculous.
- rayiner 12y agoTo be fair, how is the tech really supposed to know? Serviceability is a complicated question. There's engineering issues (how far from existing plant is the address?); there's legal issues (is servicing the address required under a franchise agreement?); there's logistical issues (is this a subdivision where the HOA won't let us dig up; is it a multi-dwelling unit where the property manager won't let us run wire)? It's not like houses are built in a structured, systematic manner. In most of the country, property developers just put up subdivisions at random. You're right though, "we don't know" is the right answer.
- mikeash 12y agoI'm not sure I understand your point. How are they supposed to know, outside of taking the appropriate actions that would allow them to know? Well, take those actions. Sure, it could be a hard question to answer. It's also a question whose answer is part of their core business. If they can't obtain the answer somehow, why do they even exist? I'd have been fine with "Because of X, Y, or Z, I have to pass this off to department Q and they'll get back to you in a day or two." But that's not what they said. Edit: I should clarify that the local wiring was all in place. Verizon phone service was available (and I had had it at one point, although not at the time of the call). Nothing needed digging or drilling or any sort of wire running at all.
- rayiner 12y agoMy point is that the data isn't sitting in a database the phone tech can look up. Putting in a service order is how it gets to the people that can answer the question.
- mikeash 12y agoAnd my point is that if they can't simply answer the question as given (even if it takes work) then the company as a whole is completely and utterly incompetent. If you're saying that they must put in a service order to get an answer to the question, you're merely describing specifics of the incompetence.
- res0nat0r 12y agoHuh? All of the specifics he mentioned above aren't just magically sitting somewhere in a simple database query. Your question needs to be handed off to someone so they can specifically research your situation and get back to you with the results. It sounds like specifically in your case, their system allows the techs who take new cable signups to enter your data in the system, and then it will return weather your house is serviceable, not serviceable, and with what type of service options are available if you can in fact sign up. Doesn't sound like a very strenuous process from the customer side.
- jolan 12y agoAt least they were honest instead of guessing. AT&T has a database of the line rate/quality that the last person who had service was able to achieve. That doesn't mean it's accurate though. Quality can have gone down due to rotted shielding, new sources of interference, etc.